The best book, hobby & craft shops in Cortland

Odyssey Bookstore keeps book lovers busy with staff-curated picks, flexible subscriptions, and a lively calendar of reading groups, author conversations, and occasional themed happenings.

From the Finger Lakes newsletter, October 9, 2026

Autumn Leaves Books has been a locally loved spot since 1993 for those “I’ll just peek” visits that accidentally become an hour. They buy books, and with Angry Mom Records upstairs selling vinyl, cassettes, CDs, and comics, it’s an easy downtown Ithaca doubleheader for rainy afternoons or brain breaks.

From the Ithaca newsletter, October 2, 2026

Bookseller chain stocking housebrand eReader, plus a broad selection of titles for adults & kids.

All My Friends Books is a general-interest, all-ages indie with new and used reads, stationery, and bookish gifts for every kind of reader. Expect thoughtful staff picks, lively book clubs, easy preorders for big releases, and audiobooks or monthly subscriptions if you want your TBR handled for you.

From the Homer newsletter, October 6, 2026

From emergency strings to NYSSMA solos, Hickey's Music Center is the local go-to for sheet music, rentals, expert repairs, and a seriously stocked wall of brass, guitars and more. Pop in, find that part you need, then actually practice it this time.

From the Finger Lakes newsletter, August 6, 2026

Ithaca Guitar Works has a deep lineup of new and used acoustics, electrics, and basses from Fender, Martin, Taylor, Eastman, and more, plus amps, effects pedals, and folkie fun like banjos, mandolins, and ukuleles. Swing through, find a tone for porch nights and basement jams.

From the Finger Lakes newsletter, October 23, 2026

SewGreen is the rare spot where your next project and your conscience high five, with pre-owned fabric, local yarn, a bead bar, and all the notions... plus reclaimed Eileen Fisher finds. They also run approachable classes and youth apprenticeships, making reuse feel like the default, not a compromise.

From the Finger Lakes newsletter, October 16, 2026

Chain retailer carrying art & hobby supplies plus home decor (most offer classes & custom framing).