The best restaurants in Penn Yan

13 restaurants we’ve checked and stand behind — with the story on each one. Not a ranking; a record.

Browse another shelf: all of Penn Yan’s best · Nightlife · Bakeries & Sweets

Pinned in Penn Yan today

This spot is open today.

Two pinned places a day in Penn Yan — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. List your business →

Paid placements are always marked.

Restaurants · 13 places · showing the latest additions first

Wood-fired pizzas & breads earn raves at this stylish American spot offering gluten-free options.

100 Seneca St (Geneva)

Wood-fired pizzas & breads earn raves at this stylish American spot offering gluten-free options.

Website ↗

Taco Bell

Restaurants

Fast-food chain serving Mexican-inspired fare such as tacos, quesadillas & nachos.

212 Lake St

Fast-food chain serving Mexican-inspired fare such as tacos, quesadillas & nachos.

Website ↗

Casual diner chain dishing up classic American comfort fare, including all-day breakfast favorites.

813 Canandaigua Rd (Geneva)

Casual diner chain dishing up classic American comfort fare, including all-day breakfast favorites.

Website ↗

F2T Kitchen

Restaurants

Relaxed hotel restaurant & bar featuring a surf ’n’ turf menu & a large patio with lake views.

41 Lake Front Dr (Geneva)

Relaxed hotel restaurant & bar featuring a surf ’n’ turf menu & a large patio with lake views.

Website ↗
Run a Penn Yan business? Two pinned spots a day — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. Advertise →

Subway

Restaurants

Casual counter-serve chain for build-your-own sandwiches & salads, with health-conscious options.

472 Hamilton St (Geneva)

Casual counter-serve chain for build-your-own sandwiches & salads, with health-conscious options.

Website ↗

Penn Yan Diner

Restaurants

Daytime diner serving breakfast, sandwiches & shakes in an old-school setting since 1925.

131 E Elm St

Daytime diner serving breakfast, sandwiches & shakes in an old-school setting since 1925.

Website ↗

Quaint choice with antiques & scenic views & classic American steakhouse fare with wine pairings.

4069 W Lake Rd (Geneva)

Quaint choice with antiques & scenic views & classic American steakhouse fare with wine pairings.

Website ↗

The Rusty Pig

Restaurants

Burgers, BBQ & craft beer in a laid-back hub with ceilings & wall panels that give it a rustic vibe.

60 Seneca St (Geneva)

Burgers, BBQ & craft beer in a laid-back hub with ceilings & wall panels that give it a rustic vibe.

Website ↗

Subway

Restaurants

Casual counter-serve chain for build-your-own sandwiches & salads, with health-conscious options.

232 Lake St

Casual counter-serve chain for build-your-own sandwiches & salads, with health-conscious options.

Website ↗

Area chain restaurant offering creative pies, tons of toppings, wings & Italian subs.

812 Canandaigua Rd (Geneva)

Area chain restaurant offering creative pies, tons of toppings, wings & Italian subs.

Website ↗

Water St. Cafe

Restaurants

Easygoing local cafe for hearty American breakfast & lunch plates such as eggs, burgers & coffee.

467 S Exchange St (Geneva)

Easygoing local cafe for hearty American breakfast & lunch plates such as eggs, burgers & coffee.

Website ↗

Cam's Pizzeria

Restaurants

Counter-service chain offering NY-style pies & other standard pizzeria fare like pasta & subs.

476 Exchange St (Geneva)

Counter-service chain offering NY-style pies & other standard pizzeria fare like pasta & subs.

Website ↗

Kindred Fare

Restaurants

Kindred Fare nails that Finger Lakes, come-as-you-are energy with seasonal plates built to share and a pour that suits the mood. If this…

512 Hamilton St (Geneva)

Kindred Fare nails that Finger Lakes, come-as-you-are energy with seasonal plates built to share and a pour that suits the mood. If this week needs an easy, delicious reset with friends, their spirited cookery makes the table feel like the best seat in town.

From the Finger Lakes newsletter, August 29, 2026

Website ↗

Listed here?

You’ve earned the mark — get the BaseLocal’s Best badge for your site →. Want in? List your business →