The best bars & nightlife in Amherst

31 bars & nightlife we’ve checked and stand behind — with the story on each one. Not a ranking; a record.

Browse another shelf: all of Amherst’s best · Restaurants · Shopping · Beauty · Bakeries & Sweets · Entertainment · Arts & Culture · Hobbies, Books, & Crafts · Home & Garden · Antiques, Thrift, & Vintage · Sporting Goods · Services

Pinned in Amherst today

This spot is open today.

Two pinned places a day in Amherst — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. List your business →

Paid placements are always marked.

Nightlife · 31 places · showing the latest additions first

Sports bar offering year-round volleyball, darts & a casual menu of steak burgers & more.

935 Harlem Rd (West Seneca)

Sports bar offering year-round volleyball, darts & a casual menu of steak burgers & more.

Website ↗

Informal diner plating traditional American dishes, including fish fry, in a laid-back atmosphere and offering take-out.

1748 Clinton St Ste 1 (Buffalo)

Informal diner plating traditional American dishes, including fish fry, in a laid-back atmosphere and offering take-out.

Website ↗

Jack Rabbit

Nightlife

Jack Rabbit is the move when you want nightly live music and DJs supporting local talent while a scratch kitchen turns out rotisserie…

1010 Elmwood Ave (Buffalo)

Jack Rabbit is the move when you want nightly live music and DJs supporting local talent while a scratch kitchen turns out rotisserie chicken, cast iron pizzas, and mouthwatering sandwiches. Grab your crew, pick a room vibe from piano-cozy to game-room rowdy, and make brunch plans this week.

From the Buffalo newsletter, August 3, 2026

Website ↗

Hartman's Distilling Co. mixes the kind of craft cocktails you brag about, built on their own bourbon, rye, gin, and vodka. Slide into the…

55 Chicago St (Buffalo)

Hartman's Distilling Co. mixes the kind of craft cocktails you brag about, built on their own bourbon, rye, gin, and vodka. Slide into the tasting room for a view of the distillery, weekend brunch, or book a tour and tasting to nerd out on how the good stuff is made.

Website ↗
Run a Amherst business? Two pinned spots a day — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. Advertise →

Burger fans fill this tiny, cash-only haunt known for mammoth patties & cheeseburger soup.

9160 Transit Rd (East Amherst)

Burger fans fill this tiny, cash-only haunt known for mammoth patties & cheeseburger soup.

Website ↗

Rec Room

Nightlife

Small concert hall featuring live bands as well as karaoke and dueling pianos.

79 W Chippewa St (Buffalo)

Small concert hall featuring live bands as well as karaoke and dueling pianos.

Website ↗

Modern sports-pub chain boasting recliners plus high-concept bar food & a huge selection of beer.

4120 Maple Rd

Modern sports-pub chain boasting recliners plus high-concept bar food & a huge selection of beer.

Website ↗

Nietzsche's

Nightlife

Renowned entertainment venue hosting musicians, open-mike nights, comedy acts & burlesque shows.

248 Allen St (Buffalo)

Renowned entertainment venue hosting musicians, open-mike nights, comedy acts & burlesque shows.

Website ↗

Ballyhoo

Nightlife

Cheery, old-fashioned tavern known for refined cocktails, housemade sausages & rotating craft beers.

211 South Park Ave (Buffalo)

Cheery, old-fashioned tavern known for refined cocktails, housemade sausages & rotating craft beers.

Website ↗

Famous TV comics draw laughs at this stand-up comedy club with a variety of American eats.

30 Mississippi St (Buffalo)

Famous TV comics draw laughs at this stand-up comedy club with a variety of American eats.

Website ↗

Bada Bing

Nightlife

Sports bar & grill boasting a deep lineup of American grub & games showing on numerous TVs.

42 W Chippewa St (Buffalo)

Sports bar & grill boasting a deep lineup of American grub & games showing on numerous TVs.

Website ↗

Innovative American small plates & entrees join lengthy wine list in chic, candlelit environs.

56 W Chippewa St (Buffalo)

Innovative American small plates & entrees join lengthy wine list in chic, candlelit environs.

Website ↗

Cocktails, wine, coffee & internationally inspired eats served in a space with eclectic decor.

376 Grant St (Buffalo)

Cocktails, wine, coffee & internationally inspired eats served in a space with eclectic decor.

Website ↗

Eddie Brady's

Nightlife

Easygoing watering hole & American grill with a nostalgic vibe, dark-wood decor & outdoor seating.

97 Genesee St (Buffalo)

Easygoing watering hole & American grill with a nostalgic vibe, dark-wood decor & outdoor seating.

Website ↗

Easygoing watering hole with familiar pub grub & sports on TV in a casual setting.

85 W Chippewa St (Buffalo)

Easygoing watering hole with familiar pub grub & sports on TV in a casual setting.

Website ↗

Festive bar & grill serving house-brewed ales, with trivia nights, live music & a beer garden.

73 Hamburg St (Buffalo)

Festive bar & grill serving house-brewed ales, with trivia nights, live music & a beer garden.

Website ↗

This lively, sports-centric bar offers classic pub grub, plus cocktails & beer on tap.

1300 Sweet Home Rd

This lively, sports-centric bar offers classic pub grub, plus cocktails & beer on tap.

Website ↗

Burgers, wood-fired pizzas & other comfort food in an airy, casual venue with an industrial feel.

500 Pearl St (Buffalo)

Burgers, wood-fired pizzas & other comfort food in an airy, casual venue with an industrial feel.

Website ↗

Long-standing eatery known for steaks, burgers and wings plus macaroni salad.

3989 Main St

Long-standing eatery known for steaks, burgers and wings plus macaroni salad.

Website ↗

Lively spot for comedy shows, including all-ages ComedySportz Buffalo & 18+ shows, plus a bar & dining.

155 Chandler St (Buffalo)

Lively spot for comedy shows, including all-ages ComedySportz Buffalo & 18+ shows, plus a bar & dining.

Website ↗

Més Que

Nightlife

Draft beer, specialty cocktails & small plates in a lively, soccer-centric hangout with games on TV.

1420 Hertel Ave (Buffalo)

Draft beer, specialty cocktails & small plates in a lively, soccer-centric hangout with games on TV.

Website ↗

Cozy, pink-hued hangout offering cocktails, beer, and food at the bar, plus a pool table.

517 Washington St (Buffalo)

Cozy, pink-hued hangout offering cocktails, beer, and food at the bar, plus a pool table.

Website ↗

Buffalo's oldest tavern, open in 1868, featuring happy hour from Tuesday to Friday.

674 Ellicott St (Buffalo)

Buffalo's oldest tavern, open in 1868, featuring happy hour from Tuesday to Friday.

Website ↗

Wine bar and eatery for vino by the glass or bottle, plus tapas and beer.

1370-1374 Hertel Ave (Buffalo)

Wine bar and eatery for vino by the glass or bottle, plus tapas and beer.

Website ↗

Casual jazz club, wine bar and arts venue offering tapas and cheese plates in an intimate setting.

19 Wadsworth St (Buffalo)

Casual jazz club, wine bar and arts venue offering tapas and cheese plates in an intimate setting.

Website ↗

Cole's

Nightlife

Rotating taps & creative American pub grub served beneath pennants, mounted deer & carousel horses.

1104 Elmwood Ave (Buffalo)

Rotating taps & creative American pub grub served beneath pennants, mounted deer & carousel horses.

Website ↗

Quaint former school building housing a cozy comedy club also offering music acts.

3200 Elmwood Ave (Buffalo)

Quaint former school building housing a cozy comedy club also offering music acts.

Website ↗

Casual neighborhood bar and grill known for its wings, happy hours, and shuffleboard.

2067 Kensington Ave

Casual neighborhood bar and grill known for its wings, happy hours, and shuffleboard.

Website ↗

Trendy bar with a warm, historic vibe offering a vast range of whiskey & bourbon, plus casual bites.

320 Pearl St (Buffalo)

Trendy bar with a warm, historic vibe offering a vast range of whiskey & bourbon, plus casual bites.

Website ↗

Wings, burgers, and other Irish-style pub grub served in a relaxed bar that has shuffleboard.

474 Abbott Rd (Buffalo)

Wings, burgers, and other Irish-style pub grub served in a relaxed bar that has shuffleboard.

Website ↗

High Violet

Nightlife

Posh venue offering creative cocktails and small plates on a menu that evolves with the seasons.

710 Elmwood Ave (Buffalo)

Posh venue offering creative cocktails and small plates on a menu that evolves with the seasons.

Website ↗

Listed here?

You’ve earned the mark — get the BaseLocal’s Best badge for your site →. Want in? List your business →