The best restaurants in Nantucket

41 restaurants we’ve checked and stand behind — with the story on each one. Not a ranking; a record.

Browse another shelf: all of Nantucket’s best · Shopping · Arts & Culture · Nightlife · Home & Garden · Antiques, Thrift, & Vintage · Health & Wellness · Bakeries & Sweets · Beauty · Cafes · Entertainment · Pets · Sporting Goods

Pinned in Nantucket today

This spot is open today.

Two pinned places a day in Nantucket — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. List your business →

Paid placements are always marked.

Restaurants · 41 places · showing the latest additions first

Galley Beach

Restaurants

For days when you want brunch that feels like a mini vacation without leaving the island, Galley Beach delivers refined New American…

54 Jefferson Ave

For days when you want brunch that feels like a mini vacation without leaving the island, Galley Beach delivers refined New American plates, craft cocktails, and polished surrounds. Post up at the beach bar or lounge, linger between menus, and pretend it's "research".

From the Nantucket newsletter, September 20, 2026

Website ↗

Tacos, margaritas & more are served cafeteria-style in a casual, colorful destination.

2 Broad St

Tacos, margaritas & more are served cafeteria-style in a casual, colorful destination.

Website ↗

Cru

Restaurants

Stylish hot spot, right on the water, offers expansive raw bar options & cooked seafood fare.

1 Straight Wharf

Stylish hot spot, right on the water, offers expansive raw bar options & cooked seafood fare.

Website ↗

Popular for breakfast, this down-to-earth New American eatery also offers BYOB-friendly dinners.

10 India St

Popular for breakfast, this down-to-earth New American eatery also offers BYOB-friendly dinners.

Website ↗
Run a Nantucket business? Two pinned spots a day — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. Advertise →

Locally focused spot with patio & chic bar offering New American fare, many wines & weekend brunch.

12 Federal St

Locally focused spot with patio & chic bar offering New American fare, many wines & weekend brunch.

Website ↗

The Fairgrounds

Restaurants

The Fairgrounds is that homey local pub you call when sports are on and you want classic American comfort fare without the fuss. Big screen…

27 Fairgrounds Rd

The Fairgrounds is that homey local pub you call when sports are on and you want classic American comfort fare without the fuss. Big screen TVs, a breezy patio, and cocktails that play well with the classics make it an easy weeknight habit.

From the Nantucket newsletter, September 8, 2026

Website ↗

Provisions

Restaurants

Provisions is the island go-to when you want breakfast that actually wakes you up and lunch that keeps you moving. Home of the Turkey…

3 Harbor Square

Provisions is the island go-to when you want breakfast that actually wakes you up and lunch that keeps you moving. Home of the Turkey Terrific and other handmade favorites, they bake pastries, roll bagels, and stack wholesome sandwiches that taste like summer on Nantucket.

From the Nantucket newsletter, September 13, 2026

Website ↗

Since 1974, The Nantucket Lobster Trap has been dishing out authentic New England seafood that tastes like home, with cozy indoor dining, a…

23 Washington St

Since 1974, The Nantucket Lobster Trap has been dishing out authentic New England seafood that tastes like home, with cozy indoor dining, a relaxed patio and full bars. Grab something fast from the takeout window, or hit their food truck at Cisco Brewery if you're already out and about.

From the Nantucket newsletter, September 15, 2026

Website ↗

The Restaurant at Miacomet Golf Course keeps things simple in the best way, a relaxed spot for American comfort and post round catchups…

12 W Miacomet Rd

The Restaurant at Miacomet Golf Course keeps things simple in the best way, a relaxed spot for American comfort and post round catchups that works just as well when your swing is resting and you just want a solid, no-nonsense meal.

From the Nantucket newsletter, September 21, 2026

Website ↗

Ventuno Restaurant turns the weeknight slump into something worth dressing up for, serving refined Italian cooking and fresh pasta in that…

21 Federal St

Ventuno Restaurant turns the weeknight slump into something worth dressing up for, serving refined Italian cooking and fresh pasta in that handsome Greek Revival building locals actually notice again. Settle in for thoughtful flavors, a wine list worth exploring, and the pleasant risk of bread-basket overcommitment.

From the Nantucket newsletter, August 8, 2026

Website ↗

B-ACK Yard BBQ

Restaurants

Craving something low-key with big flavor? B-ACK Yard BBQ keeps it simple with housemade barbecue plates and sides, plenty of Tennessee…

20 Straight Wharf

Craving something low-key with big flavor? B-ACK Yard BBQ keeps it simple with housemade barbecue plates and sides, plenty of Tennessee whiskeys, and craft beers to match, all in a chill sports bar vibe that makes catching the game with friends dangerously easy to turn into dinner.

From the Nantucket newsletter, August 3, 2026

Website ↗

Stubbys

Restaurants

Whether your morning needs a proper egg sandwich or your afternoon requires some spicy jerk chicken, Stubbys is the low-key spot keeping…

8 Steamboat Wharf · ✓ checked Jul 28

Whether your morning needs a proper egg sandwich or your afternoon requires some spicy jerk chicken, Stubbys is the low-key spot keeping Nantucket fed with eclectic comfort favorites. When you want a no-fuss burger or something warm and satisfying between errands, this cozy standby delivers.

From the Nantucket newsletter, September 16, 2026

Website ↗

PPX Events & Pâtisserie is the Nantucket-based planning and catering atelier to call when you're hosting this week, turning backyard…

7 S Water St

PPX Events & Pâtisserie is the Nantucket-based planning and catering atelier to call when you're hosting this week, turning backyard dinners, milestone parties, and office to-dos into effortless, deeply personal moments.

From the Nantucket newsletter, August 18, 2026

Website ↗

The Surf

Restaurants

When you just want solid cooking without the scene, The Surf keeps it simple in the best way, with unfussy plates, a comfortable room, and…

4 Western Ave

When you just want solid cooking without the scene, The Surf keeps it simple in the best way, with unfussy plates, a comfortable room, and the kind of laid-back buzz where you’ll probably bump into someone you know. Easy choice for weeknights or low-key weekends.

From the Nantucket newsletter, September 3, 2026

Website ↗

American Seasons

Restaurants

American Seasons pairs Chef-Owner Neil Ferguson’s 35 years of London, Paris and New York know-how with a bright, artful room Cheryl Fudge…

80 Centre St

American Seasons pairs Chef-Owner Neil Ferguson’s 35 years of London, Paris and New York know-how with a bright, artful room Cheryl Fudge reimagined, then turns out seasonal, locally sourced plates and a serious bar program of cocktails, amaros and digestifs that’s perfect for an easy midweek treat or celebratory…

From the Nantucket newsletter, September 2, 2026

Website ↗

Millie's

Restaurants

When that fish taco itch hits and you want it fresh and unfussy, Millie’s keeps it simple with coastal fare, Baja-inspired flavors, and the…

326 Madaket Rd

When that fish taco itch hits and you want it fresh and unfussy, Millie’s keeps it simple with coastal fare, Baja-inspired flavors, and the island-famous Madaket Mystery cocktail. Multiple island spots make it an easy weeknight staple, not just a summer fling.

From the Nantucket newsletter, August 31, 2026

Website ↗

GypSea Café

Restaurants

Locals keep GypSea Café in the rotation for unfussy breakfast staples, hearty sandwiches, and acai bowls that somehow make you feel…

15 Harbor View Way

Locals keep GypSea Café in the rotation for unfussy breakfast staples, hearty sandwiches, and acai bowls that somehow make you feel virtuous. It’s family-friendly and laid-back, the sort of spot you swing by post-errands or pre-beach and leave wondering why you ever ate cereal at home.

From the Nantucket newsletter, September 2, 2026

Website ↗

TOPPER'S

Restaurants

This week, when you need a proper treat, Topper's delivers seasonally inspired New England plates, oysters harvested just down the shore,…

120 Wauwinet Rd

This week, when you need a proper treat, Topper's delivers seasonally inspired New England plates, oysters harvested just down the shore, and a cellar stacked with 2,000 wines, all with that calm Nantucket Bay view that makes Monday feel like Friday.

From the Nantucket newsletter, August 29, 2026

Website ↗

The Nautilus

Restaurants

Whether you’re plotting a low-key date or corralling friends, The Nautilus nails global, seafood-centric small plates that play nice with…

12 Cambridge St

Whether you’re plotting a low-key date or corralling friends, The Nautilus nails global, seafood-centric small plates that play nice with inventive cocktails. It’s lively without trying too hard, and if you’re feeling celebratory, the Captain’s Table setup turns a regular night into a mini event.

From the Nantucket newsletter, September 1, 2026

Website ↗

Celebrating six decades on the harbor, Straight Wharf Restaurant reinterprets summer classics into seafood you actually crave after a beach…

6 Harbor Square

Celebrating six decades on the harbor, Straight Wharf Restaurant reinterprets summer classics into seafood you actually crave after a beach day, served with that easy, genuine warmth you want from a true island standby. If this week calls for special without the fuss, this spot reminds you why you live here.

From the Nantucket newsletter, August 24, 2026

Website ↗

The Proprietors Bar & Table keeps things interesting with locally sourced, globally influenced plates that actually make sharing fun, from…

9 India St

The Proprietors Bar & Table keeps things interesting with locally sourced, globally influenced plates that actually make sharing fun, from craveable smalls to bigs built around peak island produce. Pair it with a mythic cocktail like Zeus or Aphrodite, then pretend you planned this all week.

From the Nantucket newsletter, August 25, 2026

Website ↗

Sometimes you just want hearty plates, a good pour, and the familiar hum of live music. Brotherhood of Thieves keeps the whaling bar and…

23 Broad St

Sometimes you just want hearty plates, a good pour, and the familiar hum of live music. Brotherhood of Thieves keeps the whaling bar and tavern spirit alive with crowd-pleasing menus, a cozy vibe, and takeout when you’re hunkering down at home, perfect for a midweek reset.

From the Nantucket newsletter, August 30, 2026

Website ↗

When you want no-fuss good food, Island Kitchen | Restaurant & Catering serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner that hits the spot, with…

1 Chins Way

When you want no-fuss good food, Island Kitchen | Restaurant & Catering serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner that hits the spot, with house-made ice cream for dessert. They also do full-service catering across Nantucket, Naples, Miami, and Palm Beach, plus in-flight options and IK Juice Co. for a quick fix.

From the Nantucket newsletter, September 2, 2026

Website ↗

Via Mare

Restaurants

Via Mare brings a playful bacari spirit to island nights with Venetian-inspired small plates that follow the spice-trade winds across…

17 Broad St

Via Mare brings a playful bacari spirit to island nights with Venetian-inspired small plates that follow the spice-trade winds across garden and sea. Think Italian-ish snacks, thoughtful wines and cocktails, and a Bohemian living room vibe that makes midweek catch-ups feel casually special this week.

From the Nantucket newsletter, August 29, 2026

Website ↗

Slip 14

Restaurants

Homey indoor-outdoor New American spot for fish-focused fare & creative cocktails with water views.

14 Old South Wharf

Homey indoor-outdoor New American spot for fish-focused fare & creative cocktails with water views.

Website ↗

Tucked inside the iconic Jared Coffin House, Nantucket Tap Room pairs exposed-brick charm with a cozy, lively vibe and good drinks, plus…

Located inside the Jared Coffin House, 29 Broad St

Tucked inside the iconic Jared Coffin House, Nantucket Tap Room pairs exposed-brick charm with a cozy, lively vibe and good drinks, plus the Big M-Ack burger that locals whisper about like island lore. Swing by this week if you’re craving flavor with a side of history.

From the Nantucket newsletter, August 26, 2026

Website ↗

Pi Pizzeria

Restaurants

If you’ve been meaning to get a pie this week, Pi Pizzeria is turning out thin-crust Neapolitan pizzas in Nantucket’s only commercial…

11 W Creek Rd

If you’ve been meaning to get a pie this week, Pi Pizzeria is turning out thin-crust Neapolitan pizzas in Nantucket’s only commercial wood-fired oven, with dough made fresh each morning, scratch San Marzano sauce, and fresh-grated mozzarella.

From the Nantucket newsletter, August 28, 2026

Website ↗

Crosswinds Restaurant is the island’s before-check-in standby at Nantucket Memorial Airport for burgers, seafood, and pancake-fueled…

14 Airport Rd

Crosswinds Restaurant is the island’s before-check-in standby at Nantucket Memorial Airport for burgers, seafood, and pancake-fueled mornings, plus daily specials with generous portions and great prices. Grab takeout or settle in for a low-key meal while planes come and go, even if you’re not going anywhere.

From the Nantucket newsletter, August 31, 2026

Website ↗

The Rose and Crown is that long-running island fallback for nights when you want live local music, notorious karaoke, and early or late…

23 S Water St · ✓ checked Aug 13

The Rose and Crown is that long-running island fallback for nights when you want live local music, notorious karaoke, and early or late chances to catch the game, plus reliable pub fare and cocktails when your fridge is just vibes.

From the Nantucket newsletter, August 21, 2026

Website ↗

Oran Mor

Restaurants

Oran Mor is serving polished, seasonal Nantucket cuisine from the second story of a charming historic house, with a deep wine list and…

2 S Beach St

Oran Mor is serving polished, seasonal Nantucket cuisine from the second story of a charming historic house, with a deep wine list and proper cocktails to match. Keep it in your back pocket for when you want dinner to feel like an occasion without leaving island mode.

From the Nantucket newsletter, August 13, 2026

Website ↗

Sister Ship

Restaurants

Sister Ship does the island proud with seafood-forward, Mediterranean plates built on New England catch and local produce, plus elevated…

29 Centre St

Sister Ship does the island proud with seafood-forward, Mediterranean plates built on New England catch and local produce, plus elevated cocktails that actually earn the adjective. It’s an easy go-to for a weeknight dinner, courtyard hangs, or planning that private-dining celebration you've been putting off.

From the Nantucket newsletter, September 1, 2026

Website ↗

Bloom Bar

Restaurants

Bloom Bar & Café pulls double duty as a relaxed daytime café and an evening spot for dinner and drinks, so it fits your Tuesday catch-ups…

9 S Water St

Bloom Bar & Café pulls double duty as a relaxed daytime café and an evening spot for dinner and drinks, so it fits your Tuesday catch-ups and low-stakes date nights alike. Keep it simple, grab a seat, and let them handle the vibes and the pours.

From the Nantucket newsletter, August 12, 2026

Website ↗

Pizzeria Gemelle

Restaurants

When you want unfussy, well-made pies, Pizzeria Gemelle leans into Neapolitan, Margherita and thin-crust in a casual setting that just…

2 E Chestnut St

When you want unfussy, well-made pies, Pizzeria Gemelle leans into Neapolitan, Margherita and thin-crust in a casual setting that just works for Nantucket life. Keep an eye on their Instagram for specials and goofy snapshots of the regulars... it's part of the charm.

From the Nantucket newsletter, August 31, 2026

Website ↗

The Club Car

Restaurants

Tucked inside a landmark 19th-century train car, The Club Car serves seasonal, coastal-inspired plates, handcrafted cocktails, and live…

1 Main St

Tucked inside a landmark 19th-century train car, The Club Car serves seasonal, coastal-inspired plates, handcrafted cocktails, and live piano vibes. If you want a night that feels like Nantucket without trying too hard, put it on your list this week.

From the Nantucket newsletter, August 27, 2026

Website ↗

or, The Whale

Restaurants

When you need a low-key spot that still feels special, or, The Whale serves classic American plates, handcrafted cocktails, and a sunny…

38 Main St

When you need a low-key spot that still feels special, or, The Whale serves classic American plates, handcrafted cocktails, and a sunny patio that turns lunch into gossip hour. Brunch is equally dangerous in the best way, perfect for catching up without cooking.

From the Nantucket newsletter, August 15, 2026

Website ↗

Brant Point Grill is serving New England comfort with a view, think raw oysters, little necks, the famous lobster roll, and grilled steaks…

White Elephant, 50 Easton St

Brant Point Grill is serving New England comfort with a view, think raw oysters, little necks, the famous lobster roll, and grilled steaks backed by an award-winning wine cellar. Grab a Lobster Bloody Mary on the newly renovated deck, enjoy live music and those smugly perfect harbor breezes.

From the Nantucket newsletter, August 11, 2026

Website ↗

Something Natural has been feeding Nantucket for over 50 years with thick, satisfying sandwiches, fresh-baked bread, soul-soothing soups,…

50 Cliff Rd

Something Natural has been feeding Nantucket for over 50 years with thick, satisfying sandwiches, fresh-baked bread, soul-soothing soups, and giant cookies you swear you’ll share but never do. When lunch needs to be easy and actually delicious, it delivers "Good Things To Eat and Drink".

From the Nantucket newsletter, August 23, 2026

Website ↗

Fusaro's Homemade Italian keeps it simple and satisfying with crisp pies, hearty meat entrées, and plenty of vegetarian-friendly plates…

17 Old South Rd · ✓ checked Aug 13

Fusaro's Homemade Italian keeps it simple and satisfying with crisp pies, hearty meat entrées, and plenty of vegetarian-friendly plates that actually feel like dinner. Put it in your this-week rotation when you need a no-fuss red-sauce fix that tastes like Nonna had the night off.

From the Nantucket newsletter, August 20, 2026

Website ↗

Whether you’re craving perfectly crafted sushi, The LoLa Burger on an English muffin, or a lively cocktail like the Lola Spritz, Lola 41…

15 S Beach St

Whether you’re craving perfectly crafted sushi, The LoLa Burger on an English muffin, or a lively cocktail like the Lola Spritz, Lola 41 Nantucket nails the weeknight treat factor with a global bistro lineup that keeps dinner fun. Slide it into your rotation this week.

From the Nantucket newsletter, August 30, 2026

Website ↗

The Seagrille

Restaurants

The Seagrille keeps locals happy with chef-crafted seafood rooted in Nantucket’s coastal pantry, a raw bar heavy on Pocomo Meadow oysters,…

45 Sparks Ave

The Seagrille keeps locals happy with chef-crafted seafood rooted in Nantucket’s coastal pantry, a raw bar heavy on Pocomo Meadow oysters, and creative plates like linguica-crusted cod with lobster mash or yellowfin tuna with cornmeal fried oysters. Cocktails and caviar bumps if you're feeling fancy.

From the Nantucket newsletter, September 1, 2026

Website ↗

Le Languedoc Bistro is celebrating 50 seasons with French-inspired dishes built on classic technique and pristine Nantucket and New England…

24 Broad St

Le Languedoc Bistro is celebrating 50 seasons with French-inspired dishes built on classic technique and pristine Nantucket and New England ingredients... think escargot tucked into homemade pasta, octopus, and that Duxelles Chicken, all in a casually elegant 1780s tavern with a proper bar.

From the Nantucket newsletter, August 14, 2026

Website ↗

Listed here?

You’ve earned the mark — get the BaseLocal’s Best badge for your site →. Want in? List your business →