The best bakeries & sweet shops in Fort Myers

“Ice cream chain offering design-your-own creations hand-mixed on a granite slab, plus shakes & more.”

“Freshly hand-rolled and baked, Wetzel's Pretzels nails that sweet-or-salty craving, plus pretzel dogs and real-deal lemonade that just hits in our humidity. They also cater parties and teams, and the Rewards program makes your snack habit feel responsible... almost.”

From the Lehigh Acres newsletter, September 17, 2026

“Atlixco Foods of Lehigh Acres is the go-to when taco night needs to go pro, with daily-made corn and flour tortillas, custom-cut meats, and a bakery cranking out pan dulce, tacos, gorditas, and tortas. Grab aguas frescas, fresh produce, and Latin groceries, or order for parties and quinceañeras.”

From the Lehigh Acres newsletter, September 7, 2026

“From creamy helados to house-made paletas, fruit cups and those craveable botanas, Tohui Ice Cream nails the Mexican-snack run locals actually want. They have micheladas if you lean savory, and a fun backstory named after a famous panda, with family vibes since 2013 in Lehigh Acres.”

From the Lehigh Acres newsletter, September 21, 2026

“When you want something a little fancy without being fussy, Gutierrez Sweet Macarons LLC delivers those crisp-shelled, chewy-centered bites of happiness that pair perfectly with coffee, birthdays, or a Tuesday around Lehigh Acres. Local, sweet, and just the right size to make your day less ordinary.”

From the Lehigh Acres newsletter, September 5, 2026

“LadyCakes Bakery turns life’s sweet moments into edible art, from elegant wedding showstoppers to 3D cakes, cupcakes, and cookies that actually taste as good as they look. Swing by for their daily specials and exclusive creations, or order online when a celebration sneaks up and you need a hero in buttercream.”

From the Cape Coral newsletter, August 3, 2026

“Best Ice Cream "Under The Sea Experience" and Mermaid Room Cafe spins liquid nitrogen ice cream while you watch, then lets you invent any flavor you can imagine. Treat yourself to a Dream Cloud or Dream Burrito, cotton candy bowls stacked with gummies, sprinkles, and edible glitter.”

From the Fort Myers newsletter, September 17, 2026

“Forgot the birthday is, like, today? Tamu Cupcakery has same day cakes in-store and a wild lineup of cupcakes with over 80 flavors, including vegan, gluten-free, and even booze-infused options, so treat yourself this week or bribe the office.”

From the Cape Coral newsletter, August 11, 2026

“Italian shop, deli and bakery selling cannolis, cookies and pies, plus pasta, meats and sandwiches.”

“Cupcakes, cookies, mini-cakes and more are available at this bakery for take-out and delivery.”

“BB's Unique Cupcake Boutique and Custom Cakes is an online custom bakery known for unique cupcake bouquets and artistically crafted cakes. Show them a cake you found or describe your idea, and they'll match it beautifully, delivering that wow factor that actually tastes as good as it looks.”

From the Cape Coral newsletter, August 15, 2026

“For a midweek treat or weekend reset, Bread Pete is a German bakery turning out fresh daily loaves, flaky croissants, legit pretzels, and a lighter, tangy German cheesecake made with old world recipes.”

From the Cape Coral newsletter, August 22, 2026

“EA Bake Brunch & Bakery has been keeping Lehigh Acres fed for 48 years with fresh breakfasts, brunchy comfort, and a bakery case that makes willpower optional. They also handle catering for everything from work meetings to family parties, so this week you can skip cooking and just enjoy the pastry glow.”

From the Lehigh Acres newsletter, August 18, 2026

“Traditional store selling chocolates, confections & fudge, as well as original recipe ice cream.”

“Retailer offering a huge selection of candy & bottled sodas in innovative flavors.”

“At Maddie's Artisanal Bakery right here in Cape Coral, neighborhood spot meets dessert bar, serving scratch-made small-batch treats from flaky viennoiserie and weekly surprises like éclairs or kolaches to crusty sourdough and soft focaccia.”

From the Cape Coral newsletter, September 1, 2026

“From flaky croissants and decadent cinnamon rolls to raclette stacked sandwiches and luxe bruschettas, Sour & Dough Artisan Bakery brings French-inspired sourdough that actually tastes like it had a passport. Pair it with specialty coffee brewed from Colombian beans this week, then call it your midweek upgrade.”

From the Fort Myers newsletter, August 10, 2026

“Whether you need a same-day cookie fix or a thoughtfully curated gift basket loaded with local goodies, Sweet Real comes through with homemade treats that taste like someone actually cares. Favorites like the lemon sandwich cookie and the chocolate PB&J bomb keep showing up in Cape Coral cravings.”

From the Cape Coral newsletter, September 8, 2026

“Craving something beyond supermarket sugar? Mayuli’s Bakery, right here in Cape Coral, turns out handmade Cuban treats that taste like they came straight from abuela’s kitchen, from flaky pastelitos orientales stuffed with guava to fully customizable cakes with fillings like coconut, dulce de leche, or Ferrero...”

From the Cape Coral newsletter, September 16, 2026

“From the Signature Collection bon bons to build-your-own gift boxes, Norman Love Confections nails the thoughtful, luxurious stuff when you want to wow someone or just yourself.”

From the Fort Myers newsletter, September 6, 2026

“When the midweek slump hits, Pão De Minas Bakery delivers Brazilian comfort with fresh pão de queijo, flaky pastries, and breakfast sandwiches. Stock up on sweets to make your next get-together actually delicious, or just treat yourself because you deserve it.”

From the Cape Coral newsletter, August 26, 2026

“Esmeralda Cuban Bakery hits the spot this week with cafe con leche, flaky guava pastries, warm croquetas, and Cuban sandwiches, plus comfort plates like roasted pork with black beans. Grab a loaf of fresh Cuban bread and a slice of flan, then thank us later.”

From the Lehigh Acres newsletter, September 12, 2026

“One More Bite Organic Desserts is the rare bakery that’s 100% peanut-free, soy- and corn-free, yet still fully indulgent. Think fudgy organic brownies, brookie magic, and coconut macaroons, all small-batch and individually wrapped to prevent cross-contamination.”

From the Fort Myers newsletter, September 7, 2026

“Rize Craft Coffee and Patisserie is the kind of nearby spot where buttery, flaky pastries meet properly crafted coffee, perfect for powering through errands or treating yourself after a long week. Swing by this week for fresh bakes, smooth sips, and that quiet moment you keep promising yourself.”

From the Fort Myers newsletter, August 26, 2026

“Need an easy win for the next get-together? Herrera's Cakes y Antojitos Hondureños delivers fresh Honduran bread, super-crispy plantain chips, and a lineup of classics like baleadas, pastelitos, and carne asada, plus customizable catering and pastries that make Lehigh Acres gatherings feel like a family feast.”

From the Lee Island Coast newsletter, August 14, 2026

“When you need fuel mid flea market, R & L Delicious Bakery turns the stroll into a victory lap with fresh cakes, flaky empanadas, and other fresh-baked treats. A quick bite that satisfies both sweet and savory cravings, made by folks who clearly love baking.”

From the Fort Myers newsletter, September 2, 2026