Sarasota’s home decor scene is the perfect mix of coastal charm and eclectic surprises—there’s something for every style, budget, and room that needs a little refresh. Whether you’re on the hunt for vintage finds, custom handcrafted pieces, or just a colorful accent to liven up your space, this city has more hidden gems than you might expect.
Let’s get to it.
Garden Argosy
Garden Argosy on St. Armand’s Circle feels like whimsy come to life. This bright, laid-back shop has been family-owned since 1996 and specializes in beachy bits mixed with boho charm. You’ll find artsy dinnerware, sassy picture frames, baby onesies sized for adults, and locally made jewelry that fits every budget.
They’re big on Sarasota-area makers, so you’ll discover unique treasures you won’t spot everywhere. Seasonal displays pop up regularly, tempting you to rethink your “just browsing” mindset. Staffers are friendly and more than happy to help you pick gifts or become your unofficial personal shoppers.
Whether you stop in for a small souvenir or decide to splurge on a bold piece of wall art or cologne, Garden Argosy makes shopping feel like chatting with a friend. You might just walk out with something fun for yourself too.
Leather Gallery and Bedding Center
When you visit Leather Gallery and Bedding Center, you’ll get a taste of clean, modern style that’s way comfier than what you see on design blogs. Their two strip-mall showrooms (S. Tamiami Trail in Sarasota and one near The Villages) feel right at home but are packed with well-arranged displays.
On one side you’ll spot Tempur-Pedic and Sealy mattresses. On the other, rows of leather sofas set up like everyday living rooms that make your old couch seem dull. They carry top Scandinavian names like Ekornes/Stressless and Fjords, plus recliners, sectionals, and power lift chairs that often hit $500 to $1,000 off during clearance events.
Family-owned since 2009, the staff won’t shadow you with clipboards. They keep it relaxed and even offer a Platinum Lifetime Warranty on most seating, so you can commit without second-guessing.
Sarasota Architectural Salvage
If salvaged treasures are your jam, Sarasota Architectural Salvage is your jackpot. Their 10,000-square-foot warehouse on Central Avenue is like a creative maze: one aisle of cypress lumber, another stacked with reclaimed hardware, and a few steps later you’re face-to-face with a ten-foot iron fountain.
They go beyond raw salvage with custom upcycled pieces—from full-blown kitchen islands in real wood to sculptural accents you won’t find anywhere else. Some items are weekend-DIY friendly, while others sit firmly in “conversation piece” territory.
Stock rotates all the time, so every visit feels new. You might go in hunting for a door knob and walk out hauling a clawfoot tub or at least talking about nearly doing it. It’s a spot where history, creativity, and budget-friendly finds collide.
DutchCrafters Amish Furniture
If you’re in the market for solid, American-made furniture, DutchCrafters Amish Furniture has you covered. Nestled on Lockwood Ridge, it’s easy to park and just far enough from the highway to feel relaxed. For over twenty years, Jim and Linse Miller have grown their living-room dream into a suburban showroom full of handcrafted kitchens, bedrooms, living rooms, and outdoor patios…complete with poly chairs that look tough enough to weather a storm.
Skip scrolling through endless online catalogs and actually test a sofa in person. Their Design Center is packed with wood and fabric samples, and shopping here really is kind of fun—you can grab a coffee or a glass of wine at Sip & Shop Saturdays, and well-behaved dogs are always welcome. Prices lean heirloom-quality rather than college-budget cheap, but floor-model and outlet deals can surprise you. Their team will walk you through every detail—whether you drop by, meet virtually, or have them come to your home. Custom orders? That’s just another day at DutchCrafters.
Baer’s Furniture Co. Inc.
Cruising down Clark Road in Sarasota, you can’t miss Baer’s Furniture Co. Inc. Their huge suburban showroom is one of fifteen locations across Florida, and it feels anything but generic. You’ll find styles from tropical and coastal to traditional, leather, and modern. It’s more than couches and beds—think full living-room and dining setups, outdoor patios, plus window treatments and home accents that always manage to catch your eye.
Prices are friendly for those who want quality without a mortgage-level splurge, and the floor features brands like Tommy Bahama Home, Lexington, and Paula Deen Home. Whether you need help picking paint, wallpaper, rugs, or custom drapes, Baer’s free design service has your back. You can get that designer touch in-store or have them come to you. It’s straightforward, local, and geared toward real people who just want their homes to look and feel a whole lot better.
The Exchange Inc.
For a real treasure-hunt vibe, check out The Exchange Inc. This 15,000 square-foot consignment spot in Sarasota mixes snazzy vintage Persian rugs, Tiffany silver, boho throw blankets, and high-end designer finds. It never feels like your grandma’s attic—each section is styled into little vignettes that make it easy to see how pieces could work in your space.
Inventory changes constantly, so every visit brings something new. You can score unique furniture, décor, or even crystal without breaking the bank. Best of all, it’s volunteer-run and proceeds go back into local arts grants and scholarships. If you love hunting for one-of-a-kind deals and supporting community creativity, The Exchange delivers. You might stop in for a mirror or a rug and end up leaving with a handful of pillows.
Decor Direct Wholesale Warehouse
Decor Direct Wholesale Warehouse has a unique blend of antique shop finds, lumberyard stock, and salvage yard treasures all under one roof. This family-owned operation has run its own workshop for over 25 years. It’s set in a 30,000 square-foot warehouse just five minutes from the Sarasota-Bradenton airport, so you know it’s massive and worth the trip.
You’ll find sustainable live-edge wood slabs that reach up to sixteen or eighteen feet, reclaimed barnwood, global antiques, and a variety of rustic, coastal, modern farmhouse, or steampunk pieces. Craftsmen work on custom dining tables and outdoor setups right in the warehouse. Lots of people stop by for big statement pieces that you can’t fit in a typical car. They’ll even help load items if you’re renting a van or using a trailer. Interior designers and restaurant owners shop here, but you’ll never feel out of place if you’re just browsing for wall art or a unique lamp.
Prices are mid to high, but they run seasonal sales that can save you a bundle. Public hours are Thursday through Sunday, so plan ahead and avoid showing up to locked doors.
CITY Furniture
Step into CITY Furniture’s 120,000-square-foot Sarasota showroom and you’ll see why they’ve been around since the ’70s. They started with waterbeds and now cover modern, transitional, and coastal styles across living rooms, dining areas, and bedrooms.
Prices land in that sweet spot where most people can afford polished, on-trend pieces. You’ll find everything from basic upholstered sofas to designer imports that turn heads without turning wallets inside out.
In the middle of it all is the KC Café & Wine Bar (plus a Starbucks), so you can sip a latte or even a glass of pinot while hunting for that perfect throw pillow. Don’t skip the City Marketplace—aisles of mirrors, lamps, art, pillows, and live plants turn redecorating into a playground. Free design consults, open galleries, Tesla charging stations, and escalators round out the one-stop-shop experience.
Ethan Allen
At Ethan Allen, craftsmanship has ruled since 1932. Their Sarasota Design Center is laid out like a series of mini show homes, each featuring custom sofas you can tweak, tables that balance fancy and friendly, and a hefty fabric and leather library that challenges even the most decisive shopper.
Prices run on the upscale side—think quality that outlasts trends and most phone contracts. A good chunk of their collection is made in North America, with a classic colonial flair that mixes effortlessly with modern accents. You’ll see indoor and outdoor furniture, rugs, lighting, and window treatments all under one roof.
The real draw is the complimentary design service. Whether you need 3D mockups or expert advice on which throw pillow won’t clash, their team is ready to help. High-end doesn’t have to feel intimidating here—just leave your bargain-hunter hat at home.
Kane’s Furniture – Sarasota
Strolling up North Washington Blvd. brings you to Kane’s Furniture – Sarasota, a family-owned spot since 1948. It’s rare for a Florida store to stay independent this long, and Kane’s still feels like the neighborhood’s go-to furniture source. Whether you’re into modern farmhouse, classic grandma chic, or a more transitional vibe, you’ll find it in their expansive room setups.
Sofas start around six hundred dollars, and accent pieces can run less than your last electric bill. They often offer 48-month interest-free financing if you want to spread out payments. You can shop in-store, online, or even preview items in your own room through their home-visualizer tool. Kane’s backs every sale with a price guarantee, loyalty perks, and genuine customer service. No corporate games—just a Florida classic taking care of regular folks.
HomeGoods
At the HomeGoods in Village Plaza Shopping Center on Bee Ridge Road, you’ll find a true bargain playground. With the same treasure-hunt energy as any of their 900+ stores, it’s easy to wander in looking for a throw pillow and leave with a velvet pouf, a frying pan, two lanterns, and maybe a Christmas gnome. Aisles shift regularly, showcasing cozy farmhouse blankets, boho planters, kitchenware, and patio accents.
It’s organized chaos meets warehouse vibes—midst open zones you’ll spot little staged areas that spark ideas. They run seasonal sections, so you might find spooky skeletons one week and Santas the next. Prices are usually 20–50% below department store tags, making it feel like you scored something special. If you love finding deals and don’t mind poking around a bit, HomeGoods is both hilarious and dangerously addictive.
The Furniture Warehouse
For budget-friendly furniture on the Gulf Coast, The Furniture Warehouse is your spot. This family-run chain started in 1988 with the Richmond family and now includes six warehouse showrooms stretching from Ellenton down to Port Charlotte.
Each store has more than 20,000 square feet of open aisles filled with furniture. You’ll find classic traditional sets, coastal-inspired pieces that fit Florida living, and modern accents to keep things interesting. The mattress section covers just about every brand you’ve heard on local radio. Each location offers ample parking, which makes loading purchases straightforward.
Prices stay low thanks to regular sales and warehouse discounts. Staff here focus on a friendly, laid-back shopping experience so there’s no heavy sales pressure. They update stock regularly, so you’ll often spot new arrivals.
They offer delivery, assembly, and even lease-to-own plans for added flexibility. Whether you need a new couch, a bedroom set, or just a few accent pieces, The Furniture Warehouse makes it easy to update your space without breaking the bank.
