The best antique, thrift & vintage shops in Finger Lakes

If you enjoy the thrill of spotting something with a past and a little personality, Maeske's Antiques & Oddities is worth a browse. This Penn Yan antique shop is a local place to hunt for the unexpected…because apparently your shelves do have room for one more intriguing thing.

From the Finger Lakes newsletter, November 11, 2026

Finger Lakes Treasure Trove has four rooms of pre-loved clothing, housewares, books, toys, jewelry, and plenty of “I didn’t know I needed that” finds. It’s a nonprofit, so your thrifting also supports community programs, including a free pantry.

From the Canandaigua newsletter, November 10, 2026

Part treasure hunt, part community engine, Cayuga ReUse Center turns castoffs into genuinely useful finds for your home, shop, or project list.

From the Ithaca newsletter, October 11, 2026

Christopher Young Coins is a seasoned local appraiser and dealer with over 40 years helping collectors, heirs, and estate pros make sense of coins, currency, and precious metals.

From the Finger Lakes newsletter, October 8, 2026

Whether you're clearing out closets or hunting that just-right hidden gem, The Once Again Shoppe keeps the thrill of the find alive with a thoughtful, community-minded vibe. Donate the things you’re done with, browse for what you actually need, feel good knowing your support helps right here in town.

From the Penn Yan newsletter, November 6, 2026

If you love serendipitous shelf finds, the Friends of the Library Book Sale is a local ritual that turns donations into community impact, funding the Tompkins County Public Library, the Finger Lakes Library System, and literacy groups.

From the Ithaca newsletter, September 29, 2026

Over in downtown Geneva, Geneva Antique Co-Op mixes true antique gems with thrift-y surprises, and the best part is they actually haggle. If you love the thrill of the find, this spot rewards patient browsers and anyone who appreciates character over cookie-cutter.

From the Geneva newsletter, November 13, 2026

Morgan Laurent in Geneva is a go-to for a rotating mix of soulful art, mid-century furnishings, decorative oddities, and legit vinyl, all handpicked by Finger Lakes locals Francis Morgan and Dana Laurent. Perfect when your living room needs personality, not more mass-produced stuff.

From the Ontario County newsletter, November 12, 2026

Route 54 Antiques is a multi-dealer shop packed with furniture, primitives, china and glassware, architectural bits, and quirky man and woman cave collectibles that feel tailor-made for Finger Lakes homes.

From the Penn Yan newsletter, October 20, 2026

Long-standing nonprofit chain with a range of pre-owned clothing, housewares & more.

Second Editions Bookshop is a long-running, family-owned Elmira staple with shelves of affordable used reads, a cozy sit-and-browse spot, and plenty for kids. They’ll hunt down special orders, too, and you can browse online when the TBR pile somehow isn’t tall enough.

From the Chemung County newsletter, November 6, 2026

The Purple Iris Boutique in Horseheads is a thoughtfully curated trove of upscale consignment, handcrafted pieces by American artisans, and a surprisingly deep formal section. New treasures arrive daily, the vibe is cozy, and their Women Helping Women mission makes feel-good finds even better.

From the Chemung County newsletter, October 28, 2026

Antique Revival brings together fine antiques, art, and accessories, with an inventory that gives Victorian ornaments and other distinctive finds room to shine. It’s a worthwhile browse for locals who enjoy pieces with a little history and personality.

From the Chemung County newsletter, November 4, 2026

Evergreen Ithaca curates vintage and secondhand men’s staples, from broken-in denim to streetwear, with a focus on long-lasting, well-constructed pieces. Restocks happen constantly, the vibe is upbeat, and it’s an easy way to dress better while keeping things sustainable and local.

From the Ithaca newsletter, September 21, 2026

Seed Bomb is the Ithaca Commons spot for art, apparel, zines, stickers, and more from 40+ regional alternative artists, plus a welcoming third-space vibe with a growing zine library. They also crank out budget-friendly custom merch with low minimums, no set-up fees, and quick turnaround.

From the Ithaca newsletter, November 4, 2026

With 50,000 square feet, 1000+ dealers, and 1 million+ items, Ontario Mall Antiques Corporation is the Finger Lakes go-to when you’re after real-deal vintage, from Pyrex and vinyl to furniture and sports cards. Inventory turns fast, so swing through often... before your white whale walks out with someone else.

From the Finger Lakes newsletter, September 9, 2026

Thrift store chain offering used clothing, furniture, and other items to benefit rehabilitation programs.

Charity shop selling used items such as clothing and homeware.

Chain selling used clothes and housewares, electronics, books and other items donated to fund a shelter.

Three floors of unique gifts, antiques, furniture and home decor await at L W Emporium Co-op, a sprawling co-op of vendors where you can wander, discover handmade finds, and inevitably leave with something you didn’t know you needed… plus a story about who made it.

From the Finger Lakes newsletter, September 5, 2026

Pastimes is a small, colorful shop packed with ever-changing vintage finds, from art deco jewelry and classic threads to early postcards, buttons, and unexpected curios. Stop by to flip through vinyl, hunt for silver or ephemera, and maybe sell a treasure of your own... the thrill is that next week it all changes.

From the Finger Lakes newsletter, August 29, 2026

Elmira Trading Company buys far more than gold and jewelry, including electronics, video games, tools, instruments, collectibles, and antiques. If there’s something gathering dust at home, this Elmira Heights shop may be a handy place to see whether it’s worth selling.

From the Chemung County newsletter, November 13, 2026

Part treasure hunt, part Ithaca time machine, East Hill Antiques mixes wearable vintage, quirky postcards, and those just-right oddities you didn’t know you needed. The proprietor’s enthusiasm is contagious, so expect stories with your finds and a gentle nudge toward the piece that secretly belongs in your home.

From the Finger Lakes newsletter, September 16, 2026

Significant Elements is a nonprofit architectural salvage trove of antique hardware, vintage lighting, lumber, doors and windows, plus ever-changing decor. Score the just-right piece for your old-house project, then feel good knowing your buy fuels Historic Ithaca’s preservation work and youth job training.

From the Ithaca newsletter, November 11, 2026

If your place needs character, The Treasure Chest in Ithaca curates authentic antique furniture, lamps, rugs, clocks, and one-of-a-kind finds like vintage maps, books, and jewelry... all vetted for quality and history. New pieces roll in constantly, so pop back and snag that conversation starter.

From the Finger Lakes newsletter, October 22, 2026

Found In Ithaca is a multi-dealer vintage and antique playground in SouthWorks, where 45 dealers bring 19th century to mid-century furniture, plus estate jewelry, vintage clothing, pottery, art, ephemera and books.

From the Finger Lakes newsletter, October 15, 2026

Chain retailer buying & selling trendy secondhand clothing for teens & young adults.

Ithaca ReUse Center is where half-finished projects and mystery cords find purpose again, with solid furniture, building materials, and an eCenter packed with electronics and parts.

From the Finger Lakes newsletter, October 29, 2026

Grace Auction & Estate Gallery is a go-to for antique finds that feel like they’ve lived a little. It’s the sort of place where a five-minute browse becomes “okay, now I need to rearrange everything,” and you’re oddly thrilled about it.

From the Ithaca newsletter, September 8, 2026

If your go-to outfits are begging for a plot twist, Thank Me L8ter curates one-of-a-kind secondhand pieces that actually feel new to you, not new to the planet. Expect statement-making finds that spark compliments, built from a sustainability ethos locals can get behind.

From the Ithaca newsletter, September 20, 2026