The best antique, thrift & vintage shops in Riverhead

19 places we’ve checked and would send a neighbor to. Open any one to read what we wrote about it.

19 places · newest first

Your business could be here.

Be at the top of Riverhead's page when you're in Riverhead's newsletter.

Put my business here

Local businesses pay to be shown here. A person checks every one.

Angels of Long Island, Inc (opens in a new tab)

14 Herkimer St · Mastic

Angels of Long Island, Inc is more than a thrift store, it’s part of a local charity providing goods and support to people facing crisis.…

Angels of Long Island, Inc is more than a thrift store, it’s part of a local charity providing goods and support to people facing crisis. Browse for a secondhand find and you’ll be supporting an organization that turns community care into practical help.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, November 21, 2026

Mastic Sales (opens in a new tab)

14 Herkimer St · Mastic

Mastic Sales is a local thrift shop for secondhand clothing and home goods, where a little browsing might turn up exactly the thing you…

Mastic Sales is a local thrift shop for secondhand clothing and home goods, where a little browsing might turn up exactly the thing you didn’t know you needed. Pop in for a practical addition to the closet or home, and let the treasure hunt begin.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, November 10, 2026

Mary Immaculate Thrift Shop (opens in a new tab)

Maple St. &, Browns Ln · Bellport

Whether you need a quirky mug, a cozy sweater, or a stack of old-school DVDs, Mary Immaculate Thrift Shop is the church-run treasure hunt…

Whether you need a quirky mug, a cozy sweater, or a stack of old-school DVDs, Mary Immaculate Thrift Shop is the church-run treasure hunt hiding in plain sight. Donate your usable goods, then swing back to discover something you didn’t know your home was missing.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, October 21, 2026

Angels of Long Island (opens in a new tab)

350-23 E Main St · East Patchogue

Angels of Long Island is a nonprofit resale spot for low-price clothing, housewares, and vintage finds, plus a food pantry that keeps…

Angels of Long Island is a nonprofit resale spot for low-price clothing, housewares, and vintage finds, plus a food pantry that keeps neighbors fed. They team with 1-800-GOT-JUNK and Evtek Recycling to reroute usable goods and recycle cans, so your closet clean-out actually helps people.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, October 11, 2026

The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center (opens in a new tab)

194 Front St · Hempstead

Thrift store chain selling donated items such as furniture, clothing, and other goods.

Thrift store chain selling donated items such as furniture, clothing, and other goods.

Encore Une Fois (opens in a new tab)

103 South St · Oyster Bay

Craving a little low-rise nostalgia and sparkly chaos? Encore Une Fois is a Y2K-focused thrift store with throwback finds and Instagram…

Craving a little low-rise nostalgia and sparkly chaos? Encore Une Fois is a Y2K-focused thrift store with throwback finds and Instagram Live Auctions that keep the good stuff moving fast, perfect for leveling up your weekend fits without raiding your high school closet.

From the Nassau County newsletter, October 23, 2026

Ketcham Inn Book Barn (opens in a new tab)

81 Main St · Center Moriches

Ketcham Inn Book Barn is a treasure trove with one of the South Shore’s largest used-book inventories, spanning Long Island history,…

Ketcham Inn Book Barn is a treasure trove with one of the South Shore’s largest used-book inventories, spanning Long Island history, fiction, YA, kids, art, nature, cooking and more, plus vintage records for good measure.

From the Riverhead newsletter, November 12, 2026

East End Hospice Thrift Shop (opens in a new tab)

52 Old Riverhead Rd · Westhampton Beach

From clean, well-organized racks of designer clothing and jewelry to housewares, vintage scores and furniture, East End Hospice Thrift Shop…

From clean, well-organized racks of designer clothing and jewelry to housewares, vintage scores and furniture, East End Hospice Thrift Shop makes browsing dangerously fun. 100% of proceeds benefit local children's bereavement services, so your weekend haul quietly does something beautiful for our community.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, October 30, 2026

Grandma Did It Better - Southampton (opens in a new tab)

1 Windmill Ln · Southampton

Grandma Did It Better brings together original vintage clothing across eras, from ’60s mod to ’90s supermodel, with every piece fully…

Grandma Did It Better brings together original vintage clothing across eras, from ’60s mod to ’90s supermodel, with every piece fully restored. If your wardrobe could use a little more character and a little less “I bought this because it was on sale,” this Southampton shop is worth a browse.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, November 16, 2026

Savers (opens in a new tab)

700 Patchogue-Yaphank Rd · Medford

Thrift store chain offering secondhand clothing, footwear, furniture, books & household items.

Thrift store chain offering secondhand clothing, footwear, furniture, books & household items.

Collette (opens in a new tab)

1 Hampton Rd · Southampton

Collette is the rare consignment find where Mies van der Rohe BRNO chairs, Milo Baughman chairs, chic lighting, rugs, and witty art share…

Collette is the rare consignment find where Mies van der Rohe BRNO chairs, Milo Baughman chairs, chic lighting, rugs, and witty art share the floor with new arrivals to browse, plus interior design and estate sales.

From the Riverhead newsletter, November 20, 2026

Barntique Village (opens in a new tab)

327 Montauk Hwy · Moriches

Barntique Village brings together a collection of independent antique, collectible, and artisan shops in rustic barns and outbuildings, so…

Barntique Village brings together a collection of independent antique, collectible, and artisan shops in rustic barns and outbuildings, so browsing can turn up anything from vintage toys and furniture to handmade décor.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, November 12, 2026

Starke Naked Vintage (opens in a new tab)

12 Bell St · Bellport

Starke Naked Vintage is a smart local go-to when your closet needs character, with Lydia Starke’s picks spanning Alaïa, Issey Miyake,…

Starke Naked Vintage is a smart local go-to when your closet needs character, with Lydia Starke’s picks spanning Alaïa, Issey Miyake, Chanel, Dior and Versace, plus wearable staples for women and men, bags and jewels. There are even under-$50 and under-$100 sections for guilt-free treasure hunting.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, October 28, 2026

Twin Hearts Vintage (opens in a new tab)

66-B Jobs Ln · Southampton

Twin Hearts Vintage has a new Southampton location open, serving up 40s to 70s jewelry, chic handbags, MCM glass, and the occasional…

Twin Hearts Vintage has a new Southampton location open, serving up 40s to 70s jewelry, chic handbags, MCM glass, and the occasional designer gem that makes you say I’ll plan an outfit around this. Your weekly reminder to choose character over cookie cutter.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, October 26, 2026

Islip UMC Thrift Shoppe (opens in a new tab)

350 E Main St · Islip

Islip UMC Thrift Shoppe is where locals score real finds without the rummage fatigue. Racks of clothing for men, women, infants, and kids,…

Islip UMC Thrift Shoppe is where locals score real finds without the rummage fatigue.

From the Islip newsletter, November 5, 2026

The Carriage House Shop (opens in a new tab)

17 Meeting House Ln · Southampton

The Carriage House Shop pairs the thrill of finding an unexpected vintage treasure with a feel-good reason to browse: proceeds support…

The Carriage House Shop pairs the thrill of finding an unexpected vintage treasure with a feel-good reason to browse: proceeds support Southampton History Museum programs and gardens. Set in a restored 1890s carriage house, it offers a distinctive mix of antiques, artwork, jewelry, books, LPs, dishes, and more.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, November 3, 2026

The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center (opens in a new tab)

319 E Main St

Thrift store selling clothing and other donated goods to benefit an adult drug and alcohol rehabilitation center.

Thrift store selling clothing and other donated goods to benefit an adult drug and alcohol rehabilitation center.

Island Thrift (opens in a new tab)

3657, 1800 NY-112 · Medford

Clean and spacious thrift shop for second-hand items including clothing, home goods and toys.

Clean and spacious thrift shop for second-hand items including clothing, home goods and toys.

Privet Estate Sales (opens in a new tab)

3 Industrial Dr Rear Building · Quogue

Privet Estate Sales turns Hamptons move-outs and renos into a rotating online trove of modern and mid-century furniture, lighting, outdoor…

Privet Estate Sales turns Hamptons move-outs and renos into a rotating online trove of modern and mid-century furniture, lighting, outdoor sets, and art pulled from real local homes. Sprucing the place up this week? Keep an eye on their latest auctions and pounce when that perfect piece pops up.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, October 29, 2026

Collette Home (opens in a new tab)

2231 Montauk Hwy · Bridgehampton

Collette Home is where Hamptons locals score one-of-a-kind furniture, art, lighting, rugs, and all the little finishing touches, with fresh…

Collette Home is where Hamptons locals score one-of-a-kind furniture, art, lighting, rugs, and all the little finishing touches, with fresh arrivals in Bridgehampton, Southampton Village, and Tanger Outlet. Want to lighten the load at home too? They make consignment easy so great pieces keep circulating locally.

From the Riverhead newsletter, November 8, 2026

The Retreat Boutique (opens in a new tab)

2102 Montauk Hwy · Bridgehampton

The Retreat Boutique is a good place to browse for men’s and women’s clothing, designer finds, accessories, handbags, and shoes in its Shoe…

Checked Nov 6

The Retreat Boutique is a good place to browse for men’s and women’s clothing, designer finds, accessories, handbags, and shoes in its Shoe Parlor. Even better, all store proceeds support The Retreat’s services for survivors, which are free of charge.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, November 14, 2026

Small Holdings Farm (opens in a new tab)

965 Main Rd · Aquebogue

Small Holdings Farm is a country antique store where farmhouse, cottage, coastal, and elegant industrial all play nice, which means chic…

Small Holdings Farm is a country antique store where farmhouse, cottage, coastal, and elegant industrial all play nice, which means chic decor without the fuss. When your living room needs a little "I actually tried" energy, this modern country trove delivers character pieces you’ll keep bragging about.

From the North Fork newsletter, November 15, 2026