The best local shops in Anderson

26 local shops we’ve checked and stand behind — with the story on each one. Not a ranking; a record.

Browse another shelf: all of Anderson’s best · Restaurants · Beauty · Bakeries & Sweets · Nightlife · Hobbies, Books, & Crafts · Entertainment · Antiques, Thrift, & Vintage · Arts & Culture · Home & Garden · Sporting Goods · Health & Wellness · Pets · Cafes · Services

Pinned in Anderson today

This spot is open today.

Two pinned places a day in Anderson — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. List your business →

Paid placements are always marked.

Shopping · 26 places · showing the latest additions first

Established, locally owned retailer providing fine jewelry, loose diamonds & custom pieces.

6010 W 86th St (Indianapolis)

Established, locally owned retailer providing fine jewelry, loose diamonds & custom pieces.

Website ↗

Sai's Boutique nails the latest Indian styles with personal service, from saris, jewelry, purses and bindis to men's, women's and kids'…

8840 Michigan Rd Ste 102 (Indianapolis)

Sai's Boutique nails the latest Indian styles with personal service, from saris, jewelry, purses and bindis to men's, women's and kids' looks, plus sizes included. If you need something festive or just everyday-elegant, they'll help you find the right piece without the runaround.

From the Westfield newsletter, September 12, 2026

Website ↗

Sporting goods chain with equipment, apparel & footwear for athletics, outdoor recreation & fitness.

6030 W 86th St (Indianapolis)

Sporting goods chain with equipment, apparel & footwear for athletics, outdoor recreation & fitness.

Website ↗

From corporate recognition to youth sports and fantasy league bragging rights, Bardach Awards has crystal and glass awards, acrylics,…

4222 W 86th St (Indianapolis) · ✓ checked Sep 12

From corporate recognition to youth sports and fantasy league bragging rights, Bardach Awards has crystal and glass awards, acrylics, plaques, medals, trophies, plus gift items and promotional picks.

From the Indianapolis newsletter, September 17, 2026

Website ↗
Run a Anderson business? Two pinned spots a day — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. Advertise →

Five Below

Shopping

Teen-oriented retail chain for a large assortment of games, snacks, jewelry, room decor & more.

3495 W 86th St (Indianapolis)

Teen-oriented retail chain for a large assortment of games, snacks, jewelry, room decor & more.

Website ↗

Old Navy

Shopping

Chain with a wide range of clothing for the family from jeans to loungewear, plus fun accessories.

6010 W 86th St Ste 102 (Indianapolis)

Chain with a wide range of clothing for the family from jeans to loungewear, plus fun accessories.

Website ↗

Retail chain selling brand-name clothing, shoes, accessories & housewares at discount prices.

3487 W 86th St (Indianapolis)

Retail chain selling brand-name clothing, shoes, accessories & housewares at discount prices.

Website ↗

Rally House Southport Commons keeps local fans covered with team apparel, accessories, and gifts for favorites like the Indiana Hoosiers…

4850 E Southport Rd Ste J (Indianapolis)

Rally House Southport Commons keeps local fans covered with team apparel, accessories, and gifts for favorites like the Indiana Hoosiers and Indianapolis Colts. Easy spot to refresh your game-day look, snag a quick present, or declare allegiance without saying a word.

From the Greenwood newsletter, September 5, 2026

Website ↗

Whether it's quince, prom, bridal, bridesmaid, or homecoming, Pretty Chicas Boutique helps you nail the vibe with options from simple and…

4850 E Southport Rd E (Indianapolis)

Whether it's quince, prom, bridal, bridesmaid, or homecoming, Pretty Chicas Boutique helps you nail the vibe with options from simple and elegant to full-on sparkle. This week, swing by to try on something that actually feels like you, then twirl out ready for photos, dance floors, or saying I do.

From the Greenwood newsletter, August 29, 2026

Website ↗

Retail chain selling brand-name clothing, shoes, accessories & housewares at discount prices.

4200 S East St (Indianapolis)

Retail chain selling brand-name clothing, shoes, accessories & housewares at discount prices.

Website ↗

Fun Services

Shopping

From PTO holiday shops to company parties, Fun Services makes planning easier with Santa’s Secret Shop gift programs, FunFairs, and…

5842 S Harding St Ste b (Indianapolis)

From PTO holiday shops to company parties, Fun Services makes planning easier with Santa’s Secret Shop gift programs, FunFairs, and fundraising options. If your school or group needs a dependable partner, their programs help keep things organized so you can focus on the fun part.

From the Anderson newsletter, September 10, 2026

Website ↗

Yireh Flower Shop turns birthdays, anniversaries and just-because moments into mini events with personalized designs, trendy Korean-style…

935 E Hanna Ave (Indianapolis)

Yireh Flower Shop turns birthdays, anniversaries and just-because moments into mini events with personalized designs, trendy Korean-style wraps and those rose-and-chocolate boxes that make people do a double take. They craft with care and offer next-day delivery, so planning ahead actually pays off.

From the Kokomo newsletter, September 3, 2026

Website ↗

Whether it’s a birthday you almost forgot or a just-because moment, Flowers by Valerie nails it with custom designs using the best blooms,…

8053 Madison Ave (Indianapolis)

Whether it’s a birthday you almost forgot or a just-because moment, Flowers by Valerie nails it with custom designs using the best blooms, plus fruit or candy bouquets, balloons, and lush dish gardens. They make gifting ridiculously easy with local delivery across Greenwood and the greater Indy orbit.

From the Greenwood newsletter, August 28, 2026

Website ↗

Refresh your weekly rotation with Zadie B's Fashions, a local go-to for versatile dresses, pencil skirts in a rainbow of colors, and lace…

7785 US 31 S (Indianapolis)

Refresh your weekly rotation with Zadie B's Fashions, a local go-to for versatile dresses, pencil skirts in a rainbow of colors, and lace layering pieces that make outfits feel thought out even on laundry day.

From the Greenwood newsletter, August 27, 2026

Website ↗

Artisans

Shopping

Artisans is a gallery-style gift shop in Indy’s Mass Ave Arts District with designer jewelry like UNOde50, Italian leather and Hammitt…

433 Massachusetts Ave (Indianapolis)

Artisans is a gallery-style gift shop in Indy’s Mass Ave Arts District with designer jewelry like UNOde50, Italian leather and Hammitt handbags, one-of-a-kind American handcrafts, and clever Ken Bailey pet art. When you need something this week that feels special, this spot nails it without the gift-aisle panic.

From the Indianapolis newsletter, August 4, 2026

Website ↗

Resell Indy

Shopping

If you love snagging solid gadgets, comfy furniture, kid-tempting toys, and practical appliances without paying full freight, Resell Indy…

10202 E Washington St Ste 800 (Indianapolis)

If you love snagging solid gadgets, comfy furniture, kid-tempting toys, and practical appliances without paying full freight, Resell Indy is worth a lap this week. It’s the kind of friendly, dig-around shop locals hit when a room needs a refresh or your tech stash needs a cheap upgrade.

From the Lawrence newsletter, August 26, 2026

Website ↗

Mass Ave Knit Shop is the community-minded spot for squishy skeins, practical tools, smart patterns, and ready-to-go kits, plus classes and…

862 Virginia Ave (Indianapolis)

Mass Ave Knit Shop is the community-minded spot for squishy skeins, practical tools, smart patterns, and ready-to-go kits, plus classes and open knitting nights that keep projects moving and friendships growing. If your stash needs inspiration this week or your fingers just miss the needles, this is your sign.

From the Greenwood newsletter, August 13, 2026

Website ↗

Indy climbers, Roam & Stow inside North Mass Boulder nails that sweet spot between performance and chill, with curated apparel,…

1411 Roosevelt Ave Ste 100 (Indianapolis)

Indy climbers, Roam & Stow inside North Mass Boulder nails that sweet spot between performance and chill, with curated apparel, accessories, climbing shoes, and soft-as-hell recovery layers that look as good post-session as they feel mid-problem. Swing by, try on, and let the fit do the flexing. Check it out.

From the Lawrence newsletter, August 14, 2026

Website ↗

Whether you're stocking up on crystals and stones, sniffing out spell oils, or grabbing Twig's Tea for a cozy ritual, Twisted Twigs House…

3504 Main St

Whether you're stocking up on crystals and stones, sniffing out spell oils, or grabbing Twig's Tea for a cozy ritual, Twisted Twigs House of Earthen Goods keeps the vibe high and the woo grounded. They also offer intuitive readings with Mike, perfect for a midweek reset or fresh perspective.

From the Anderson newsletter, September 14, 2026

Website ↗

Ghost House Gear is serving fresh drops that actually slap, from stacked jeans and joggers to hoodies, matching sets, and clean tops, plus…

908 S Scatterfield Rd

Ghost House Gear is serving fresh drops that actually slap, from stacked jeans and joggers to hoodies, matching sets, and clean tops, plus a Women’s lineup. Perfect for upgrading your weekly rotation before those last-minute plans hit.

From the Anderson newsletter, September 20, 2026

Website ↗

Lids

Shopping

Chain specializing in licensed team hats, logo apparel & other sports merchandise.

8702 Keystone Crossing SP150B (Indianapolis)

Chain specializing in licensed team hats, logo apparel & other sports merchandise.

Website ↗

Whether you’re hard on your work boots or dressing up for a Friday night at the fairgrounds, Cowpokes Work & Western outfits the whole…

1812 E 53rd St

Whether you’re hard on your work boots or dressing up for a Friday night at the fairgrounds, Cowpokes Work & Western outfits the whole family with solid brands like Ariat, Anderson Bean, Wrangler and Resistol, plus hats, denim, flame-resistant workwear, and even tack and rodeo gear.

From the Anderson newsletter, September 19, 2026

Website ↗

Kids grow fast, your wallet doesn't, and Dress My Mini keeps up with both, stocking fun, trendy kids clothing, shoes, equipment and…

1832 S Scatterfield Rd

Kids grow fast, your wallet doesn't, and Dress My Mini keeps up with both, stocking fun, trendy kids clothing, shoes, equipment and accessories. Bring in outgrown clothes, shoes, toys, and equipment for cash or same-day credit, then treasure-hunt for the next size up without the sticker shock.

From the Muncie newsletter, August 15, 2026

Website ↗

When your closet needs more personality than another big-box basic, Vintage Kulture Clothing comes through with throwback style and one-off…

869 Massachusetts Ave (Indianapolis)

When your closet needs more personality than another big-box basic, Vintage Kulture Clothing comes through with throwback style and one-off pieces that feel lived-in in the best way. It’s the kind of spot Indy locals hit when they want something different, not just new.

Website ↗

Lids

Shopping

Chain specializing in licensed team hats, logo apparel & other sports merchandise.

6020 E 82nd St Sp 346A (Indianapolis)

Chain specializing in licensed team hats, logo apparel & other sports merchandise.

Website ↗

Listed here?

You’ve earned the mark — get the BaseLocal’s Best badge for your site →. Want in? List your business →