The best restaurants in Riverhead

88 places we’ve checked and would send a neighbor to. Open any one to read what we wrote about it.

88 places · newest first

Your business could be here.

Be at the top of Riverhead's page when you're in Riverhead's newsletter.

Put my business here

Local businesses pay to be shown here. A person checks every one.

JC's Restaurant Mastic (opens in a new tab)

1086 Mastic Rd · Mastic

JC's Restaurant in Mastic is a family-run spot with decades of experience, a friendly atmosphere, and food cooked fresh to order. Check out…

JC's Restaurant in Mastic is a family-run spot with decades of experience, a friendly atmosphere, and food cooked fresh to order. Check out the daily lunch and dinner specials, and if gluten is a concern, the menu includes gluten-free pasta and bread options.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, November 22, 2026

Moriches Bay Diner (opens in a new tab)

62 Montauk Hwy · Moriches

Moriches Bay Diner has been serving up freshly prepared food with a family atmosphere since 1994. With breakfast, lunch, and dinner on the…

Moriches Bay Diner has been serving up freshly prepared food with a family atmosphere since 1994. With breakfast, lunch, and dinner on the menu, it’s a dependable pick when you want a satisfying meal without making a whole production of it.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, November 19, 2026

Bernie's Family Pizzeria (opens in a new tab)

225 Montauk Hwy · Moriches

Bernie's Family Pizzeria brings together classic pizzeria favorites and grill specialties, with standouts like garlic knot pie, Sicilian…

Bernie's Family Pizzeria brings together classic pizzeria favorites and grill specialties, with standouts like garlic knot pie, Sicilian pie, chicken rolls, lasagna, and meatballs. It’s a handy local pick when you want a familiar slice or feel like giving the grill menu a turn.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, November 16, 2026

Islip Country Deli (opens in a new tab)

240 E Main St · Islip

From breakfast sandwiches and griddle favorites to heroes, salads, and catering platters, Islip Country Deli has the familiar deli lineup…

From breakfast sandwiches and griddle favorites to heroes, salads, and catering platters, Islip Country Deli has the familiar deli lineup covered. It’s been serving Islip for over 20 years, so it’s a handy local pick when you want lunch without making a whole production out of it.

From the Islip newsletter, November 11, 2026

Back Country Deli (opens in a new tab)

70 Horseblock Road #4 · Yaphank

Back Country Deli serves up sandwiches, heroes, wraps, breakfast plates, and comfort-food classics, with house-made creations like the…

Back Country Deli serves up sandwiches, heroes, wraps, breakfast plates, and comfort-food classics, with house-made creations like the Chicken Yaphank Hero and Monte Cristo. It’s a handy local pick for a satisfying breakfast or casual lunch, especially when choosing what to order is the hardest part.

From the Riverhead newsletter, November 9, 2026

Hacienda De La Patrona Restaurant (opens in a new tab)

234 William Floyd Pkwy · Shirley

Hacienda De La Patrona Restaurant brings together freshly prepared Salvadoran and Latin American dishes, from pupusas to seafood and…

Hacienda De La Patrona Restaurant brings together freshly prepared Salvadoran and Latin American dishes, from pupusas to seafood and grilled meats. With generous portions and a welcoming family atmosphere, it’s a good pick when dinner calls for something flavorful and a little different from the usual.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, November 14, 2026

Los Amigos Pizzeria and Restaurant (opens in a new tab)

351 William Floyd Pkwy · Shirley

At Pizzeria Los Amigos, Shirley locals can find crispy Grandma pizza alongside heroes, salads, wraps, pasta, panini, and soups. It’s a…

At Pizzeria Los Amigos, Shirley locals can find crispy Grandma pizza alongside heroes, salads, wraps, pasta, panini, and soups. It’s a welcoming spot for comfort-food cravings, whether you’re settling in for a meal or bringing your favorites home.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, November 15, 2026

Wendy's (opens in a new tab)

168 E Main St · Islip

Fast-food burger chain serving sides such as chili & baked potatoes.

Fast-food burger chain serving sides such as chili & baked potatoes.

McDonald's (opens in a new tab)

107 E Main St · Islip

Classic, long-running fast-food chain known for its burgers & fries.

Classic, long-running fast-food chain known for its burgers & fries.

Five Guys (opens in a new tab)

855 Montauk Hwy · Shirley

Fast-food chain with made-to-order burgers, fries & hot dogs, plus free peanuts while you wait.

Fast-food chain with made-to-order burgers, fries & hot dogs, plus free peanuts while you wait.

Taco Bell (opens in a new tab)

551 William Floyd Pkwy · Shirley

Fast-food chain serving Mexican-inspired fare such as tacos, quesadillas & nachos.

Fast-food chain serving Mexican-inspired fare such as tacos, quesadillas & nachos.

Burger King (opens in a new tab)

862 Montauk Hwy · Shirley

Well-known fast-food chain serving grilled burgers, fries & shakes.

Well-known fast-food chain serving grilled burgers, fries & shakes.

Sonic Drive-In (opens in a new tab)

800 Montauk Hwy · Shirley

Fast-food burger & fries joint with an old-school feel, including retro drive-in service.

Fast-food burger & fries joint with an old-school feel, including retro drive-in service.

Applebee's Grill + Bar (opens in a new tab)

855 Montauk Hwy · Shirley

Full-service chain bar & grill providing hearty American eats in an informal setting.

Full-service chain bar & grill providing hearty American eats in an informal setting.

El Toro Restaurant and Deli (opens in a new tab)

255 Fulton Ave #B · Hempstead

Relaxed family-owned cantina serving tacos, burritos & other Mexican standards, plus margaritas.

Relaxed family-owned cantina serving tacos, burritos & other Mexican standards, plus margaritas.

Pollos Mario Steak House & Seafood (opens in a new tab)

75 N Franklin St · Hempstead

Laid-back and family friendly, Pollos Mario Steak House & Seafood delivers the kind of Colombian comfort that fixes weeknights fast, from…

Laid-back and family friendly, Pollos Mario Steak House & Seafood delivers the kind of Colombian comfort that fixes weeknights fast, from juicy roasted chicken to grill-showcase plates like churrasco, entraña, and parrillada, plus seafood paella and fresh natural juices that actually taste like the fruit.

From the Yonkers newsletter, September 21, 2026

La Hacienda (opens in a new tab)

392 Clinton St · Hempstead

Compact outfit serving a range of Central American specialties & enduring favorites like burritos.

Compact outfit serving a range of Central American specialties & enduring favorites like burritos.

J&R's Islip Steak House (opens in a new tab)

116 E Main St · Islip

J&R's Islip Steak House serves marinated steaks, premium burgers, combos, and seafood in a laid-back, family-friendly setting. It’s a…

J&R's Islip Steak House serves marinated steaks, premium burgers, combos, and seafood in a laid-back, family-friendly setting. It’s a welcoming local pick when everyone at the table wants something different, and nobody wants dinner to turn into a negotiation.

From the Islip newsletter, November 14, 2026

The Pizza Shoppe (opens in a new tab)

678 S Country Rd · East Patchogue

Skip the overthinking and let The Pizza Shoppe handle dinner this week with hot, cheesy pies and Italian favorites that never miss. Grab…

Skip the overthinking and let The Pizza Shoppe handle dinner this week with hot, cheesy pies and Italian favorites that never miss. Grab your favorite topping combo, share a few bites with the fam, and enjoy that reliable Brookhaven-level deliciousness you can count on any weeknight.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, August 23, 2026

Joes Pizza Restaurant (Shirley NY) (opens in a new tab)

433 William Floyd Pkwy · Shirley

Joes Pizza Restaurant (Shirley NY) keeps things comfort-first with classic pies, a Grandma pizza, and hearty picks like chicken parmigiana,…

Joes Pizza Restaurant (Shirley NY) keeps things comfort-first with classic pies, a Grandma pizza, and hearty picks like chicken parmigiana, garlic knots, and calzones. When dinner needs to feed a crew fast, their combo deals, heroes, wings, and baked pastas keep everyone happy without overthinking it.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, October 25, 2026

Island Sushi (opens in a new tab)

77 Northern Blvd · Shirley

Whether you’re craving classic sushi and sashimi, a teriyaki or tempura comfort detour, or a party platter that disappears faster than…

Whether you’re craving classic sushi and sashimi, a teriyaki or tempura comfort detour, or a party platter that disappears faster than weekend plans, Island Sushi in Shirley keeps it simple and solid. The Japanese menu hits the essentials without fuss, perfect for quick weeknight orders or low-key hangouts.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, October 31, 2026

Anthony's Pizza (opens in a new tab)

520 Mastic Rd · Mastic Beach

Local counter-serve chain that's a take-out/delivery staple for NY-style pies & other Italian eats.

Local counter-serve chain that's a take-out/delivery staple for NY-style pies & other Italian eats.

Pizza Hut (opens in a new tab)

534 William Floyd Pkwy · Shirley

Popular delivery, carry-out & dine-in chain known for pizza, wings & pasta, plus sides & desserts.

Popular delivery, carry-out & dine-in chain known for pizza, wings & pasta, plus sides & desserts.

Bella pizzeria (opens in a new tab)

44 Surrey Cir D · Shirley

Between crisp Grandma and Sicilian squares, quirky picks like Garlic Knot Pizza and Chicken Bacon Ranch, and all the Italian comfort hits…

Between crisp Grandma and Sicilian squares, quirky picks like Garlic Knot Pizza and Chicken Bacon Ranch, and all the Italian comfort hits from chicken parm heroes to penne alla vodka, Bella Pizzeria nails the craving calculus. They even do catering, so the next backyard hang basically plans itself.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, October 19, 2026

Cafe Gia (opens in a new tab)

700 Patchogue-Yaphank Rd · Medford

When the group chat can’t pick between a classic margherita and something a little extra, Cafe Gia handles both with homemade Italian…

When the group chat can’t pick between a classic margherita and something a little extra, Cafe Gia handles both with homemade Italian comfort. Think crisp pies, hearty pastas, and entrées that actually taste like Nonna cooked. They also cater, so your next get-together eats well.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, September 9, 2026

Pizza Time (opens in a new tab)

273 Neighborhood Rd · Mastic Beach

When you need a reliable pie night, Pizza Time has the classics and the fun stuff: square Grandma and Sicilian, thin Margherita, even…

When you need a reliable pie night, Pizza Time has the classics and the fun stuff: square Grandma and Sicilian, thin Margherita, even Chicken Marsala or Clam pies. Solid slices, easy ordering, and a menu that reads like every Long Island craving in one place.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, November 5, 2026

2 Spring (opens in a new tab)

2 Spring St · Oyster Bay

Sophisticated, modern American eatery plating tasting menus and multi-course dishes for intimate gatherings.

Sophisticated, modern American eatery plating tasting menus and multi-course dishes for intimate gatherings.

The Pizzeria of Yaphank (opens in a new tab)

311 Boulevard E · Yaphank

When dinner needs to be simple and actually good, The Pizzeria of Yaphank keeps it easy with pies that hit the spot. Hosting a birthday,…

When dinner needs to be simple and actually good, The Pizzeria of Yaphank keeps it easy with pies that hit the spot. Hosting a birthday, office thing, or Sunday crew, their catering brings the same quality straight to your get-together.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, October 13, 2026

270 Deli NY Inc. (opens in a new tab)

270 Jerusalem Ave · Hempstead

270 Deli NY Inc. is a nearby go-to keeping locals fueled with hefty sandwiches, fresh bagels, a legit hot bar, and a juice bar when you…

270 Deli NY Inc. is a nearby go-to keeping locals fueled with hefty sandwiches, fresh bagels, a legit hot bar, and a juice bar when you want to behave. The menu leans American and Latin, so one day it’s rotisserie chicken with rice and beans, the next it’s a shrimp special, plus easy catering.

From the Freeport newsletter, September 1, 2026

Camelitas (opens in a new tab)

400 Fulton Ave # C · Hempstead

Camelitas is serving the kind of Mexican you brag about to your group chat, with traditional recipes dialed up using quality ingredients…

Camelitas is serving the kind of Mexican you brag about to your group chat, with traditional recipes dialed up using quality ingredients and a modern touch. From cozy catch-ups to private celebrations or catering the whole crew, this spot nails flavor and keeps Hempstead’s cravings happily in check.

From the Hempstead newsletter, August 17, 2026

Starbucks Coffee Company (opens in a new tab)

455 E Main St · Islip

Welcoming coffeehouse with handcrafted coffee, espresso & tea, plus breakfast, lunch & pastries.

Welcoming coffeehouse with handcrafted coffee, espresso & tea, plus breakfast, lunch & pastries.

Ivy On Main (opens in a new tab)

103 Main St · Westhampton Beach

Ivy On Main brings New American cooking with a coastal polish to Westhampton Beach, pairing craveable comfort plates with a legit cocktail…

Ivy On Main brings New American cooking with a coastal polish to Westhampton Beach, pairing craveable comfort plates with a legit cocktail program and a new brunch that locals are already texting about. Easy pick when you want something polished but not fussy.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, September 7, 2026

Chicos Tex Mex Food Truck (opens in a new tab)

160 Margin Dr W · Shirley

Casual restaurant whipping up Mexican dishes, including popular birria tacos, and empanadas.

Casual restaurant whipping up Mexican dishes, including popular birria tacos, and empanadas.

Eternal Deli (opens in a new tab)

115 Main St · Hempstead

When you need a quick win, Eternal Deli comes through with egg sandwiches, omelettes, lox bagels, cheesy pizzas, and stacked subs and wraps…

When you need a quick win, Eternal Deli comes through with egg sandwiches, omelettes, lox bagels, cheesy pizzas, and stacked subs and wraps that fill you up. Perfect for grabbing breakfast, lunch, or an easy dinner without overthinking it, and yes, it tastes like Hempstead.

From the Hempstead newsletter, August 29, 2026

Okeno Sushi (opens in a new tab)

451 Glen Dr · Shirley

Craving a low-key, consistently good sushi fix close to home, Brookhaven folks keep Okeno Sushi in the rotation for clean flavors, classic…

Craving a low-key, consistently good sushi fix close to home, Brookhaven folks keep Okeno Sushi in the rotation for clean flavors, classic rolls, and no fuss. It’s the kind of spot you return to when you want fresh sushi without the scene, just straightforward fish and good vibes.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, October 24, 2026

La Bella Pizzeria (opens in a new tab)

342 Lexington Ave · Oyster Bay

La Bella Pizzeria in Oyster Bay turns cravings into rituals with authentic Italian recipes and a specialty pie lineup that goes beyond…

La Bella Pizzeria in Oyster Bay turns cravings into rituals with authentic Italian recipes and a specialty pie lineup that goes beyond basic. Think Grandma or Upside Down Sicilian, Chicken Marsala or Francaise pizzas, plus hearty entrées when you want more than a slice, and peek at today’s specials for inspiration.

From the Gold Coast newsletter, August 21, 2026

La Bistro (opens in a new tab)

6263 NY-25A · Wading River

Modern pizzeria serving simple pies, Italian dinners and salads.

Modern pizzeria serving simple pies, Italian dinners and salads.

Jalapeño (opens in a new tab)

114 N Franklin St · Hempstead

Tacos, pupusas, and other Mexican dishes share the menu at this casual place with live music and karaoke nights.

Tacos, pupusas, and other Mexican dishes share the menu at this casual place with live music and karaoke nights.

Sea cove (opens in a new tab)

361 Main St · Center Moriches

Modest eatery serving pasta, pizza, familiar Italian entrees, steaks & burgers in a warm atmosphere.

Modest eatery serving pasta, pizza, familiar Italian entrees, steaks & burgers in a warm atmosphere.

El Guadalajara Bar & Grill (opens in a new tab)

46 Fulton Ave Ste 6 · Hempstead

El Guadalajara Bar & Grill nails the fun side of Mexican dining with flavorful plates, cocktails that know how to mingle, and a steady…

El Guadalajara Bar & Grill nails the fun side of Mexican dining with flavorful plates, cocktails that know how to mingle, and a steady lineup of live music. When you want the vibe without the drive, their Guadalajara Digital portal lets you browse the menu, snag a reservation, or order in like a pro.

From the Valley Stream newsletter, September 11, 2026

FUNCHOS (opens in a new tab)

1156 W Main St

Serving the East End for over two decades, Funchos nails from-scratch, homestyle Mexican with a laid-back, come-as-you-are vibe. Think…

Serving the East End for over two decades, Funchos nails from-scratch, homestyle Mexican with a laid-back, come-as-you-are vibe. Think loaded burritos, enchiladas, and tacos made for messy happiness, plus fresh-squeezed margaritas... the kind of spot you hit this week when cooking feels optional.

From the Riverhead newsletter, October 25, 2026

TJ's Hero Shop (opens in a new tab)

328 Mastic Rd · Mastic Beach

A Brookhaven standby, TJ's Hero Shop turns out homemade sandwiches, crisp salads, and saucy wings made fresh daily, with menus that run…

A Brookhaven standby, TJ's Hero Shop turns out homemade sandwiches, crisp salads, and saucy wings made fresh daily, with menus that run from breakfast to dinner. Two convenient spots in Patchogue and Mastic Beach, and they cater if the whole crew shows up hungry.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, October 23, 2026

La Plage Bistro (opens in a new tab)

14 Station Rd · Bellport

La Plage Bistro brings Parisian bistro soul to Bellport with chef-crafted plates that lean local, think duck confit, steak frites, and a…

La Plage Bistro brings Parisian bistro soul to Bellport with chef-crafted plates that lean local, think duck confit, steak frites, and a seafood plateau, plus a sharp wine list and proper cocktails. Warm lantern-lit tables and a cozy bar make it an easy go-to for weeknights or low-key celebrations.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, October 31, 2026

Mama Lisa Restaurant (opens in a new tab)

1226 Montauk Hwy · Mastic

Mama Lisa Restaurant serves classic Italian dishes and specialty pizzas in a welcoming dining room, with takeout and online ordering for…

Mama Lisa Restaurant serves classic Italian dishes and specialty pizzas in a welcoming dining room, with takeout and online ordering for nights when cooking feels wildly overrated. Family recipes have been at the heart of the Mastic restaurant since 1999, and catering is available for gatherings big and small.

From the Suffolk County newsletter, November 21, 2026

La Margherita Pizzeria (opens in a new tab)

1231 Station Rd · Medford

La Margherita Pizzeria fires pies in a wood-burning brick oven that nails the char and chew, then backs it up with the comforting Italian…

La Margherita Pizzeria fires pies in a wood-burning brick oven that nails the char and chew, then backs it up with the comforting Italian classics you actually eat, all from a family that's run the place for three generations, with easy online ordering and catering for your Brookhaven nights.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, August 31, 2026

Nino's Pizzeria & Cucina (opens in a new tab)

201 Mastic Beach Rd · Mastic Beach

Since 1976, Nino's Pizzeria & Cucina has been the cozy, family-friendly standby for crisp pies, classic pastas, and all the Italian comfort…

Since 1976, Nino's Pizzeria & Cucina has been the cozy, family-friendly standby for crisp pies, classic pastas, and all the Italian comfort you crave. Solid for weeknights or gatherings, with a full menu and catering that keeps everyone fed without drama.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, November 3, 2026

Grana Trattoria Antica & Enoteca (opens in a new tab)

1556 Main Rd · Jamesport

Grana Trattoria Antica & Enoteca builds its menu around organic, locally sourced ingredients, with wood-fired pizzas, daily handmade…

Grana Trattoria Antica & Enoteca builds its menu around organic, locally sourced ingredients, with wood-fired pizzas, daily handmade pastas, fresh fish, and its own chicken chop prepared three ways. Its recipes draw on regions across Italy, so there’s more to explore than the usual red-sauce routine.

From the North Fork newsletter, November 21, 2026

La Volpe Ristorante & Anton Pizzeria (opens in a new tab)

611 Montauk Hwy · Center Moriches

A Long Island staple for 30-plus years, La Volpe Ristorante & Anton Pizzeria blends the Volpe family’s Sicilian roots with crowd-pleasing…

A Long Island staple for 30-plus years, La Volpe Ristorante & Anton Pizzeria blends the Volpe family’s Sicilian roots with crowd-pleasing Italian comfort, from crisp, cheesy pies to plates built for lingering. Ideal for this week’s low-stress dinner plan or a family-style feast to share.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, August 8, 2026

Tuckers Taproom & Smokehouse (opens in a new tab)

9095 Sound Ave · Mattituck

Whether you need a no-fuss weeknight fix or a reliable crowd-pleaser for that backyard thing, Tucker's Taproom & Smokehouse turns out…

Whether you need a no-fuss weeknight fix or a reliable crowd-pleaser for that backyard thing, Tucker's Taproom & Smokehouse turns out slow-smoked meats, house-made sauces, signature rubs, and scratch-made sides with local taproom vibes that feel like, yep, this is our spot.

From the North Fork newsletter, November 17, 2026

The Chicken Spot Inc (opens in a new tab)

235 N Sea Rd · Southampton

Keep weekday dinners easy with The Chicken Spot Inc, serving authentic Latin American comfort that actually hits the spot. Homestyle…

Keep weekday dinners easy with The Chicken Spot Inc, serving authentic Latin American comfort that actually hits the spot. Homestyle flavors, saucy classics, and plenty of juicy goodness from the Southampton and Hampton Bays kitchens... perfect for those nights when you want real flavor without the dishes.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, November 1, 2026

La Parmigiana (opens in a new tab)

44-48 NY-27A · Southampton

Since 1974, La Parmigiana has been the village staple for cheese-loving, Sicilian-rooted comfort that makes Tuesday feel like Sunday…

Since 1974, La Parmigiana has been the village staple for cheese-loving, Sicilian-rooted comfort that makes Tuesday feel like Sunday dinner. House-made sauces, dressings, and all the classic red-sauce plates keep it simple and satisfying, perfect when you want big flavor with zero fuss.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, November 12, 2026

The Pigs BBQ Hideout (opens in a new tab)

174 Islip Ave · Islip

Save yourself the charcoal splinters and let The Pigs BBQ Hideout handle dinner. A delivery-first barbecue outfit that leans into saucy,…

Save yourself the charcoal splinters and let The Pigs BBQ Hideout handle dinner. A delivery-first barbecue outfit that leans into saucy, smoky comfort, perfect when you crave slow-cooked flavor without babysitting a smoker, so queue it up this week and reclaim your evening.

From the Islip newsletter, October 19, 2026

Yama Q (opens in a new tab)

2395 Montauk Hwy · Bridgehampton

Small, quiet choice for sushi, stir-fries & non-Asian items like wraps & burritos.

Small, quiet choice for sushi, stir-fries & non-Asian items like wraps & burritos.

Wings 'n Things (opens in a new tab)

519 Fulton Ave · Hempstead

Wings 'n Things has been frying it right since 1988, serving fresh, crispy chicken with homemade sides and fall-off-the-bone ribs that…

Wings 'n Things has been frying it right since 1988, serving fresh, crispy chicken with homemade sides and fall-off-the-bone ribs that absolutely slap. Bookmark it for this week’s weeknight cravings or your next crew hang, and let their decades of catering chops keep everyone quiet, busy, happy.

From the Huntington newsletter, August 8, 2026

Tellers: An American Chophouse (opens in a new tab)

605 E Main St · Islip

Tellers: An American Chophouse is the kind of local institution you save for when you're feeling fancy, then remember why you should go…

Tellers: An American Chophouse is the kind of local institution you save for when you're feeling fancy, then remember why you should go more often. Celebrating 25 years of gilded elegance, it pairs classic chophouse indulgence with a Legacy Brunch and new private-event digs at Tellers Next Door this week.

From the Islip newsletter, October 17, 2026

Turkuaz Grill (opens in a new tab)

40 McDermott Ave

When you're craving smoky lamb chops, tender doner, and mezze that actually taste homemade, Turkuaz Grill delivers. Think hummus, baba…

When you're craving smoky lamb chops, tender doner, and mezze that actually taste homemade, Turkuaz Grill delivers. Think hummus, baba ganoush, Turkish cigars, branzino and kofta plates that hit the spot, a Riverhead staple locals lean on when they want dinner that feels special without fuss.

From the North Fork newsletter, November 22, 2026

Roadhouse Jr Pizza Truck (opens in a new tab)

1111 W Main St

Whether it's a backyard birthday, business lunch, or the wedding cousin Joe promised to plan, Roadhouse Jr Pizza Truck brings hot pies to…

Whether it's a backyard birthday, business lunch, or the wedding cousin Joe promised to plan, Roadhouse Jr Pizza Truck brings hot pies to your crew this week. Straightforward booking for 15 to 1000 guests, so you can feed the North Fork without stress and still claim all the credit.

From the North Fork newsletter, October 29, 2026

Sant Ambroeus Southampton (opens in a new tab)

30 Main St · Southampton

At Sant Ambroeus Southampton, expect Milanese dishes built on local seafood and farmers’ market finds, an all-day rhythm from cappuccino to…

At Sant Ambroeus Southampton, expect Milanese dishes built on local seafood and farmers’ market finds, an all-day rhythm from cappuccino to aperitivo.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, November 5, 2026

Caruso's Pizzeria (opens in a new tab)

1104 Old Country Rd

Caruso's Pizzeria has been family-owned in Riverhead since 1974, serving thin-crust pizza alongside Italian comfort-food favorites like…

Caruso's Pizzeria has been family-owned in Riverhead since 1974, serving thin-crust pizza alongside Italian comfort-food favorites like grandma pizza, lasagna and chicken marsala. It’s a solid pick when the craving calls for familiar recipes, a relaxed meal, or a generous spread catered for a gathering.

From the North Fork newsletter, November 13, 2026

Sakura House (opens in a new tab)

540B Montauk Hwy · East Quogue

Whether you're craving a tight, super-fresh roll or a comforting teriyaki situation, Sakura House keeps it simple and tasty. Friendly…

Whether you're craving a tight, super-fresh roll or a comforting teriyaki situation, Sakura House keeps it simple and tasty. Friendly folks, fast takeout, and consistently good Japanese staples make it a go-to when the fridge is judging you and the couch is calling.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, November 14, 2026

Smoke Shack BBQ (opens in a new tab)

792 Montauk Hwy · Center Moriches

Smoke Shack BBQ keeps it casual and dialed into the classics, from tender brisket and pulled pork to corned-beef sandwiches, ribs and…

Checked Aug 27

Smoke Shack BBQ keeps it casual and dialed into the classics, from tender brisket and pulled pork to corned-beef sandwiches, ribs and wings. It’s the kind of local spot you call when dinner needs smoke, sauce and zero fuss, then you promptly guard your leftovers from roommates.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, September 3, 2026

Shinnecock Lobster Factory (opens in a new tab)

42 Montauk Hwy · Southampton

Shinnecock Lobster Factory serves famous lobster rolls and local seafood favorites, including crab cakes, at its roadside Southampton spot.…

Shinnecock Lobster Factory serves famous lobster rolls and local seafood favorites, including crab cakes, at its roadside Southampton spot. It’s a handy local go-to for a seafood fix, and the catering menu can bring the lobster-roll love to your next gathering.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, November 13, 2026

Angela's Pizzeria (opens in a new tab)

192 Islip Ave · Islip

Angela's Pizzeria keeps Islip fed with creative specialty pies and classic comfort, plus a kids' menu for the picky eaters. Think Islip…

Angela's Pizzeria keeps Islip fed with creative specialty pies and classic comfort, plus a kids' menu for the picky eaters. Think Islip Avenue Pizza with vodka sauce and burrata, the garlic-knot-crusted Angry Italian, and even a Notorious Mac or Chicken Waffle pie when you want something fun.

From the Islip newsletter, November 6, 2026

Captain Jack's On The Coast (opens in a new tab)

1109 Noyack Rd · Southampton

Whether you’re craving fresh seafood or classic American comfort with a coastal twist, Captain Jack's On The Coast keeps it laid-back with…

Whether you’re craving fresh seafood or classic American comfort with a coastal twist, Captain Jack's On The Coast keeps it laid-back with a full bar, a legit kids’ menu, and waterfront views locals actually brag about. Easy spot for weeknights, birthday dinners, or whenever the water is calling.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, October 12, 2026

Melrose East Restaurant and Pizza (opens in a new tab)

801 County Rd 39 #2 · Southampton

Skip the “what’s for dinner” debate and let Melrose East Restaurant & Pizza handle it, from Grandma and Sicilian pies to crowd-pleasers…

Skip the “what’s for dinner” debate and let Melrose East Restaurant & Pizza handle it, from Grandma and Sicilian pies to crowd-pleasers like Chicken Parmigiana and Penne Alla Vodka pizza. Solid salads, classic apps, and a gluten-free option mean everyone at home gets fed fast.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, October 15, 2026

Sushi by Bou Westhampton Beach @ Sydney’s Taylor Made Cuisine (opens in a new tab)

32 Mill Rd A · Westhampton Beach

Sushi by Bou Westhampton Beach @ Sydney’s Taylor Made Cuisine is an intimate omakase hideaway where seasoned chefs handle the magic. Choose…

Sushi by Bou Westhampton Beach @ Sydney’s Taylor Made Cuisine is an intimate omakase hideaway where seasoned chefs handle the magic. Choose the 12-Course Signature Omakase or go full treat-yourself with Bou Reserve, then settle in as each bite hits that perfect tradition-meets-innovation sweet spot.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, October 8, 2026

Limoncello Ristorante (opens in a new tab)

21 Hill St · Southampton

When your group chat is stuck on where to eat, Limoncello Ristorante brings the coastal ease, from wood-fired pizzas and vibrant pastas to…

When your group chat is stuck on where to eat, Limoncello Ristorante brings the coastal ease, from wood-fired pizzas and vibrant pastas to signature limoncello cocktails. Book ahead, order in, or plot your next celebration, then let that sunlit, garden-driven menu do the heavy lifting.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, November 19, 2026

El Matador Restaurant (opens in a new tab)

680 NY-112 · East Patchogue

Cozy, casual, and reliably tasty, El Matador Restaurant is the Patchogue spot when you want sizzling fajitas, margaritas, and familiar…

Cozy, casual, and reliably tasty, El Matador Restaurant is the Patchogue spot when you want sizzling fajitas, margaritas, and familiar Spanish comfort without fuss. It’s the kind of place you meet friends, overorder the chips, then remember why you’re a regular.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, September 9, 2026

The Birchwood of Polish Town (opens in a new tab)

512 Pulaski St

Craving old-school warmth without turning on the stove this week? The Birchwood of Polish Town plates Polish classics with American comfort…

Craving old-school warmth without turning on the stove this week? The Birchwood of Polish Town plates Polish classics with American comfort in a 1920s tavern vibe, all tin ceiling and memorabilia, plus a brunch buffet and to-go trays when the whole crew shows up.

From the Riverhead newsletter, October 23, 2026

Mango Tango (opens in a new tab)

496 E Main St · Islip

When you can’t decide between sushi and a plate of Chinese comfort food, Mango Tango makes a happy case for having both. This casual Asian…

When you can’t decide between sushi and a plate of Chinese comfort food, Mango Tango makes a happy case for having both. This casual Asian fusion spot also has a bar serving beer, sake and cocktails, so dinner can take whichever delicious direction the evening demands.

From the Islip newsletter, November 15, 2026

FĒNIKS Cuisine and Cocktails (opens in a new tab)

75 Jobs Ln · Southampton

Chef Douglas Gulija’s FĒNIKS Cuisine and Cocktails brings his Plaza Cafe pedigree to a seasonally driven, locally sourced take on coastal…

Chef Douglas Gulija’s FĒNIKS Cuisine and Cocktails brings his Plaza Cafe pedigree to a seasonally driven, locally sourced take on coastal dining, with three vibes to match your mood: an intimate dining room, an eight-movement chef’s counter experience, or an upstairs lounge pouring precise, expressive cocktails.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, October 19, 2026

il Piccolo Villaggio Ristorante (opens in a new tab)

260 Islip Ave · Islip

Il Piccolo Villaggio Ristorante nails the classics with dishes like Insalata Caprese and Linguine alla Vongole, plus daily chef specials…

Il Piccolo Villaggio Ristorante nails the classics with dishes like Insalata Caprese and Linguine alla Vongole, plus daily chef specials and a thoughtful wine, beer, and cocktail lineup.

From the Islip newsletter, November 2, 2026

The Gourmet Bagel Co (opens in a new tab)

1105 Old Country Rd

The Gourmet Bagel Co. bakes bagels fresh daily, but there’s plenty beyond the dozen: gourmet breakfast and lunch sandwiches, panini,…

The Gourmet Bagel Co. bakes bagels fresh daily, but there’s plenty beyond the dozen: gourmet breakfast and lunch sandwiches, panini, salads, pastries, and specialty coffees. It’s a handy Riverhead pick for a quick bite or a more generous breakfast spread, with catering available too.

From the Riverhead newsletter, November 4, 2026

Drifters Kitchen and Bar (opens in a new tab)

1600 Middle Country Rd · Ridge

Eatery serving American fare and cocktails in a laid-back atmosphere with a bar and takeout.

Eatery serving American fare and cocktails in a laid-back atmosphere with a bar and takeout.

Tweed's Restaurant (opens in a new tab)

17 E Main St

Tweed's Restaurant is that Riverhead classic where bison burgers and steaks meet a lovingly restored 1896 tavern vibe, complete with the…

Tweed's Restaurant is that Riverhead classic where bison burgers and steaks meet a lovingly restored 1896 tavern vibe, complete with the mahogany and marble bar from the 1893 Exposition. Go for the local-forward menu, stay for the bourbon list, including the full Pappy Van Winkle lineup.

From the North Fork newsletter, November 15, 2026

Showwin Japanese Cuisine Southampton (opens in a new tab)

1678 County Rd 39 · Southampton

Showwin Japanese Cuisine Southampton is known for extremely fresh, tasty sushi and friendly service in a stylish but comfortable setting.…

Showwin Japanese Cuisine Southampton is known for extremely fresh, tasty sushi and friendly service in a stylish but comfortable setting. Settle into a booth or try the traditional no-shoes seating, a nice change of pace from the usual dinner routine.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, November 22, 2026

Michelangelo Pizzeria (opens in a new tab)

10095 Main Rd · Mattituck

Past the pizzeria storefront, Michelangelo Pizzeria doubles as a full-on Italian spot with a newly renovated dining room, an extensive…

Past the pizzeria storefront, Michelangelo Pizzeria doubles as a full-on Italian spot with a newly renovated dining room, an extensive lineup of specialty pies, generous classics, and a legit bar. Weekly specials keep things interesting, and yes, the tiramisu rumors are apparently true.

From the North Fork newsletter, October 19, 2026

Calissa Hamptons (opens in a new tab)

1020 Montauk Hwy · Water Mill

Calissa Hamptons brings Cycladic-soul energy to your week with abundant Greek feasts, Aegean-inspired plates, and a cellar built for…

Calissa Hamptons brings Cycladic-soul energy to your week with abundant Greek feasts, Aegean-inspired plates, and a cellar built for Mediterranean sipping, honored annually with Wine Spectator’s Award of Excellence. Think lingering dinners, live music, and a little dancing under the stars with your favorite people.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, October 30, 2026

Bayberry (opens in a new tab)

501 E Main St · Islip

Whether you’re catching up at the bar during happy hour, lingering over weekend brunch, or posting up on the patio when the weather…

Whether you’re catching up at the bar during happy hour, lingering over weekend brunch, or posting up on the patio when the weather behaves, Bayberry brings a fresh, seasonal American menu and an easygoing crowd. It’s the kind of spot you recommend before someone even asks.

From the Islip newsletter, October 21, 2026

La Buena Vida Spanish Restaurant (opens in a new tab)

714 Montauk Hwy · Moriches

Craving saffron and sunshine vibes without leaving the neighborhood? La Buena Vida Spanish Restaurant turns out paella, grilled octopus,…

Craving saffron and sunshine vibes without leaving the neighborhood? La Buena Vida Spanish Restaurant turns out paella, grilled octopus, and other Mediterranean comforts, with a lively bar and a relaxed lakeside patio. They’ll also cater or host your next get-together, so you can actually enjoy it.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, October 18, 2026

Harp & Hound (opens in a new tab)

528 E Main St · Islip

When the week calls for cozy pub fare, a pint, and a family-friendly scene, Harp & Hound hits the spot. Expect Irish-American comfort…

When the week calls for cozy pub fare, a pint, and a family-friendly scene, Harp & Hound hits the spot. Expect Irish-American comfort staples, a solid beer and cocktail list, and neighborhood energy that makes weeknights better... plus online ordering and catering if you’re hosting.

From the Islip newsletter, October 23, 2026

Americano Pie Bar (opens in a new tab)

517 E Main St · Islip

Americano Pie Bar nails that casual night out with classic Italian dishes given a smart Americano twist, from crisp pies and a gluten-free…

Americano Pie Bar nails that casual night out with classic Italian dishes given a smart Americano twist, from crisp pies and a gluten-free cauliflower crust to a legit steak night, plus cocktails built with fresh ingredients and a wine list locals quietly brag about. Weekend brunch doesn't hurt either.

From the Islip newsletter, October 29, 2026

RUMBA Island Inspired Cuisine & Rum Bar (opens in a new tab)

43 Canoe Place Rd · Hampton Bays

When the week needs a reset, RUMBA Island Inspired Cuisine & Rum Bar delivers island plates like coconut shrimp, Dominican ribs, and duck…

When the week needs a reset, RUMBA Island Inspired Cuisine & Rum Bar delivers island plates like coconut shrimp, Dominican ribs, and duck empanadas, plus proper rum cocktails, easy reggae, and Shinnecock Bay views that do most of the stress relief for you.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, October 31, 2026

Haiku Sushi (opens in a new tab)

40 E Main St

Haiku Sushi keeps Riverhead’s maki cravings in check with fresh, handcrafted sushi and sashimi, plus comforting soups and salads in a…

Haiku Sushi keeps Riverhead’s maki cravings in check with fresh, handcrafted sushi and sashimi, plus comforting soups and salads in a relaxed, unfussy setting. Friendly pros, plenty of classic rolls from crunchy spicy tuna to shrimp tempura, and prices that feel fair make it a dependable local go-to.

From the North Fork newsletter, November 18, 2026

Olga's (opens in a new tab)

40b E Main St

Olga’s keeps Riverhead mornings simple and satisfying, serving straightforward breakfast your sleepy brain can trust. When you need a…

Olga’s keeps Riverhead mornings simple and satisfying, serving straightforward breakfast your sleepy brain can trust. When you need a no-drama bite before errands or after the gym, order online for a fast pickup and get back to real life with something warm and reliably good.

From the North Fork newsletter, November 20, 2026

Burger King (opens in a new tab)

900 Old Country Rd

Well-known fast-food chain serving grilled burgers, fries & shakes.

Well-known fast-food chain serving grilled burgers, fries & shakes.

Anthony’s Pizza and Grill (opens in a new tab)

2478 Montauk Hwy · Brookhaven

Anthony's Pizza and Grill turns the week into a rotation of cravings, from classic pies and garlicky knots to steak, panini, big salads and…

Anthony's Pizza and Grill turns the week into a rotation of cravings, from classic pies and garlicky knots to steak, panini, big salads and a stacked burger lineup. Keep it in your back pocket for Family Night vibes, Prime Rib energy, and Sunday chicken comfort... all made fresh.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, November 1, 2026

TJ’s Fried Chicken and Gyro (opens in a new tab)

427 S Franklin St · Hempstead

TJ’s Fried Chicken and Gyro turns out golden fried chicken, juicy gyros, and hefty halal platters with rice, salad and warm pita, all fast…

TJ’s Fried Chicken and Gyro turns out golden fried chicken, juicy gyros, and hefty halal platters with rice, salad and warm pita, all fast and flavorful. Fresh-made sauces run mild to fiery, plus thick shakes and waffles if your sweet tooth shows up uninvited.

From the Freeport newsletter, September 3, 2026

Maple Tree BBQ (opens in a new tab)

820 W Main St

Maple Tree BBQ keeps it simple, smoking meats on site daily for that deep, barky goodness. Grab reliable takeout midweek or call them for…

Maple Tree BBQ keeps it simple, smoking meats on site daily for that deep, barky goodness. Grab reliable takeout midweek or call them for your next backyard bash, and if you’re hanging around, their Peach Sangria and Bourbonade don’t exactly hurt morale.

From the Riverhead newsletter, November 5, 2026

Jerry and The Mermaid (opens in a new tab)

469 E Main St

When you want no-nonsense coastal cooking, Jerry and The Mermaid leans on fresh local catches, legit lobster rolls, and chowders in a…

When you want no-nonsense coastal cooking, Jerry and The Mermaid leans on fresh local catches, legit lobster rolls, and chowders in a relaxed waterfront setting, all from a family crew running since 1994. Book a table or order online, and keep them in mind for parties and catering.

From the Riverhead newsletter, November 14, 2026

Bar Clementine (opens in a new tab)

553 E Main St · Islip

From the team behind The LakeHouse, Bar Clementine nails that sit-and-sip moment with its signature Clementine Cocktail, plus bistro…

From the team behind The LakeHouse, Bar Clementine nails that sit-and-sip moment with its signature Clementine Cocktail, plus bistro classics like steak frites and escargot. Casually elegant, neighborly, and perfect for a quick bite or lingering catch-up when you want Paris without the plane ticket.

From the Islip newsletter, October 30, 2026

Barrow Food House (opens in a new tab)

452 Main Rd

Barrow Food House is the kind of fast-casual spot you keep “accidentally” stopping by, with a hot-honey fried chicken thigh sandwich,…

Barrow Food House is the kind of fast-casual spot you keep “accidentally” stopping by, with a hot-honey fried chicken thigh sandwich, single-or-double smash burgers, and rotating specials that actually rotate. Run by a husband and wife chef team, it’s unfussy, local, and reliably delicious.

From the North Fork newsletter, October 28, 2026

Pete’s Taverna Restaurant and Bar (opens in a new tab)

3225 Sound Ave

Pete’s Taverna Restaurant and Bar serves honest-to-goodness Greek and Mediterranean plates with the kind of attentive service that makes…

Pete’s Taverna Restaurant and Bar serves honest-to-goodness Greek and Mediterranean plates with the kind of attentive service that makes weeknights feel like a celebration. Book a table online, catch a live-music evening, or tap them for catering and private parties when the whole crew assembles.

From the Riverhead newsletter, November 22, 2026

T Bar Southampton (opens in a new tab)

268 Elm St · Southampton

T Bar Southampton nails that Hamptons sweet spot with a beautiful garden, a sleek dining room, and a lively bar where the cocktails…

T Bar Southampton nails that Hamptons sweet spot with a beautiful garden, a sleek dining room, and a lively bar where the cocktails actually wow. Think New American comfort with steakhouse gravitas and global accents, plus a solid beer and wine lineup for easy weeknights.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, September 21, 2026

Farm Country Kitchen (opens in a new tab)

513 W Main St

Farm Country Kitchen plates seasonal New American dishes in a refurbished farmhouse on the Peconic River, a cozy spot that makes weeknights…

Farm Country Kitchen plates seasonal New American dishes in a refurbished farmhouse on the Peconic River, a cozy spot that makes weeknights feel like an occasion. Hosting something bigger or mapping a winery day? They handle full-service catering up to 400 guests and offer wine tours.

From the Riverhead newsletter, November 8, 2026

Painters' Restaurant (opens in a new tab)

416 S Country Rd · Brookhaven

With floor-to-ceiling art, an eclectic menu, and live entertainment, Painters' Restaurant brings plenty of personality to a meal in…

With floor-to-ceiling art, an eclectic menu, and live entertainment, Painters' Restaurant brings plenty of personality to a meal in Brookhaven. It’s a good pick when dinner could use a little more color, and maybe a soundtrack.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, November 8, 2026

The Greenery (opens in a new tab)

454 E Main St · Islip

Craving something clean that still hits? The Greenery builds bowls and salads that actually excite, with options like za’atar chicken,…

Craving something clean that still hits? The Greenery builds bowls and salads that actually excite, with options like za’atar chicken, sesame ginger tofu, BBQ jackfruit, and dressings from Greenery Goddess to avocado lime. Go build-your-own with quinoa or cauliflower rice, then grab a smoothie for the ride home.

From the Islip newsletter, October 15, 2026

Wingstop (opens in a new tab)

5 Front St · Hempstead

Casual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.

Casual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.

Cooperage Inn (opens in a new tab)

2218 Sound Ave · Baiting Hollow

Cooperage Inn keeps it North Fork with generous plates of casual country cooking, an extensive lunch and dinner lineup, and local wines,…

Cooperage Inn keeps it North Fork with generous plates of casual country cooking, an extensive lunch and dinner lineup, and local wines, all in a cozy, country-style dining room that’s perfect when you want comfort food without leaving the neighborhood.

From the North Fork newsletter, November 14, 2026

Namiro Sushi (opens in a new tab)

76c Jobs Ln · Southampton

Namiro Sushi nails the local craving for modern Japanese, with nigiri done properly, signature rolls like the Namiro, Sekebi, and Umami,…

Namiro Sushi nails the local craving for modern Japanese, with nigiri done properly, signature rolls like the Namiro, Sekebi, and Umami, steamy ramen, yakitori off the grill, and a cocktail program that behaves... until it doesn’t. Grab a table under the colorful lanterns or book them to cater your next get-together.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, October 30, 2026

Tutto Il Giorno South (opens in a new tab)

56 Nugent St · Southampton

Tutto Il Giorno South nails Southern Italian comfort this week with bright antipasti, twirlable pastas like rigatoni and linguine, and…

Tutto Il Giorno South nails Southern Italian comfort this week with bright antipasti, twirlable pastas like rigatoni and linguine, and mains such as branzino acqua pazza or a proper cioppino. Save room for tiramisu and budino made at Tutto Caffe, because yes, dessert absolutely counts.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, October 11, 2026

Bobby Van's Steakhouse (opens in a new tab)

2393 Montauk Hwy · Bridgehampton

Part of a small chain of chophouses serving steak, seafood & other classic fare in a clubby setting.

Part of a small chain of chophouses serving steak, seafood & other classic fare in a clubby setting.

Claude's Restaurant at the Southampton Inn (opens in a new tab)

91 Hill St · Southampton

When you want something easy and local, Claude's Restaurant at the Southampton Inn offers weekly specials and lets you dine inside or…

When you want something easy and local, Claude's Restaurant at the Southampton Inn offers weekly specials and lets you dine inside or outside in a European-style courtyard. Perfect for those in-the-know nights when you prefer conversation over a scene and a good meal without fuss.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, November 9, 2026

Sirene Hamptons (opens in a new tab)

15 Prospect St · Southampton

Sirene Hamptons is your move when you want a Mediterranean-meets-American chophouse dinner that slides into live music, curated events, and…

Sirene Hamptons is your move when you want a Mediterranean-meets-American chophouse dinner that slides into live music, curated events, and a legit late-night menu. Think polished plates, wine pairings, and that lively, see-your-neighbors energy that makes a random Tuesday feel like an occasion.

From the Suffolk County newsletter, November 7, 2026

Sergio's Pizza (opens in a new tab)

739 Old Country Rd

When you want a legit New York slice without the fuss, Sergio's Pizza has you covered with hand-made pies by the slice, classic Grandma and…

When you want a legit New York slice without the fuss, Sergio's Pizza has you covered with hand-made pies by the slice, classic Grandma and Sicilian squares, plus garlic knots, hearty pastas, and hero-sized chicken parm. Comfort-food levels high... weeknight cooking excuses accepted.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, August 14, 2026

NY Burger Shack (opens in a new tab)

2080 NY-112 · Medford

NY Burger Shack keeps it simple and stellar with a house blend beef lineup of specialty burgers, plus unique chicken sandwiches, fresh…

NY Burger Shack keeps it simple and stellar with a house blend beef lineup of specialty burgers, plus unique chicken sandwiches, fresh salads, and indulgent milkshakes made with locally sourced homemade ice cream.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, October 5, 2026

The Vintage Beano and Vino Lounge (opens in a new tab)

3316 Rte 112 D · Medford

Vintage furniture and live music are the draw at this low-key restaurant serving comfort food and beer.

Vintage furniture and live music are the draw at this low-key restaurant serving comfort food and beer.

Bubba's Burrito Bar (opens in a new tab)

513 E Main St · Islip

Bubba's Burrito Bar brings Tex-Mex and Cali-style eats to a relaxed counter-serve spot, with signature burritos, tacos, salads, and more on…

Bubba's Burrito Bar brings Tex-Mex and Cali-style eats to a relaxed counter-serve spot, with signature burritos, tacos, salads, and more on the menu. Local art and surf scenes add a little beachy personality, so you can pick up lunch without pretending you’re at the shore.

From the Islip newsletter, November 17, 2026

koiKOKORO / Islip NY (opens in a new tab)

501 E Main St · Islip

For those days when choosing between a cozy bowl of ramen and a sushi roll feels like an unfair test, koiKOKORO makes a strong case for…

For those days when choosing between a cozy bowl of ramen and a sushi roll feels like an unfair test, koiKOKORO makes a strong case for enjoying both. This wood-encased Islip eatery serves Japanese favorites, with plenty of ways to turn a quick meal into a satisfying one.

From the Islip newsletter, November 13, 2026

Avino's Italian Table (opens in a new tab)

108 S Country Rd · Bellport

Avino's Italian Table is rolling out a summer Lobsterfest menu alongside Italian favorites, so you can split buttery claws with the same…

Avino's Italian Table is rolling out a summer Lobsterfest menu alongside Italian favorites, so you can split buttery claws with the same crew you trust for Sunday gravy. Book a table with friends this week or let them cater your get-together and call it hosting made easy.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, October 30, 2026

Sean's Place - Deli - Sandwiches (opens in a new tab)

76A Jobs Ln · Southampton

Sean's Place is the locals' deli move when you need breakfast all day made with real local farm eggs, bright green juices, and sandwiches…

Sean's Place is the locals' deli move when you need breakfast all day made with real local farm eggs, bright green juices, and sandwiches on garlic toasted bread. If you spy pistachio muffins, grab a few, then let a monster lunch special or perfect egg sandwich carry you through.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, November 2, 2026

Da Noi Italian Restaurant (opens in a new tab)

301 E Main St · Islip

Da Noi means at our place, and Da Noi Italian Restaurant brings that fine dining meets home vibe Islip loves. With recipes honed over years…

Da Noi means at our place, and Da Noi Italian Restaurant brings that fine dining meets home vibe Islip loves. With recipes honed over years and roots in Manhattan, expect thoughtful plates, a table set with care, and the kind of warm welcome that turns dinner into a memory.

From the Islip newsletter, October 22, 2026

The Bellport (opens in a new tab)

159 S Country Rd · Bellport

Craving something that actually hits the spot? The Bellport keeps it classy with ever-changing seafood specials, housemade pasta,…

Craving something that actually hits the spot? The Bellport keeps it classy with ever-changing seafood specials, housemade pasta, buttermilk fried chicken, and a pecan pie that ruins other desserts for you. Brunch is a local rite of passage, so bring your appetite and your best gossip.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, October 22, 2026

Wings Airport Grill (opens in a new tab)

135 Dawn Dr · Shirley

Wings Airport Grill keeps breakfast and lunch simple, hearty, and served all day at the counter. With a menu built for hungry locals, it’s…

Wings Airport Grill keeps breakfast and lunch simple, hearty, and served all day at the counter. With a menu built for hungry locals, it’s a laid-back Shirley spot where you can fuel up without making a whole production of brunch.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, November 20, 2026

Applebee's Grill + Bar (opens in a new tab)

1832 Old Country Rd

Full-service chain bar & grill providing hearty American eats in an informal setting.

Full-service chain bar & grill providing hearty American eats in an informal setting.

Crispy Taco Co (opens in a new tab)

44 Hampton Rd Ste 2 · Southampton

Crispy Taco Co brings bold West Coast flavor to the East End with its signature crispy corn tortilla tucked into a soft one with…

Crispy Taco Co brings bold West Coast flavor to the East End with its signature crispy corn tortilla tucked into a soft one with mozzarella, pico, guac, and your pick of carne asada, adobada, chicken, cod, shrimp, or veggies. Fresh salsas, slow braised pozole, good margs, plus online ordering and catering.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, October 24, 2026

Goldberg's Famous Bagels (opens in a new tab)

801 County Rd 39 · Southampton

Local mornings run better with Goldberg's Famous Bagels. Fresh, classic bagels and breakfast that actually hits the spot, the summer lines…

Local mornings run better with Goldberg's Famous Bagels. Fresh, classic bagels and breakfast that actually hits the spot, the summer lines move fast, and if you’re hosting, their catering keeps everyone happily fed. Consider this your reminder to make the menu your weekend game plan.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, November 7, 2026

Carlo's Pizza Oven (opens in a new tab)

435 Osborn Ave

When you want a no fuss local pie that still hits, Carlo's Pizza Oven is the move. Their thin pan Grandma pie with fresh marinara is a…

When you want a no fuss local pie that still hits, Carlo's Pizza Oven is the move. Their thin pan Grandma pie with fresh marinara is a staple, the stuffed pizzas are unapologetically extra, and those famous garlic rolls quietly disappear the second they hit the table.

From the North Fork newsletter, November 7, 2026

Dopo Argento (opens in a new tab)

15 Main St · Southampton

Dopo Argento brings an innovative Italian and modern Mediterranean kitchen together with a New York style bespoke cocktail bar, the kind of…

Dopo Argento brings an innovative Italian and modern Mediterranean kitchen together with a New York style bespoke cocktail bar, the kind of spot you slip into for lunch, linger through dinner, then toast a birthday in the private dining room. Solid local go-to when you want polished without stuffy.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, October 17, 2026

The Pizzeria of Islip (opens in a new tab)

591 E Main St · Islip

When the late-night "let's just get a slice" turns into a full pie situation, The Pizzeria of Islip nails it with crisp thin-crust slices,…

When the late-night "let's just get a slice" turns into a full pie situation, The Pizzeria of Islip nails it with crisp thin-crust slices, gluten-free pies, and fun specialty combos that actually work. They’ll even cater your backyard hang, so you can claim hosting glory without touching the oven.

From the Islip newsletter, October 31, 2026

Showing the 120 most recent of 147. See what changed this month