In Sarasota, refined consignment boutiques and curated resale showrooms make it easy to elevate your wardrobe and home while spending wisely. Expect designer labels, fine jewelry, and quality furnishings, plus straightforward consignment options and pleasant, unhurried shopping.
Let’s get to it.
Loved Again Boutique
Think boutique polish without the boutique sticker shock. Loved Again Boutique zeroes in on women’s designer clothing, handbags, shoes, and jewelry, curated so tightly that only clean, excellent-condition pieces make the racks.
The space feels calm and tidy, with merch arranged by style and season for easy browsing. Owner Judy brings decades of retail savvy, which shows in the edit: wearable, current, and label-forward rather than high-volume castoffs.
New arrivals roll in often, so the treasure-hunt factor is real. This is not a bargain-bin thrift. You might find a standout handbag one week and, the next, a bit of one-of-a-kind wearable art or a well-chosen vintage piece. Prices sit in the mid-to-high range, but far lower than buying these designers new.
Service leans personal and style-minded, the kind that helps you refine rather than overwhelm. The shop sits in a south Sarasota plaza with easy parking, making quick pop-ins painless.
For sellers, consignors speak highly of organized payouts and clear communication. In short, Loved Again suits shoppers who prize quality and design over sheer quantity, and anyone who enjoys a polished boutique experience with smarter price tags than retail.
The Blue Heirloom Vintage
At The Blue Heirloom Vintage, the thrill is the mix: more than a dozen independent vendors curated under one cool roof, so your budget and your taste both get options. The space tops 3,000 square feet, air conditioned and laid out like a treasure hunt, with small vignettes that pull you in and bigger zones for furniture.
Expect a thoughtful blend of mid-century finds and one-off designer pieces alongside everyday vintage. Racks of clothing, jewelry and shoes sit near home decor, art and collectibles. Music lovers get vinyl, instruments and memorabilia, which adds a fun, nostalgic thread.
Prices run the spectrum. You can snag an affordable accent or invest in a standout piece without feeling pressured. With new arrivals rolling in frequently, return visits actually pay off.
Staff keep it friendly and tidy, and the overall vibe leans artsy without the attitude. Located near downtown Sarasota, pairing a browse with lunch is easy.
If you have goods of your own, they operate as a multi-vendor marketplace with booth options, and terms vary, so call ahead to ask about rental versus traditional consignment.
Beautiful You Boutique
Curated runway pieces meet neighborhood warmth at Beautiful You Boutique. On Hillview Street, this owner-led spot leans upscale, and the team knows their labels.
Shop designer and contemporary clothing for women, with a tidy men’s edit. Authenticated luxury handbags headline, flanked by shoes, jewelry, sunglasses, belts, and polished accessories. Occasional vintage and small gift items appear, all merchandised like a petite gallery.
Pricing sits mid to high, fitting the condition and curation. Expect real savings on quality, not thrift-bin steals. Layaway helps with splurges, and they can ship if you are not local.
New arrivals land often, so coveted pieces move fast. Seasonal rotations and periodic sale days keep the hunt lively. Staff are attentive and genuinely helpful without hovering.
Consigning is straightforward. Drop-offs by appointment, in-house pricing, and a MyResaleWeb portal to track items and sales. Payouts typically run store credit or check, so confirm percentages at intake. Ideal for shoppers who want designer labels and polished service; skip it if rock-bottom is the only goal.
PEL Consignments, Inc.
PEL Consignments blends estate-sale savvy with decorator-ready finds, and the nonprofit mission sweetens the deal. Purchases support youth programs, which adds heart to the hunt.
The 9,400 square foot showroom reads like a well staged home. Furniture for living and patio, rugs, artwork, lighting, fine crystal and china, plus everyday dishes and small appliances. Jewelry, purses, a touch of vintage clothing, and occasional collectibles keep things lively.
Prices skew mid to higher end, drawing decorators and home stagers who want quality without full retail. You will find the odd bargain, but this is not bottom-dollar thrift. New inventory arrives weekly, and in-store shoppers get first crack. The online catalog typically trails by about a week.
On the consignment side, they handle single standout pieces and full estate lots with white glove service. Consignments and donations are welcome. Some intakes carry a $1,000 minimum, and payout terms are case by case, so a quick call or email gets the specifics.
Along the Lime Avenue corridor, the warehouse-style space is easy to navigate, with staged vignettes that make browsing simple. Parking is straightforward, and staff include estate specialists and knowledgeable volunteers, a smart stop for upgrading a room or outfitting a short-term rental.
The Exchange Inc.
Shopping that funds the arts? The Exchange makes that proposition irresistible. Decades of community giving power this nonprofit, and every consigned piece helps seed local grants and scholarships.
In downtown Sarasota, it spans about 15,000 square feet yet feels thoughtfully staged. Volunteers keep the multi-room floor moving, so the assortment turns over quickly and the hunt stays fresh.
Expect fine jewelry, designer handbags, Baccarat crystal, Tiffany silver, polished apparel, Persian rugs, furniture, and standout vintage. Intake is selective, with photo pre-approval on furniture and updated rules for framed art, which keeps quality high and surprises delightful.
Prefer to consign? Contracts are straightforward, with a Silver 60/40 split that pays you 60 percent while fueling the mission. Pricing follows a cadence, full price for three weeks, then reductions, with deeper cuts after six weeks. By day 60, unclaimed items become store property. Monthly checks are mailed, and the team can coordinate furniture pickup and delivery through a third party. Browse the online catalog, then pick up in person.
Best for design lovers who crave a refined treasure hunt and value with purpose.
Laura Jean’s
Labels you recognize, prices you will actually like. Laura Jean’s proves that smart luxury can be easy on the wallet, with no rummage feel. A long-established, well-reviewed local favorite.
Racks are tidy and curated, a boutique-sized space where sizes 00 through 26 share room with current boutique pieces. Expect designer shoes, handbags, jeans, jewelry, scarves, belts, even sunglasses. New arrivals hit the floor daily, so the treasure-hunt thrill is real, but browsing stays calm.
The quality bar is high. Items are accepted only when like-new, freshly laundered, and in-season, which keeps everything looking current. Pricing typically lands at a third to a quarter of original retail, and every so often an occasional tags-on gem appears. Staff are friendly and clued-in on labels and fit, a change from big-box guessing.
Thinking of consigning? Drop-offs are taken Monday to Saturday, no appointment. The split is a straightforward 50/50 for a 30-day run, and you can reclaim or donate anything that does not sell. Seasonal rotation is enforced, which shoppers appreciate. The shop sits in a convenient plaza near Sarasota’s main shopping corridor, and their website and newsletter make it easy to track specials and Girls Night Out style events.
Fine Home Consignments
Chandeliers that actually sparkle, rugs with pedigree, and case goods that feel solid when you tug a drawer. Fine Home Consignments delivers that rare mix of high-end taste and secondhand sanity, all in a calm, showroom setting along the North Trail.
The mix is broad yet selective, from seating and dining suites to bedroom and office pieces, mirrors, art, and outdoor furniture, plus crystal, sterling, fine china, and estate or designer jewelry. Condition matters here. They curate for style and lasting value, so you will see clean upholstery, intact finishes, no chips or wobbles. Prices lean upscale rather than thrift, and new finds land often, with a few collectibles popping up on Etsy or Chairish.
Shopping feels easy. Neat, well lit vignettes turn the hunt into a pleasant stroll, whether you need a statement chandelier, a pair of lamps, or a quietly beautiful dining table that will outlive trends. Ideal for buyers who want designer caliber without paying showroom prices.
Selling is equally clear. The standard arrangement runs about 90 days with proceeds split roughly 50/50 and checks issued around the 15th after a sale. Acceptance depends on condition, resale potential, and floor space. In some cases they buy outright and even handle the move. Turnover is steady, so act quickly.
Good As New Consignment
A bridal budget can breathe a little easier here. Good As New leans into pre-owned, and a few new, gowns, bridesmaid looks, formalwear, plus tuxedo rentals. Beyond the veils, this independent boutique mixes consignment and retail for everyday life, with men’s and women’s racks beside children’s pieces, accessories, toys, housewares, and the occasional small furniture item.
Selective intake keeps quality high, and the floor reads clean, organized, and calm. Prices land mid-range to budget friendly, with the odd designer score. New arrivals roll in often, so timing matters, and the treasure hunt rewards a focused search more than a quick scan.
Ready to consign? The shop is choosy, and terms can change, so call for the current agreement. Shoppers should also verify the latest location and hours, since multiple listings circulate online. The website helps, though the public catalog is limited.
Bottom line, this is for brides and families who want value with polish. If the goal is a gorgeous gown minus the sticker shock, plus a few well-kept extras for home, Good As New belongs on your shortlist.
Designing Women Boutique
Champagne taste meets good conscience here. Designing Women Boutique pairs designer resale with real community impact, helping channel meaningful support to Sarasota arts and human-service organizations.
Inside, it feels more gallery than thrift. Curated racks of couture and evening wear mingle with designer shoes, jewelry, and handbags, while fine art and estate decor set a quietly luxe backdrop. Everything is selective and well kept, so browsing stays calm rather than chaotic.
Prices sit in the mid to high range, yet the markdowns from retail are meaningful. Inventory turns quickly, fresh labels appear often, and seasonal sale rooms or event days deliver that treasure-hunt thrill without the clutter.
Consigning is straightforward and fair, with a historically generous split around 50/50 and tidy account tracking. Donations are welcomed. For anyone handling a downsizing or estate, the concierge team can manage the process from intake to sale, with options that may include direct purchase.
Set along North Tamiami Trail with easy parking, the boutique footprint rewards a lingering stroll. Staff include both volunteers and seasoned pros, so expertise is strong, though service can vary by day. Choose this stop when quality, curation, and philanthropy matter just as much as the label.
