From pampered poodles to rare reptiles, Sarasota’s pet stores cater to every kind of animal in style. Whether you’re searching for wholesome food, unique toys, or a boutique grooming experience, the city’s shops have everything you need to keep your pets happy and healthy.
Let’s get to it.
Bayside Great Danes
At Bayside Great Danes, you’ll discover a comprehensive selection of pet supplies under one roof. They carry premium dog food, elevated beds that blend durability with style, and every grooming essential from brushes to nail trimmers. Cat owners can choose from high-quality kibble, specialty litters, and toys designed for batting and chasing. Stylish collars and leashes are available too, so your furry friend can stand out during neighborhood strolls.
Bird enthusiasts will find a variety of seed blends, sturdy cages, perches, and enrichment toys that keep parakeets and cockatiels busy. In the aquatic and reptile section, you’ll see aquariums, tanks, filtration systems, and water-care products. Bearded dragons and other reptiles get quality heating lamps, habitat substrates, hides, and feeding tools. Whether you’re shopping for a new accessory or stocking up on essentials, Bayside Great Danes delivers a full-service experience with an impressive range for every kind of pet.
LapDog Depot
From the moment you enter LapDog Depot, you notice it’s not a big-box pet store. Their curated selection features squeaky toys with unique designs and treats made from simple, pronounceable ingredients. You can also find grooming brushes, durable feeders, water bottles, and poop bag dispensers that survive a backpack trip.
Food offerings focus on premium treats and chews only. They also cover needs from travel-friendly bowls to specialized grooming scissors. They carry pet apparel too, such as chic bandanas and matching banana-print sets so you and your dog can coordinate if you want. Matching outfits aren’t for everyone, but they’re available.
Every month, the LapDog Drop Box arrives with two new toys and two treat bags. It feels like a personal care package for your pet, but without the sad dorm food. Their leash lineup includes stylish harnesses and an LED retractable model with a built-in flashlight. That feature alone keeps you from fumbling for your phone on evening walks. The thoughtful details in each product make it clear they’ve designed this store with serious dog lovers in mind.
Cold Blooded Sensations
Stepping into Cold Blooded Sensations feels like entering a reptile enthusiast’s dream. This family-run store specializes in a wide array of reptiles, from striking Boa morphs and Green Tree Pythons to large Rhino Iguanas. Geckos, including Crested and Gargoyle varieties, share display space with robust monitors and Blue Tongue Skinks. Every enclosure showcases vivid scales and thoughtful habitat design.
The supply shelves are stocked with essential reptile care items. You’ll find heating lamps, thermostats, humidifiers, and specialty substrates. A variety of hides and climbing branches caters to both shy and active species. Live feeder options include insects and rodents that meet the nutritional needs of growing reptiles. Cold Blooded Sensations covers every aspect of reptile ownership—from animal selection to habitat setup and maintenance—offering knowledgeable service that sets it apart from a typical pet chain.
Wicked Sticks Aquarium Service and Maintenance
When it comes to aquarium care in Sarasota, Wicked Sticks Aquarium Service and Maintenance handles everything from basic cleanings to full installations. Technicians arrive on schedule to change water, scrub away algae, and inspect pumps, heaters and filters for optimal performance.
They also offer supply restocking, so you can order air pumps, fish food, water conditioners and decorative accents without running to multiple stores. The inventory often includes driftwood, live plants and unique ornaments to suit freshwater or saltwater aquariums.
For clients seeking an upgrade, Wicked Sticks can design custom displays, install advanced lighting systems and select compatible species. Regular maintenance packages cover weekly or biweekly visits, ensuring a stable environment for your fish and corals.
Businesses and homeowners alike appreciate the professional approach—no more struggling with heavy tanks or battling pond slime. With detailed service reports and prompt troubleshooting, Wicked Sticks keeps tanks healthy and vibrant, leaving you free to enjoy the view.
Marlin’s Raw Superfood for Pets
In Sarasota, Marlin’s Raw Superfood for Pets takes raw feeding seriously. They stock frozen and freeze-dried diets for dogs and cats, featuring options like beef, bison, duck, pheasant, rabbit, even emu for something adventurous. Their shelves include respected brands such as Steve’s Real Food, Primal, and Answers alongside Marlin’s own label.
Beyond meals, you’ll find goat’s milk, natural supplements, and rawhide-free bones to support dental health. They also carry bowls, beds, and collars designed for comfort and style. Curbside pickup is available for busy pet owners who need quick service.
The team offers in-store nutritional consultations, helping both new and experienced pet owners navigate raw diets. Their friendly approach feels like chatting with a knowledgeable neighbor rather than a sales clerk. From holistic treats for picky eaters to advice on balanced menus, this shop covers your pets’ nutritional needs. Every detail reflects a commitment to high-quality, species-appropriate feeding.
Mickey’s Pet Supplies
At Mickey’s Pet Supplies in Sarasota, quality is the top priority. This boutique focuses on natural, organic, and mostly USA-made products. For heavy chewers, they offer an array of durable toys and tough chews. Sensitive pups can choose machine-washable plush toys, and there are even glow-in-the-dark fetch toys for evening play.
Cat owners will find a variety of catnip toys, wand teasers from GoCat, and novelty items like plush Rosie Rats. Treat options include premium bully sticks and freeze-dried single-ingredient bites with no artificial additives. Dental health fans can shop for dental chews and ergonomic brushes.
Grooming gear ranges from nail clippers to professional-grade shampoos. For anxious pets, the store carries organic calming supplements and pheromone sprays. Mickey’s website and physical shop both offer local pickup and shipping, with a special discount available for first-time customers. The whole store feels like a wellness retreat in a single storefront.
Wet Noses Grooming Sarasota
At Wet Noses Grooming Sarasota, pets receive more than just a trim—they enjoy a full-service spa experience paired with a boutique stocked in style. Shelves hold a range of all-natural foods from raw diets to premium kibble, including grain-free and freeze-dried options that suit dogs and cats alike.
Treat displays showcase pumpkin softies, chicken chips, beef bites and even dog-friendly cupcakes. The toy selection is carefully curated, offering interactive puzzles, plush playthings and durable chews. Local artisans supply custom collars and leashes, and you’ll find pet carriers, strollers and even drinkware and apparel designed for pet parents.
Grooming services include breed-specific cuts, deep coats treatments, nail trims and gentle ear cleaning. The spa setting features calming music and non-slip tubs for anxious or wiggly pets. Staff members focus on comfort and safety, catering to each animal’s needs while maintaining a clean, welcoming environment.
Wet Noses Grooming Sarasota blends top-tier grooming with a boutique atmosphere, making it a go-to destination for pet owners who want quality, style and care all under one roof.
Pet Supplies Plus – Sarasota East
When you walk into Pet Supplies Plus – Sarasota East, you see a full pet bakery operating inside. The bakery offers freshly baked treats for dogs, cats, and small pets. Nearby shelves hold every formula imaginable: grain-free dry food, refrigerated diets, raw blends, and breed-specific kibble.
Cat lovers will notice an extensive selection of scratch posts, litter options, and interactive mouse toys. Bird enthusiasts can choose from live birds, cages, high-quality feed, and custom perches. Aquarium hobbyists find tanks, filters, and décor arranged like miniature underwater villages. Reptile fans get specialized habitats, heat lamps, and habitat accessories to keep turtles, frogs, and lizards happy.
The full-service grooming area handles trims, baths, and nail care. If you prefer hands-on, the self-serve dog wash bays include gentle sprayers and non-slip floors. For busy owners, curbside pickup and home delivery are available. Pet Supplies Plus – Sarasota East truly brings the convenience of a big store to a neighborhood setting.
Coral Connection
Coral Connection specializes in reef-style saltwater systems with an emphasis on healthy coral and marine fish. The showroom features dozens of LED lighting setups, protein skimmers, and test kits lined up alongside rows of soft and hard coral frags. Over 200 unique coral pieces, including mother colonies, showcase vibrant colors. Aquacultured live rock from Indonesia adds both function and aesthetic to any tank.
They also stock a diverse range of livestock—clownfish, gobies, tangs, and other reef dwellers. If you’re starting a new aquarium, Coral Connection handles design, installation, and customized setup. Staff members guide you through water chemistry, filtration options, and routine maintenance tasks. Ongoing services include system cleanings, water testing, and equipment checks. With hands-on support and specialized products, Coral Connection makes reef aquariums accessible for hobbyists at every experience level.
Holistic For Pets
Holistic For Pets in Sarasota offers a boutique approach to pet nutrition and care. The focus is on all-natural and holistic products, from raw and grain-free kibbles to canned and fresh diets. A wall of supplements caters to joint health, digestion, and skin support. Every ingredient is clearly listed, so you know exactly what’s in your pet’s food.
An on-site Dog Bakery crafts oven-baked treats and jerky using wholesome ingredients. The store also carries a selection of beds, crates, leashes, collars, and toys. Knowledgeable staff provide personalized nutrition advice, helping you choose the best options for your dog or cat. For added convenience, curbside pickup is available, making it easy to stock up on essentials without leaving your vehicle. Holistic For Pets delivers quality products and expert guidance in a friendly, chain-free environment.
Pet Supply Center
Pet Supply Center in Sarasota blends local charm with one-stop shopping for every type of pet. The store carries holistic and natural foods, including freeze-dried raw diets for dogs, gourmet pâtés for cats, and a variety of seed mixes for birds. Small mammals like rabbits, guinea pigs, and hamsters get specialized pellets and bedding, while reptile fans can browse terrariums, heat lamps, and substrate options.
Beyond food, the aisles hold supplements, vitamins, and grooming tools labeled for pets. The vitamin section reads like a human supplement shop but with packaging designed for safe pet use. Customers can choose dental treats, skin-support chews, and calming formulas.
You’ll also find cages, perches, water bottles, and habitat accessories to suit any pet’s home. Pet Supply Center offers both in-store shopping and curbside pickup for busy locals. Friendly staff members provide advice on feeding routines and habitat setups. This locally owned shop caters to parakeets, gerbils, geckos, and every pet in between, making it a convenient destination for all your care essentials.
Exotic Pet Center
At Exotic Pet Center you’ll find an expansive mix of animals and supplies beyond the usual cats and dogs. Parrots of various species perch in their own area, while snakes, lizards, and tiny mammals occupy tailored habitats. Fish displays feature both freshwater and saltwater setups, showcasing unique aquatic species and live plants.
A dedicated aisle offers premium pet foods—brands like Orijen, Acana, and Taste of the Wild. Gourmet pâtés and grain-free recipes appear alongside organic freeze-dried rabbit treats for dogs. The reptile section includes heated enclosures, specialized substrates, and humidity control systems. Bird owners can choose from seed mixes, pelleted diets, and an assortment of swings and perches. Exotic Pet Center also provides boarding, wing and beak trimming, and a visiting mobile vet every two weeks. With curbside pickup available, this store truly functions as a one-stop shop for any pet lover.
