The best sporting goods shops in Nantucket

3 places we’ve checked and would send a neighbor to. Open any one to read what we wrote about it.

3 places · newest first

Your business could be here.

Be at the top of Nantucket's page when you're in Nantucket's newsletter.

Put my business here

Local businesses pay to be shown here. A person checks every one.

Fish Stix Nantucket (opens in a new tab)

69 Somerset Rd

Fish Stix Nantucket crafts one-of-a-kind surf, inshore, fly, kayak, and blue-water rods using lightweight, durable components, plus they…

Fish Stix Nantucket crafts one-of-a-kind surf, inshore, fly, kayak, and blue-water rods using lightweight, durable components, plus they skillfully rehab tired sticks. Work with Jeff Allen on blank, action, guides, and wraps, then put it to work on stripers, blues, bonito or albies this week.

From the Nantucket newsletter, October 18, 2026

Haul Over, Nantucket (opens in a new tab)

7 Salem St

Haul Over has been Nantucket’s outfitter for 30 years, stocking trusted staples from Patagonia, Vuori, Helly Hansen, YETI, Xtratuf,…

Haul Over has been Nantucket’s outfitter for 30 years, stocking trusted staples from Patagonia, Vuori, Helly Hansen, YETI, Xtratuf, Grundens, Johnnie-O, and Olukai. Swing by for custom Patagonia and Helly Hansen pieces and engraved YETI bottles, barware, and even dog bowls... perfect for keeping island life dialed.

From the Nantucket newsletter, October 9, 2026

Force Five WaterSports (opens in a new tab)

6 Union St

Locals know Force Five WaterSports as Nantucket’s premier watersports shop, celebrating 41 years of getting gear right, with surfboards…

Locals know Force Five WaterSports as Nantucket’s premier watersports shop, celebrating 41 years of getting gear right, with surfboards galore, kayaks, and sun-ready essentials including shades from Maui Jim, Smith, and Costa. Swing by when the wind or swell calls, they’ll dial you in.

From the Nantucket newsletter, October 2, 2026