The best bakeries & sweet shops in Cortland

When the craving hits, Cayuga Lake Creamery at The Dewitt Mall keeps it interesting with homemade flavors that rotate in-season, from classics to sorbets and even wine ice cream. Grab a scoop or take-home pints, and remember they also do ice cream cakes and catering.

From the Ithaca newsletter, October 1, 2026

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

Ice cream chain offering design-your-own creations hand-mixed on a granite slab, plus shakes & more.

New York Bagel turns mornings into a small victory with bagels, loaded breakfast sandwiches like the Adirondack and Skinny Atlas, and cream cheese flavors that run from jalapeño to lox spread. Pair it with a Crown City Chai or Red Dragon and you’re basically winning lunch too.

From the Homer newsletter, October 17, 2026

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

Whether it's a last‑minute dessert, birthday treat, or just a 'made it through Monday' pick‑me‑up, Price Chopper keeps it easy with a Bakery that covers everyday cravings plus online ordering for occasions and catering. Reliable, local, and perfect for when you remember dessert five minutes before the party.

From the Homer newsletter, October 7, 2026

Housed in a lovingly restored 1945 Lehigh Valley caboose, Frosty Caboose serves up the kind of scoop that feels like a small-town hug, with a friendly local crew and community vibes that make grabbing a cone feel like catching up with neighbors.

From the Cortland newsletter, October 15, 2026

When the week gets chaotic, Ithaca Bakery steps in with legit bagels, stacked sandwiches, and rotating soups like creamy tomato with basil or Italian wedding. Snag a pastry or a Grab 'n Go salad, or order ahead and let their catering rescue your next meeting.

From the Finger Lakes newsletter, August 8, 2026

Wide Awake Bakery turns local organic grains from Oechsner Farms and Farmer Ground Flour into crusty, wood-fired loaves, croissants, and even granola that tastes like someone read your carb-loving mind. Grab a loaf this week, support the grain chain, and enjoy bread that actually tastes like wheat.

From the Ithaca newsletter, October 9, 2026

Bakery chain known for warm cookies, ice cream & late-night deliveries.

When the snack window in your brain says "now," Mama Said Hand Pies-Press Bay Alley, a walk-up spot, delivers made-from-scratch hand pies with flaky, golden crusts, stuffed with comforting flavors from around the world.

From the Ithaca newsletter, October 22, 2026

When only real chocolate will do, Oracle Chocolates delivers rich, elegant truffles that make a weeknight taste like a celebration. Stash a few for post-dinner bites, surprise a coworker, or keep one in the freezer for emergency morale... Ithaca-approved indulgence without leaving the neighborhood.

From the Ithaca newsletter, September 22, 2026

Rashida Sawyer Bakery is the spot when only a serious dessert will do, with over 40 years of family recipes fueling legendary carrot cake and cheesecake with an unbelievable crust. Tiramisu is finally on the menu, gluten free Blackout Bars are legit, and you can order online for pickup, delivery, or Northeast shipping.

From the Cortland newsletter, October 23, 2026

When your week needs real bread, Woodpepper is turning out organic, hearth-baked loaves and tangy sourdough from a cozy downtown nook, made by a friendly baker who remembers your favorite crust. The menu rolls day by day, and there’s even a Side Dish CSA to level up dinner.

From the Ithaca newsletter, October 15, 2026

Casual cafe specializing in an array of sweets and pastries, plus fresh coffee and tea.