The best bars & nightlife in Amherst

38 bars & nightlife we’ve checked and stand behind — with the story on each one. Not a ranking; a record.

Browse another shelf: all of Amherst’s best · Restaurants · Shopping · Beauty · Bakeries & Sweets · Arts & Culture · Entertainment · Hobbies, Books, & Crafts · Antiques, Thrift, & Vintage · Home & Garden · Health & Wellness · Cafes · Sporting Goods · Pets · Parks & Outdoors · Services

Pinned in Amherst today

This spot is open today.

Two pinned places a day in Amherst — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. List your business →

Paid placements are always marked.

Nightlife · 38 places · showing the latest additions first

Casual place with homestyle American fare, pizza & sports on TV, plus a patio & regular live music.

2970 Colvin Blvd (Tonawanda)

Casual place with homestyle American fare, pizza & sports on TV, plus a patio & regular live music.

Website ↗

Craving a proper pint without crossing half the county? Woodcock Brothers Brewery keeps it easy with fresh house beers on tap, a full…

908 Niagara Falls Blvd (North Tonawanda)

Craving a proper pint without crossing half the county? Woodcock Brothers Brewery keeps it easy with fresh house beers on tap, a full restaurant menu, and even cocktails and wine for your non-beer friends. The Wurlitzer vibe is classic North Tonawanda, and the to-go beers make weeknights nicer.

Website ↗

Buffalo Wings & Brewhouse is the neighborhood spot for live music every weekend plus 16 rotating taps heavy on local and upstate picks.…

653 Oliver St (North Tonawanda)

Buffalo Wings & Brewhouse is the neighborhood spot for live music every weekend plus 16 rotating taps heavy on local and upstate picks. Come for the signature wings (Buffalo, smoky dry rub, or house-made mambo), stay for the smash burger, beef on weck, and Friday fish fries.

From the North Tonawanda newsletter, September 11, 2026

Website ↗

Renaissance Club of North Tonawanda Inc is a members' clubhouse bar with old-school roots (their Giornale Piccolo newsletter dates to 1975)…

252 Vandervoort St (North Tonawanda)

Renaissance Club of North Tonawanda Inc is a members' clubhouse bar with old-school roots (their Giornale Piccolo newsletter dates to 1975) and plenty of ways to plug in... volleyball signups, Bills watch parties, and a rentable hall for your next shindig. Friendly, local, zero pretense.

From the North Tonawanda newsletter, September 7, 2026

Website ↗
Run a Amherst business? Two pinned spots a day — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. Advertise →

Relaxed hangout at the Golf Dome offering comfort eats, beer, live music & simulators for sports.

175 Brompton Rd (Tonawanda)

Relaxed hangout at the Golf Dome offering comfort eats, beer, live music & simulators for sports.

Website ↗

Whether your group chat needs a rally point or you just want to trade couch commentary for actual serves, Holidays Sports Bar and…

935 Harlem Rd (West Seneca)

Whether your group chat needs a rally point or you just want to trade couch commentary for actual serves, Holidays Sports Bar and Volleyball has indoor and outdoor sand leagues, dart leagues, a rotating menu with food specials, and a solid craft beer list that keeps post game hangs lively.

From the Cheektowaga newsletter, August 21, 2026

Website ↗

Founded over 50 years ago by Henry and Rose Wiechec, Wiechec's Lounge nails that no-frills neighborhood comfort, with hearty plates,…

1748 Clinton St Ste 1 (Buffalo) · ✓ checked Sep 17

Founded over 50 years ago by Henry and Rose Wiechec, Wiechec's Lounge nails that no-frills neighborhood comfort, with hearty plates, friendly chatter, and the kind of authenticity you can’t fake. When you want classic Buffalo warmth without fuss, this is your easy win for the week.

From the Buffalo newsletter, August 23, 2026

Website ↗

When you need a no-fuss place to catch the game, Sidelines Sports Bar and Grill keeps the TVs rolling, the wings crispy, and the beef on…

6036 Transit Rd (Depew)

When you need a no-fuss place to catch the game, Sidelines Sports Bar and Grill keeps the TVs rolling, the wings crispy, and the beef on weck legit. Build-your-own Bloody Marys, solid fish fry, and catering if you're hosting the crew this weekend.

From the Cheektowaga newsletter, August 27, 2026

Website ↗

Jack Rabbit

Nightlife

Jack Rabbit is the move when you want nightly live music and DJs supporting local talent while a scratch kitchen turns out rotisserie…

1010 Elmwood Ave (Buffalo)

Jack Rabbit is the move when you want nightly live music and DJs supporting local talent while a scratch kitchen turns out rotisserie chicken, cast iron pizzas, and mouthwatering sandwiches. Grab your crew, pick a room vibe from piano-cozy to game-room rowdy, and make brunch plans this week.

From the Buffalo newsletter, August 3, 2026

Website ↗

Hartman's Distilling Co. mixes the kind of craft cocktails you brag about, built on their own bourbon, rye, gin, and vodka. Slide into the…

55 Chicago St (Buffalo)

Hartman's Distilling Co. mixes the kind of craft cocktails you brag about, built on their own bourbon, rye, gin, and vodka. Slide into the tasting room for a view of the distillery, weekend brunch, or book a tour and tasting to nerd out on how the good stuff is made.

From the Buffalo newsletter, August 8, 2026

Website ↗

Grover's Bar & Grill has the burger locals brag about, voted best three years running, plus mammoth patties, that famous cheeseburger soup,…

9160 Transit Rd (East Amherst)

Grover's Bar & Grill has the burger locals brag about, voted best three years running, plus mammoth patties, that famous cheeseburger soup, and a menu that swings from specialty grilled cheese to wings, fish fry, and a shamelessly fun Grease Pit of deep-fried comforts.

From the Amherst newsletter, September 6, 2026

Website ↗

Rec Room

Nightlife

Rec Room keeps your week interesting with modern dueling pianos, rotating live band karaoke, and legit concert nights when you want a break…

79 W Chippewa St (Buffalo)

Rec Room keeps your week interesting with modern dueling pianos, rotating live band karaoke, and legit concert nights when you want a break from the usual spots.

From the West Seneca newsletter, September 12, 2026

Website ↗

Modern sports-pub chain boasting recliners plus high-concept bar food & a huge selection of beer.

4120 Maple Rd

Modern sports-pub chain boasting recliners plus high-concept bar food & a huge selection of beer.

Website ↗

Nietzsche's

Nightlife

If your week needs a soundtrack, Nietzsche's has been Buffalo’s live music bar since 1982, with a stacked schedule, weekly residencies, and…

248 Allen St (Buffalo)

If your week needs a soundtrack, Nietzsche's has been Buffalo’s live music bar since 1982, with a stacked schedule, weekly residencies, and cozy chaos in the best way. Grab a stool, catch the Saturday Celtic Sessions up front, then stick around as the night keeps getting louder and better.

From the Buffalo newsletter, August 18, 2026

Website ↗

Ballyhoo

Nightlife

Set by the Historic Buffalo River and Elevator Alley, Ballyhoo keeps it simple and excellent with house-made sausages and sides, Jam…

211 South Park Ave (Buffalo)

Set by the Historic Buffalo River and Elevator Alley, Ballyhoo keeps it simple and excellent with house-made sausages and sides, Jam Session and classic cocktails, plus draft and canned beers and wine by the glass. No reservations, just roll in when the craving hits.

From the West Seneca newsletter, September 1, 2026

Website ↗

Famous TV comics draw laughs at this stand-up comedy club with a variety of American eats.

30 Mississippi St (Buffalo)

Famous TV comics draw laughs at this stand-up comedy club with a variety of American eats.

Website ↗

Bada Bing

Nightlife

Need a spot where game-time cravings meet actual game time? Bada Bing is a downtown Buffalo sports bar and grill serving crowd-pleasing…

42 W Chippewa St (Buffalo)

Need a spot where game-time cravings meet actual game time? Bada Bing is a downtown Buffalo sports bar and grill serving crowd-pleasing eats, with a media-ready banquet room if your crew needs its own HQ. Grab pickup or delivery for couch viewing, or post up and let the big screens handle the stress.

From the Buffalo newsletter, August 14, 2026

Website ↗

Innovative American small plates and seasonal entrées meet a seriously deep wine list in a chic, candlelit setting at Bacchus Wine Bar &…

56 W Chippewa St (Buffalo)

Innovative American small plates and seasonal entrées meet a seriously deep wine list in a chic, candlelit setting at Bacchus Wine Bar & Restaurant, right in Buffalo’s entertainment district. Perfect for when you want to linger, talk, and feel a little fancy without trying too hard.

Website ↗

When you want cocktails that don't taste like copy-paste and food that actually travels, The Gypsy Parlor delivers with bohemian vibes,…

376 Grant St (Buffalo)

When you want cocktails that don't taste like copy-paste and food that actually travels, The Gypsy Parlor delivers with bohemian vibes, coffee, wine, and a fun mashup of local favorites and globally inspired plates like pastelillos and ramen. Pro tip, reservations help on busier nights.

From the Buffalo newsletter, September 21, 2026

Website ↗

Eddie Brady's

Nightlife

When you’re craving a proper beef on weck, jumbo wings, or the legendary Weck A Dilla, Eddie Brady's delivers the no-nonsense pub grub that…

97 Genesee St (Buffalo)

When you’re craving a proper beef on weck, jumbo wings, or the legendary Weck A Dilla, Eddie Brady's delivers the no-nonsense pub grub that hits the spot. Think Reubens, steak frites, and a Friday fish fry situation... classic Buffalo fare done right.

From the Buffalo newsletter, August 10, 2026

Website ↗

Buffalo Tap House keeps downtown buzzing with 31 drafts, a deep bottle list, and pub grub that hits the spot... think homemade burgers,…

85 W Chippewa St (Buffalo)

Buffalo Tap House keeps downtown buzzing with 31 drafts, a deep bottle list, and pub grub that hits the spot... think homemade burgers, wings, wraps, and veggie-friendly picks. TVs wall-to-wall for the big games and alternative tunes with a weekend DJ seal the deal.

From the Buffalo newsletter, September 18, 2026

Website ↗

Gene McCarthy's Old First Ward Brewing Company keeps it hyperlocal with taps running straight from the brewery to your glass and roughly…

73 Hamburg St (Buffalo)

Gene McCarthy's Old First Ward Brewing Company keeps it hyperlocal with taps running straight from the brewery to your glass and roughly nine of their own beers pouring daily. Add Trivial Tuesdays, Beer School, live music, and a seasonal beer garden, and you’ve got an easy weeknight escape.

From the West Seneca newsletter, September 5, 2026

Website ↗

Craving something new without driving far? Blue Bull Tavern pours a crowd-pleasing lineup, from their Hazy Owl IPA to CBW Let’s Go Pils,…

1300 Sweet Home Rd

Craving something new without driving far? Blue Bull Tavern pours a crowd-pleasing lineup, from their Hazy Owl IPA to CBW Let’s Go Pils, Ellicottville Blueberry Ale, Guinness and more. Pair it with picks from their food menu and call it a weeknight win.

From the Amherst newsletter, August 26, 2026

Website ↗

Vice

Nightlife

Vice is spinning cup & char pepperoni pies out of a blazing oven, stacking juicy burgers, and turning out comfort classics like wood-fired…

500 Pearl St (Buffalo) · ✓ checked Aug 20

Vice is spinning cup & char pepperoni pies out of a blazing oven, stacking juicy burgers, and turning out comfort classics like wood-fired wings and meatballs. Pair it with whiskey, wine, or a local beer and make it your treat this week.

From the West Seneca newsletter, August 28, 2026

Website ↗

Brunner's Tavern has been feeding the neighborhood since 1915, and the playbook still hits: a legit 12 oz steak sandwich, wings, a Friday…

3989 Main St

Brunner's Tavern has been feeding the neighborhood since 1915, and the playbook still hits: a legit 12 oz steak sandwich, wings, a Friday fish fry that tastes like home, plus that homemade macaroni salad you can snag by the quart for the week.

From the Amherst newsletter, September 19, 2026

Website ↗

Buffalo Comedy Collective keeps things lively with competitive, all-ages ComedySportz where the crowd decides who wins, plus weekly 18+…

155 Chandler St (Buffalo)

Buffalo Comedy Collective keeps things lively with competitive, all-ages ComedySportz where the crowd decides who wins, plus weekly 18+ late-night shows if you like your laughs a little spicier. Grab a drink and some bites, settle in, and let the improv chaos improve your week.

From the Amherst newsletter, September 2, 2026

Website ↗

Més Que

Nightlife

Buffalo’s original soccer bar and restaurant, Més Que channels a European matchday vibe with carefully crafted cocktails, good food, wine,…

1420 Hertel Ave (Buffalo)

Buffalo’s original soccer bar and restaurant, Més Que channels a European matchday vibe with carefully crafted cocktails, good food, wine, and beer fueling real conversation and the beautiful game. Est. 2012, it’s the city’s oldest craft cocktail bar and first soccer bar, so rally the crew this week.

From the Buffalo newsletter, August 25, 2026

Website ↗

Whether you need a post-shift bite or a not-quite-ready-to-go-home nightcap, House Of Charm keeps the party fed with apps, paninis, and…

517 Washington St (Buffalo)

Whether you need a post-shift bite or a not-quite-ready-to-go-home nightcap, House Of Charm keeps the party fed with apps, paninis, and desserts plus cocktails and cold beer. Swing through this week for live piano that brings Buffalo-meets-New Orleans vibes in a saloon that’s equal parts polished and lovable dive.

From the Buffalo newsletter, August 28, 2026

Website ↗

Buffalo’s oldest tavern since 1868, Ulrich's 1868 Tavern keeps the German grocery-saloon spirit alive with a cozy, locals-first vibe and…

674 Ellicott St (Buffalo)

Buffalo’s oldest tavern since 1868, Ulrich's 1868 Tavern keeps the German grocery-saloon spirit alive with a cozy, locals-first vibe and room for parties if you need one. They’re even teaming up with Osteria 166 to marry Ulrich’s bar with Osteria’s kitchen... a very Buffalo power couple.

From the Buffalo newsletter, September 15, 2026

Website ↗

Wine On Hertel is the cozy, dimly lit nook where you trade inbox pings for clinks, with an extensive wine list, craft beer and cider, plus…

1370-1374 Hertel Ave (Buffalo)

Wine On Hertel is the cozy, dimly lit nook where you trade inbox pings for clinks, with an extensive wine list, craft beer and cider, plus vermouth, sherry and wine-based cocktails. This week, pair it with homemade small plates from Chef Scott, and keep an eye out for their food and wine pairing events.

From the Buffalo newsletter, August 29, 2026

Website ↗

When you want the music to actually be the main character, PAUSA Art House delivers a true listening room vibe, with acclaimed local and…

19 Wadsworth St (Buffalo)

When you want the music to actually be the main character, PAUSA Art House delivers a true listening room vibe, with acclaimed local and touring artists plus a curated lineup of tapas, panini, desserts, wines, craft cocktails, local beers, and non-alcoholic beverages.

From the West Seneca newsletter, August 24, 2026

Website ↗

Cole's

Nightlife

Cole's keeps the taps changing and the pub grub playful, served under pennants, mounted deer and actual carousel horses... which is exactly…

1104 Elmwood Ave (Buffalo)

Cole's keeps the taps changing and the pub grub playful, served under pennants, mounted deer and actual carousel horses... which is exactly the Buffalo energy we love. Slide in for an easy night with an extensive beer lineup and classic neighborhood hospitality.

From the Buffalo newsletter, August 30, 2026

Website ↗

Buffalo's only literary-themed romantic horror bar offers moody, library bar vibes and drinks that fit shoegaze, darkwave, doom metal, and…

1122 Hertel Ave (Buffalo)

Buffalo's only literary-themed romantic horror bar offers moody, library bar vibes and drinks that fit shoegaze, darkwave, doom metal, and everything goth.

From the West Seneca newsletter, September 10, 2026

Website ↗

Rob's Comedy Playhouse turns a quaint former schoolhouse into a cozy, no-attitude room for stand-up and the occasional music night, with…

3200 Elmwood Ave (Buffalo)

Rob's Comedy Playhouse turns a quaint former schoolhouse into a cozy, no-attitude room for stand-up and the occasional music night, with community fundraisers sprinkled in. It’s the kind of close-to-home spot where comics actually hear you laugh... and you’ll want to stick around for another set.

From the Buffalo newsletter, September 8, 2026

Website ↗

Settle in at Snyder Bar and Grill for crispy, Buffalo-worthy wings, juicy burgers, and a neighborly vibe that feels like your living room…

2067 Kensington Ave

Settle in at Snyder Bar and Grill for crispy, Buffalo-worthy wings, juicy burgers, and a neighborly vibe that feels like your living room but with better bartenders. Call next on the shuffleboard, catch the game, and remind yourself why staying close to home tastes pretty great.

From the Amherst newsletter, September 15, 2026

Website ↗

Lucky Day Whiskey Bar keeps a warm, historic vibe with an expansive whiskey library, cocktails, and casual bites. Perfect for those Buffalo…

320 Pearl St (Buffalo)

Lucky Day Whiskey Bar keeps a warm, historic vibe with an expansive whiskey library, cocktails, and casual bites. Perfect for those Buffalo nights when you want to try something new... and maybe find a bottle you’ll be bragging about all week.

From the Buffalo newsletter, September 20, 2026

Website ↗

Keep your week easy and let Doc Sullivan’s handle the comfort food cravings, with cold beer, spirits, and pub fare in a true Irish-heritage…

474 Abbott Rd (Buffalo)

Keep your week easy and let Doc Sullivan’s handle the comfort food cravings, with cold beer, spirits, and pub fare in a true Irish-heritage neighborhood spot. It’s the kind of place that feels familiar by the second round, even if you only came for one.

From the Cheektowaga newsletter, September 16, 2026

Website ↗

High Violet

Nightlife

High Violet brings a posh-but-not-pretentious vibe, pouring inventive cocktails alongside shareable small plates on a seasonal menu that…

710 Elmwood Ave (Buffalo)

High Violet brings a posh-but-not-pretentious vibe, pouring inventive cocktails alongside shareable small plates on a seasonal menu that actually changes. Perfect for when your week needs a little sparkle and your go-to order needs a nudge.

From the West Seneca newsletter, September 6, 2026

Website ↗

Listed here?

You’ve earned the mark — get the BaseLocal’s Best badge for your site →. Want in? List your business →