The best antique, thrift & vintage shops in Penn Yan

5 places we’ve checked and would send a neighbor to. Open any one to read what we wrote about it.

5 places · newest first

Your business could be here.

Be at the top of Penn Yan's page when you're in Penn Yan's newsletter.

Put my business here

Local businesses pay to be shown here. A person checks every one.

The Once Again Shoppe (opens in a new tab)

100 E Elm St

Whether you're clearing out closets or hunting that just-right hidden gem, The Once Again Shoppe keeps the thrill of the find alive with a…

Checked Oct 1

Whether you're clearing out closets or hunting that just-right hidden gem, The Once Again Shoppe keeps the thrill of the find alive with a thoughtful, community-minded vibe. Donate the things you’re done with, browse for what you actually need, feel good knowing your support helps right here in town.

From the Penn Yan newsletter, October 8, 2026

Geneva Antique Co-Op (opens in a new tab)

475 Exchange St · Geneva

Over in downtown Geneva, Geneva Antique Co-Op mixes true antique gems with thrift-y surprises, and the best part is they actually haggle.…

Over in downtown Geneva, Geneva Antique Co-Op mixes true antique gems with thrift-y surprises, and the best part is they actually haggle. If you love the thrill of the find, this spot rewards patient browsers and anyone who appreciates character over cookie-cutter.

From the Seneca Falls newsletter, October 23, 2026

morgan laurent (opens in a new tab)

100 Castle St · Geneva

Morgan Laurent in Geneva is a go-to for a rotating mix of soulful art, mid-century furnishings, decorative oddities, and legit vinyl, all…

Morgan Laurent in Geneva is a go-to for a rotating mix of soulful art, mid-century furnishings, decorative oddities, and legit vinyl, all handpicked by Finger Lakes locals Francis Morgan and Dana Laurent. Perfect when your living room needs personality, not more mass-produced stuff.

From the Penn Yan newsletter, October 14, 2026

Route 54 Antiques (opens in a new tab)

1888 Stiles Rd

Route 54 Antiques is a multi-dealer shop packed with furniture, primitives, china and glassware, architectural bits, and quirky man and…

Route 54 Antiques is a multi-dealer shop packed with furniture, primitives, china and glassware, architectural bits, and quirky man and woman cave collectibles that feel tailor-made for Finger Lakes homes.

From the Penn Yan newsletter, October 20, 2026

Goodwill of the Finger Lakes (opens in a new tab)

328 Eastern Blvd · Canandaigua

Long-standing nonprofit chain with a range of pre-owned clothing, housewares & more.

Long-standing nonprofit chain with a range of pre-owned clothing, housewares & more.