The best antique, thrift & vintage shops in Irondequoit

23 places we’ve checked and would send a neighbor to. Open any one to read what we wrote about it.

23 places · newest first

Your business could be here.

Be at the top of Irondequoit's page when you're in Irondequoit's newsletter.

Put my business here

Local businesses pay to be shown here. A person checks every one.

McFall's Books (opens in a new tab)

1122 Monroe Ave · Rochester

McFall's Books is the cozy Upper Monroe spot with shelves of well-loved fiction, nonfiction, YA and children’s reads that still look…

Checked Aug 28

McFall's Books is the cozy Upper Monroe spot with shelves of well-loved fiction, nonfiction, YA and children’s reads that still look practically new. Swing by when your own book pile needs a refresh... they buy gently used titles and keep the curated finds flowing for Brighton readers.

From the Brighton newsletter, September 1, 2026

Lamp Repair (opens in a new tab)

680 Winton Rd N · Rochester

Got a beloved lamp on the fritz? Lamp Repair does everything in house, from antique restorations and brass or silver polishing to rewiring,…

Checked Sep 4

Got a beloved lamp on the fritz? Lamp Repair does everything in house, from antique restorations and brass or silver polishing to rewiring, rare parts on hand, and even custom builds, with same-day fixes sometimes possible.

From the Rochester newsletter, September 10, 2026

Leone’s Collectibles (opens in a new tab)

612 Stone Rd · Rochester

Leone’s Collectibles brings together toys, comics, sports cards, magazines, vinyl, action figures and memorabilia, with vintage finds and…

Leone’s Collectibles brings together toys, comics, sports cards, magazines, vinyl, action figures and memorabilia, with vintage finds and familiar favorites across the mix. It’s a good Rochester stop when you’re hunting for a particular piece or just want to see what catches your eye.

From the Rochester newsletter, November 5, 2026

Rosebud Retro (opens in a new tab)

89 Charlotte St · Rochester

Rosebud Retro nails the sweet spot between nostalgia and everyday wear, with thoughtfully curated pieces that make your closet feel new…

Rosebud Retro nails the sweet spot between nostalgia and everyday wear, with thoughtfully curated pieces that make your closet feel new again.

From the Rochester newsletter, August 5, 2026

Aaron's Alley (opens in a new tab)

662 Monroe Ave · Rochester

Family-owned since 1988, Aaron's Alley is the mom and pop hippie shop locals hit for vintage and boho threads, jewelry, incense that…

Family-owned since 1988, Aaron's Alley is the mom and pop hippie shop locals hit for vintage and boho threads, jewelry, incense that actually smells like chill, and a wall of Dead-inspired gear. Quick Monroe Ave detour when you need festival-ready layers, gifts, or to consign something and make closet karma.

From the Irondequoit newsletter, October 8, 2026

AMVETS Thrift Store (opens in a new tab)

400 Jefferson Rd · Rochester

Chain thrift store offering furniture for sale, along with an array of used wares as well as holiday and seasonal items.

Chain thrift store offering furniture for sale, along with an array of used wares as well as holiday and seasonal items.

The Shops On West Ridge (opens in a new tab)

3200 W Ridge Rd · Rochester

The Shops on West Ridge packs two floors with vendors offering antiques, furniture, toys, gifts, and collectibles, so a quick browse can…

The Shops on West Ridge packs two floors with vendors offering antiques, furniture, toys, gifts, and collectibles, so a quick browse can turn into a happily overstuffed afternoon. Each shop has its own character, and you never quite know what curious find is waiting around the next corner.

From the Rochester newsletter, November 17, 2026

Shop Intuit (opens in a new tab)

251 Park Ave · Rochester

Shop Intuit is a size- and gender-inclusive vintage clothing store in Rochester, with a welcoming spirit that extends beyond the racks…

Shop Intuit is a size- and gender-inclusive vintage clothing store in Rochester, with a welcoming spirit that extends beyond the racks through monthly wellness classes. A nice spot to find something with a little character, and maybe leave feeling a bit more grounded, too.

From the Rochester newsletter, November 11, 2026

Benedums Antiques and Gifts (opens in a new tab)

495 W Ridge Rd · Rochester

Benedum’s Antiques & Gifts packs 3,600 square feet with antiques, vintage finds, collectibles, and gifts, arranged in inviting little…

Benedum’s Antiques & Gifts packs 3,600 square feet with antiques, vintage finds, collectibles, and gifts, arranged in inviting little vignettes.

From the Irondequoit newsletter, November 18, 2026

Henrietta Mall Antiques (opens in a new tab)

945 Jefferson Rd · Rochester

Henrietta Mall Antiques fills its bright display areas with vendor-curated antiques and collectibles, from jewelry and décor to toys and…

Henrietta Mall Antiques fills its bright display areas with vendor-curated antiques and collectibles, from jewelry and décor to toys and sports memorabilia. Browse the glass cases for coins, cards, or an unexpected find, then try explaining how you went in for a quick look and left with a new favorite.

From the Irondequoit newsletter, November 5, 2026

All Things Antiques (opens in a new tab)

2788 Dewey Ave · Rochester

Whether you’re downsizing or on the prowl for something cool, All Things Antiques buys and sells jewelry, coins, sterling, watches, art…

Checked Sep 11

Whether you’re downsizing or on the prowl for something cool, All Things Antiques buys and sells jewelry, coins, sterling, watches, art glass, pottery, rugs, toys, even military pieces, and they’re not a pawn shop. Expect knowledgeable help, fair prices, and estate sale finds that change often.

From the Rochester newsletter, September 17, 2026

Panache Consignment (opens in a new tab)

1855 Monroe Ave · Rochester

Panache Consignment is where Rochester finds authenticated designer bags, luxe womenswear, and statement home pieces, all expertly curated…

Panache Consignment is where Rochester finds authenticated designer bags, luxe womenswear, and statement home pieces, all expertly curated so you can refresh your closet and living room without the sticker shock.

From the Rochester newsletter, August 11, 2026

Goodwill of the Finger Lakes (opens in a new tab)

451 S Clinton Ave · Rochester

Long-standing nonprofit chain with a range of pre-owned clothing, housewares & more.

Long-standing nonprofit chain with a range of pre-owned clothing, housewares & more.

Second Look Styling & Boutique (opens in a new tab)

709 South Ave · Rochester

Second Look Styling & Boutique is a South Wedge consignment spot proving secondhand can feel first-rate. Hunt secondhand finds, book a Sip…

Second Look Styling & Boutique is a South Wedge consignment spot proving secondhand can feel first-rate. Hunt secondhand finds, book a Sip and Shop or style party with friends, and consign your own treasures... luxury or designer appointments if your closet’s fancy.

From the Rochester newsletter, October 21, 2026

L W Emporium Co-op (opens in a new tab)

6355 Knickerbocker Rd · Ontario

Three floors of unique gifts, antiques, furniture and home decor await at L W Emporium Co-op, a sprawling co-op of vendors where you can…

Three floors of unique gifts, antiques, furniture and home decor await at L W Emporium Co-op, a sprawling co-op of vendors where you can wander, discover handmade finds, and inevitably leave with something you didn’t know you needed… plus a story about who made it.

From the Finger Lakes newsletter, September 5, 2026

Rochester Greenovation (opens in a new tab)

22 Flint St · Rochester

Whether you need a no-fuss dresser, extra plates before the in-laws descend, or that oddball vintage lamp you didn’t know you needed,…

Whether you need a no-fuss dresser, extra plates before the in-laws descend, or that oddball vintage lamp you didn’t know you needed, Rochester Greenovation is a reuse goldmine with everyday basics and one-of-a-kind finds. Their upcycling ideas and Night Market vibes will have you turning castoffs into keepers.

From the Rochester newsletter, October 28, 2026

Sequels Home Furnishings (opens in a new tab)

3450 Winton Pl · Rochester

Sequels Home Furnishings, near Irondequoit, is packed with well-made consignment finds, from Stickley and Ethan Allen to Mackenzie-Childs…

Checked Sep 19

Sequels Home Furnishings, near Irondequoit, is packed with well-made consignment finds, from Stickley and Ethan Allen to Mackenzie-Childs and Herman Miller, plus art and decor. Shop in store or online, snag a statement piece that already has a story.

From the Rochester newsletter, September 24, 2026

Ware to Wear (opens in a new tab)

777 Culver Rd · Rochester

If your closet wants character, Ware to Wear is the spot for well-picked vintage that actually fits real-life outfits. Expect quality…

If your closet wants character, Ware to Wear is the spot for well-picked vintage that actually fits real-life outfits. Expect quality fabrics, fun one-offs, and prices that make experimenting feel smart, not risky, whether you’re refreshing your look or hunting the perfect conversation piece around town.

From the Monroe County newsletter, November 11, 2026

Sew-ho (opens in a new tab)

716 University Ave · Rochester

Sew-ho is a woman-owned shop in Rochester with a curated mix of second-hand vintage clothing, new name-brand pieces, hats, bags, and shoes.…

Sew-ho is a woman-owned shop in Rochester with a curated mix of second-hand vintage clothing, new name-brand pieces, hats, bags, and shoes. Recent finds have included jackets and designer pieces, so it’s a good spot to browse for something with a little more personality than another trip to the basics rack.

From the Irondequoit newsletter, November 12, 2026

Historic Houseparts (opens in a new tab)

540 South Ave · Rochester

If your 1920s bungalow is begging for period-correct charm, Historic Houseparts has the good stuff... antique doors and hardware, vintage…

Checked Sep 22

If your 1920s bungalow is begging for period-correct charm, Historic Houseparts has the good stuff... antique doors and hardware, vintage lighting, stained glass, clawfoot tubs, and reproduction bits to match. Plus practical plumbing parts and restoration supplies, so your project looks original without the guesswork.

From the Rochester newsletter, September 30, 2026

CP Antiques & Collectibles (opens in a new tab)

1829 Monroe Ave · Loehmanns Plaza

If your shelves need stories, CP Antiques & Collectibles is a Brighton go-to for curated furniture, vintage jewelry, porcelain, and rare…

If your shelves need stories, CP Antiques & Collectibles is a Brighton go-to for curated furniture, vintage jewelry, porcelain, and rare odds-and-ends that are actually authenticated. Staff knows their history, the finds are locally sourced and ever-changing, and the hunt is half the fun.

From the Monroe County newsletter, October 21, 2026

Goodwill Clearance Center (opens in a new tab)

1555 Jefferson Rd · Rochester

Long-standing nonprofit chain with a range of pre-owned clothing, housewares & more.

Long-standing nonprofit chain with a range of pre-owned clothing, housewares & more.

A Second Thought (opens in a new tab)

349 W Commercial St #1800 · East Rochester

Thrift shop featuring books, furniture, and other household items, supporting Heritage Christian Services.

Thrift shop featuring books, furniture, and other household items, supporting Heritage Christian Services.