The best cafes in Penn Yan

“Whether you're grabbing a creamy latte or a jug of A2 creamline milk, Sweet Acres Creamery keeps it real with minimally processed dairy from local regenerative family farms. Hearty sandwiches and fried cheese curds seal the deal, and many find A2 easier to digest.”

From the Geneva newsletter, September 22, 2026

“Amity Coffee Co. roasts its own beans, bakes pastries in-house, and keeps the vibe friendly enough that a quick cup turns into catching up with half the town. If you want a spot where the coffee is thoughtful, the baked goods aren’t an afterthought, and sourcing stays local whenever possible, this is your go-to.”

From the Penn Yan newsletter, September 26, 2026

“Geneva Gelato takes its "Created in Italy, Perfected in Geneva" motto seriously, churning gelato made with fresh, local ingredients, pulling authentic Italian espresso ground to order, and tempting you with cannoli, biscotti, and Cheesy Eddie's cheesecakes.”

From the Waterloo newsletter, September 23, 2026

“Java-Gourmet Company Store, Black Cat Bistro, Keuka Lake Coffee Roasters, and Seneca Salt Company is the rare spot where beans are roasted on site, the bistro cooks with local goods, and the shelves overflow with award-winning coffee-based sauces, rubs, and real Seneca Lake flake salt.”

From the Penn Yan newsletter, September 21, 2026