The best local shops in St. Johns County

If your wardrobe needs a win, Fifi's Fine Resale Apparel curates designer-quality finds for women, men, and plus-size shoppers, from standout denim to vintage shoes and handbags. It’s an upscale consignment spot locals swear by after 25 years, so pop in this week and hunt down something that looks full-price but isn’t.

From the St. Augustine newsletter, October 11, 2026

If your jewelry keeps ghosting you, Alice & Chains Permanent Jewelry welds curated chains in premium metals that actually stay put, from dainty to bold. Get linked this week for matching bracelets, a memorial piece, or the start of your dream stack you’ll wear every day.

From the St. Augustine newsletter, August 8, 2026

Sandpiper Boutique brings big city designers at small town prices, with contemporary luxury consignment from Gucci, Louis Vuitton, Farm Rio, Johnny Was, Free People and more. Everything is handpicked and in great shape, new arrivals land daily, so it rewards quick passes and repeat peeks.

From the Palm Coast newsletter, August 5, 2026

When you want a thoughtful gift or a little wardrobe pick-me-up that doesn’t feel mass-produced, Red Pineapple does the trick with its own line of vintage-inspired apparel and jewelry. Charming, a bit nostalgic, and easy to wear, it’s the kind of spot locals keep in their back pocket.

From the St. Augustine newsletter, October 10, 2026

From boho-chic finds to beach-day staples, Vintage Clothing Co. keeps St. Augustine-ready essentials in one spot, with local tees, swimwear, comfy sandals, and personalized tumblers.

From the St. Augustine newsletter, September 9, 2026

Women's clothing boutique offering cute apparel and accessories in a welcoming atmosphere.

Swap the blah pantry vibes for Orange Zest Whipped Raw Honey, classic Orange Blossom, and Homestead Preserves from Stubbees | Hive & Homestead, then snag honey-based body yogurts, soap, and candles so your skin and space smell like actual sunshine. Treat yourself this week, St. Augustine.

From the St. Augustine newsletter, September 23, 2026

Crafts Without Borders is Uptown’s fair trade treasure trove, mixing handmade jewelry, scarves, and wall art from artisan families across the globe with owner Caroline Redding’s delicate tatting pieces. It’s the kind of shop you pop into for a card and leave with a conversation starter.

From the St. Augustine newsletter, October 18, 2026

Alvin's Island has been a St. Augustine staple since 1992, stocking swimsuits, towels, resortwear, souvenirs, toys, and suntan products for those last-minute "did I pack anything" moments. Expect beachwear and swim from big brands like O'Neill and Roxy, plus the extras that rescue a spontaneous sand day.

From the St. Augustine newsletter, October 12, 2026

Retail chain offering home goods, clothing, electronics & more, plus exclusive designer collections.

360 Boutique is a unique, vibrant St. Augustine spot for clothing, jewelry, and handbags that feel like they were picked by your stylish friend. Swing by this week to find something that actually earns a spot in your everyday rotation, not just your 'maybe someday' pile.

From the St. Augustine newsletter, September 17, 2026

From reenactment crews to pirate weddings, The Pirate Store handcrafts historically inspired garb and accessories, and they’ll build custom pieces that actually fit your inner buccaneer. An authentic outfitter in the nation's oldest city... perfect when the festival calendar or your weekend needs a little more swagger.

From the St. Augustine newsletter, August 12, 2026

Gift shop offering jewelry, home furnishings, and other unusual items for purchase.

Anchor Boutique nails that St. Augustine vibe with custom engagement rings, permanent jewelry, and breezy designs inspired by seashells and the coast, perfect when you want something personal without the pretense. Bring your idea, leave with a piece that feels like home and looks like sunshine.

From the St. Augustine newsletter, September 2, 2026

If your flip-flops are begging for a little sparkle, Tootsy's Footsies handcrafts sterling silver toe rings that are custom fitted, plus anklets and bracelets for that low-key Florida shine. Laid-back, beachy, and actually comfortable, their pieces are the kind you forget you’re wearing until someone compliments them.

From the St. Augustine newsletter, October 17, 2026