The best bakeries & sweet shops in Riverhead

29 places we’ve checked and would send a neighbor to. Open any one to read what we wrote about it.

29 places · newest first

Your business could be here.

Be at the top of Riverhead's page when you're in Riverhead's newsletter.

Put my business here

Local businesses pay to be shown here. A person checks every one.

Cookies United (opens in a new tab)

141 Freeman Ave · Islip

Cookies United calls itself a fresh source for baked goods, with a focus on cookies and a stated commitment to quality and freshness. It’s…

Cookies United calls itself a fresh source for baked goods, with a focus on cookies and a stated commitment to quality and freshness. It’s a local name to keep in mind when the cookie jar is looking a little too optimistic.

From the Islip newsletter, November 16, 2026

Dunkin' (opens in a new tab)

545 William Floyd Pkwy · Shirley

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

Baskin-Robbins (opens in a new tab)

1495 Montauk Hwy · Mastic

Ice cream parlor chain known for its many ice cream flavors & sundaes, plus cakes, drinks & other treats.

Ice cream parlor chain known for its many ice cream flavors & sundaes, plus cakes, drinks & other treats.

Dunkin' (opens in a new tab)

1495 Montauk Hwy · Mastic

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

Long-running chain serving signature breakfast items & a variety of coffee drinks.

Ralph's Famous Italian Ices & Ice Cream, Shirley (opens in a new tab)

990 Montauk Hwy · Shirley

Ralph's Famous Italian Ices & Ice Cream brings Italian ices and ice cream together in a lineup of more than 100 flavors, with roots dating…

Ralph's Famous Italian Ices & Ice Cream brings Italian ices and ice cream together in a lineup of more than 100 flavors, with roots dating back to 1928. Whether your sweet tooth wants something icy, creamy, or a little of both, this Shirley shop gives you plenty to ponder before ordering.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, November 11, 2026

Carvel (opens in a new tab)

492 William Floyd Pkwy · Shirley

Circa-1934 chain known for its soft-serve ice cream & custom cakes, mainly for take-out.

Circa-1934 chain known for its soft-serve ice cream & custom cakes, mainly for take-out.

Baskin-Robbins (opens in a new tab)

545 William Floyd Pkwy · Shirley

Ice cream parlor chain known for its many ice cream flavors & sundaes, plus cakes, drinks & other treats.

Ice cream parlor chain known for its many ice cream flavors & sundaes, plus cakes, drinks & other treats.

Ice Cream Cottage (opens in a new tab)

1590 Montauk Hwy · Mastic

Since 1990, Ice Cream Cottage has churned super premium flavors like Mastic Mash, Butter Pecan, and the award winning Chocolate Overdose,…

Since 1990, Ice Cream Cottage has churned super premium flavors like Mastic Mash, Butter Pecan, and the award winning Chocolate Overdose, plus they’ll customize ice cream cakes with your favorite photo. Online ordering, a cozy throwback vibe, and cones that actually live up to the hype.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, November 18, 2026

Carvel (opens in a new tab)

318 Jerusalem Ave · Hempstead

Circa-1934 chain known for its soft-serve ice cream & custom cakes, mainly for take-out.

Circa-1934 chain known for its soft-serve ice cream & custom cakes, mainly for take-out.

Sweet Moments Bakery (opens in a new tab)

490A Mastic Rd · Mastic Beach

From elaborate custom cakes to desserts, the sister duo behind Sweet Moments Bakery also brings the party, offering servers, bartenders,…

From elaborate custom cakes to desserts, the sister duo behind Sweet Moments Bakery also brings the party, offering servers, bartenders, plus table and chair rentals across Suffolk and Nassau. Need your Brookhaven get-together to shine and taste amazing, so you can enjoy it too? They make planning easy.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, October 28, 2026

Tim Hortons (opens in a new tab)

380 Peninsula Blvd · Hempstead

Canadian chain for signature premium-blend coffee, plus light fare, pastries & breakfast sandwiches.

Canadian chain for signature premium-blend coffee, plus light fare, pastries & breakfast sandwiches.

The Rainbow Rolls (opens in a new tab)

333 Main St · Center Moriches

Trendy ice cream shop specializing in rolled flavors — including a vegan base — as well as tacos and shakes, plus friendly staff.

Trendy ice cream shop specializing in rolled flavors — including a vegan base — as well as tacos and shakes, plus friendly staff.

Mister Softee (opens in a new tab)

252 Main St · Center Moriches

When the sweet tooth hits this week, Mister Softee is the move for creamy soft-serve cones, sundaes, shakes, floats and even ice cream…

When the sweet tooth hits this week, Mister Softee is the move for creamy soft-serve cones, sundaes, shakes, floats and even ice cream cakes, all made with premium ingredients.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, August 19, 2026

Baskin-Robbins (opens in a new tab)

247 Greenwich St · Hempstead

Ice cream parlor chain known for its many ice cream flavors & sundaes, plus cakes, drinks & other treats.

Ice cream parlor chain known for its many ice cream flavors & sundaes, plus cakes, drinks & other treats.

Coyles Homemade Ice Cream (opens in a new tab)

539 E Main St · Islip

Coyles Homemade Ice Cream serves joy in every scoop, handcrafted in-house using locally sourced ingredients since 1985. It’s the kind of…

Coyles Homemade Ice Cream serves joy in every scoop, handcrafted in-house using locally sourced ingredients since 1985. It’s the kind of community-first spot that turns a random Tuesday into a mini celebration, and a Friday into a victory lap for your sweet tooth.

From the Islip newsletter, October 13, 2026

Nettie's Country Bakery (opens in a new tab)

366 Railroad Ave · Center Moriches

Charming local bakery offering breakfast such as donuts, scones, and croissants.

Charming local bakery offering breakfast such as donuts, scones, and croissants.

Frank & Son Bakery (opens in a new tab)

1575 Montauk Hwy · Mastic

When you need an instant morale boost, Frank & Son Bakery delivers with fresh-baked bread and a case full of cookies, cakes, cannoli, and…

When you need an instant morale boost, Frank & Son Bakery delivers with fresh-baked bread and a case full of cookies, cakes, cannoli, and cheesecake. Swing by this week and turn a random Tuesday into a win.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, October 20, 2026

Insomnia Cookies (opens in a new tab)

730 Fulton Ave · Hempstead

Bakery chain known for warm cookies, ice cream & late-night deliveries.

Bakery chain known for warm cookies, ice cream & late-night deliveries.

Bagels & More (opens in a new tab)

167 Islip Ave · Islip

If you like your bagels dense, moist, and made the old-fashioned kettle way, Bagels & More is worth adding to your breakfast rotation. Pair…

If you like your bagels dense, moist, and made the old-fashioned kettle way, Bagels & More is worth adding to your breakfast rotation. Pair one with a homemade cream cheese flavor, or go for an egg sandwich and coffee when breakfast needs to do a little more.

From the Islip newsletter, November 11, 2026

Pride Enjoy (opens in a new tab)

6302 NY-25A Ste 2 Building C · Wading River

Pride Enjoy is Eastern Long Island's hub for scratch-made treats that are gluten-free, vegan, and allergy-friendly without tasting like a…

Pride Enjoy is Eastern Long Island's hub for scratch-made treats that are gluten-free, vegan, and allergy-friendly without tasting like a compromise. If your household juggles food sensitivities, this inclusive bakery makes it easy to treat everyone, no side-eyeing the ingredient list required.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, August 7, 2026

Sugar Dreams Bakery (opens in a new tab)

15 S Country Rd · East Patchogue

Sugar Dreams Bakery turns your party ideas into edible art, from custom character cakes to elegant tiers, plus cupcakes, cake pops,…

Sugar Dreams Bakery turns your party ideas into edible art, from custom character cakes to elegant tiers, plus cupcakes, cake pops, chocolate-dipped strawberries, and seasonal specials.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, September 29, 2026

Tate's Bake Shop (opens in a new tab)

43 N Sea Rd · Southampton

Southampton born and famously crispy, Tate's Bake Shop nails that just-right chocolate chip snap, plus gluten free options that still taste…

Southampton born and famously crispy, Tate's Bake Shop nails that just-right chocolate chip snap, plus gluten free options that still taste like, well, cookies.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, October 28, 2026

The Treatery Long Island (opens in a new tab)

1564 Main Rd · Jamesport

The Treatery Long Island specializes in cakes and bakes, cookies, and grilled cheeses, with its own dessert trailer adding a fun twist to…

The Treatery Long Island specializes in cakes and bakes, cookies, and grilled cheeses, with its own dessert trailer adding a fun twist to the mix. Whether you’re after a well-made chocolate chip cookie or something savory, it’s a Jamesport bakery with plenty to tempt you.

From the North Fork newsletter, November 3, 2026

North Fork Doughnut Company (opens in a new tab)

100 Love Ln · Mattituck

Made fresh every day and never boring, North Fork Doughnut Company keeps locals happy with a rotating Flavor Forecast that swings from…

Made fresh every day and never boring, North Fork Doughnut Company keeps locals happy with a rotating Flavor Forecast that swings from classics to wild seasonal experiments. If your week needs a sweet plot twist, grab a box and share... or don’t.

From the North Fork newsletter, October 27, 2026

North Fork Chocolate (opens in a new tab)

8700 Main Rd · Mattituck

Craving something joy-inducing? North Fork Chocolate does scratch-made truffles, cakes, pies and ice cream, plus a legit chocolate tasting…

Craving something joy-inducing? North Fork Chocolate does scratch-made truffles, cakes, pies and ice cream, plus a legit chocolate tasting bar, organic espresso, and fresh Belgian Liege waffles. It’s the rare spot where dessert meets lunch, with soups, sandwiches and veggie-friendly options that actually taste good.

From the North Fork newsletter, November 10, 2026

Rustik Cake Studio (opens in a new tab)

53 Hill St Ste 72 · Southampton

Rustik Cake Studio turns cakes into eye-catching centerpieces, with wedding designs, vintage piping, and playful options like superhero,…

Rustik Cake Studio turns cakes into eye-catching centerpieces, with wedding designs, vintage piping, and playful options like superhero, animal-face, and unicorn cakes. It’s a Southampton spot to keep in mind when your celebration calls for something more memorable than a supermarket sheet cake.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, November 4, 2026

Celeste Bakery (opens in a new tab)

857-863 Old Country Rd

Treat yourself to from-scratch loaves, flaky pastries, buttery cookies, and celebration-worthy cakes at Celeste Bakery, a family-owned spot…

Treat yourself to from-scratch loaves, flaky pastries, buttery cookies, and celebration-worthy cakes at Celeste Bakery, a family-owned spot that bakes daily and keeps refreshing drinks on hand. Perfect for a midweek morale boost or that dessert you swore you wouldn't share.

From the North Fork newsletter, November 13, 2026

CakeBites (opens in a new tab)

141 Freeman Ave · Islip

From the Islip-based team at CakeBites, these snackable cakes bring big flavor in combos like Strawberry Shortcake, Pistachio, and Peanut…

From the Islip-based team at CakeBites, these snackable cakes bring big flavor in combos like Strawberry Shortcake, Pistachio, and Peanut Butter Chocolate Crunch. They also roll out Crumbles, Supremes and those hulking Filled Mega Cakebars... perfect for pantry raids or last-minute dessert duty.

From the Islip newsletter, October 27, 2026

Kerri's Kandies Inc (opens in a new tab)

2160 NY-112 · Coram

Consider Kerri's Kandies Inc when you want legit homemade chocolates without the fuss and a friendly crew. Handmade truffles, fudge,…

Consider Kerri's Kandies Inc when you want legit homemade chocolates without the fuss and a friendly crew.

From the Suffolk County newsletter, October 21, 2026

Topiare Candy Shop (opens in a new tab)

51A Jobs Ln · Southampton

Topiare Candy Shop has playful finds like cotton candy cake, Swedish candy, caramels, and curated boxes for movie nights or sweet gifting.…

Topiare Candy Shop has playful finds like cotton candy cake, Swedish candy, caramels, and curated boxes for movie nights or sweet gifting. It’s a fun Southampton stop when the usual chocolate bar feels a little too ordinary.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, November 17, 2026

Dulcemania ll (opens in a new tab)

92 N Franklin St · Hempstead

Craving that tart-sweet kick without trekking far? Dulcemania II is a friendly international grocery and juice bar serving mangonadas and…

Craving that tart-sweet kick without trekking far? Dulcemania II is a friendly international grocery and juice bar serving mangonadas and fresh fruit drinks alongside global pantry favorites, so you can snag a vibrant sip and a few tasty add-ons for later, all in one stop. Check it out.

From the Valley Stream newsletter, September 13, 2026

Paleteria Mexicandy (opens in a new tab)

221 E Main St

Skip the basic soft serve and hit Paleteria Mexicandy in Riverhead for artisanal paletas, creamy ice creams, and their famous mangonadas…

Skip the basic soft serve and hit Paleteria Mexicandy in Riverhead for artisanal paletas, creamy ice creams, and their famous mangonadas that taste like summer in a cup. Perfect for post-beach cooldowns, midweek morale boosts, or when you need a little Mexico-level flavor in your day.

From the North Fork newsletter, November 21, 2026

Krieg's Bakery (opens in a new tab)

39 W Montauk Hwy #7 · Hampton Bays

If your weekends revolve around coffee and something warm, Krieg's Bakery keeps Hampton Bays happy with classic donuts, cookies, and…

If your weekends revolve around coffee and something warm, Krieg's Bakery keeps Hampton Bays happy with classic donuts, cookies, and celebration-worthy cakes, plus bread sliced to-order so it hits the table just right. It’s the kind of homey spot locals quietly guard... until friends visit.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, November 21, 2026

The Baker's Workshop at Suffolk Community College Culinary Arts Center is open to the public while school is in session! (opens in a new tab)

20 E Main St

When classes are in session, The Baker's Workshop at Suffolk Community College Culinary Arts Center turns out fresh pastries, breads,…

When classes are in session, The Baker's Workshop at Suffolk Community College Culinary Arts Center turns out fresh pastries, breads, quiche, house-made soups, salads and gourmet sandwiches with local artisan coffee and gelato.

From the North Fork newsletter, November 17, 2026

Carla Marlas ICE CREAM PARLOR & CANDY SHOPPE (opens in a new tab)

8 Bellport Ln · Bellport

Whether you’re craving a classic cone, an over-the-top sundae, or a thick shake that laughs at paper straws, Carla Marlas Ice Cream Parlor…

Whether you’re craving a classic cone, an over-the-top sundae, or a thick shake that laughs at paper straws, Carla Marlas Ice Cream Parlor & Candy Shoppe has the fix, plus a sweet stash of candy when your inner 10-year-old takes the wheel.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, October 24, 2026

Beach Bakery & Grand Cafe (opens in a new tab)

112 Main St · Westhampton Beach

Beach Bakery & Grand Cafe covers the cravings from morning coffee and breakfast to pizza, cookies, pastries, pies and custom cakes. With…

Beach Bakery & Grand Cafe covers the cravings from morning coffee and breakfast to pizza, cookies, pastries, pies and custom cakes. With more than 30 years of bakery know-how and catering for gatherings, it’s a handy local spot for a treat, a meal, or dessert worth saving room for.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, November 11, 2026

Manhattan Sweets Boutique Bakery (opens in a new tab)

547 E Main St · Islip

When your week needs a sweet plot twist, Manhattan Sweets Boutique Bakery turns out gorgeous wedding and celebration cakes, crowd-pleasing…

When your week needs a sweet plot twist, Manhattan Sweets Boutique Bakery turns out gorgeous wedding and celebration cakes, crowd-pleasing cupcakes and cookies, plus that Long Island legend, the rainbow cookie cake. Perfect for birthdays you forgot about until yesterday, or just because Tuesday deserves frosting.

From the Islip newsletter, October 20, 2026

Nita's Pastries Inc (opens in a new tab)

Holly Ave · Hempstead

When your group chat says "we need cake" Nita's Pastries Inc turns ideas into edible art, from buttercream-heavy birthday stunners to…

When your group chat says "we need cake" Nita's Pastries Inc turns ideas into edible art, from buttercream-heavy birthday stunners to elegant wedding tiers, plus cupcakes, cookies, dessert tables and a dessert catering cart. Everything's baked fresh to order, so your celebration tastes like it actually mattered.

From the Hempstead newsletter, August 10, 2026

Love Lane Sweet Shoppe (opens in a new tab)

125 Love Ln · Mattituck

Love Lane Sweet Shoppe has a big assortment of candy alongside gifts ranging from toys and apparel to home goods. It’s a handy place to…

Love Lane Sweet Shoppe has a big assortment of candy alongside gifts ranging from toys and apparel to home goods. It’s a handy place to satisfy a chocolate craving or find a small present without turning the search into a whole production.

From the North Fork newsletter, November 14, 2026

Bridgehampton Candy Kitchen (opens in a new tab)

Montauk Hwy · Bridgehampton

Bridgehampton Candy Kitchen pairs homemade ice cream with familiar breakfasts, sandwiches, and old-school soda fountain charm. Family-owned…

Bridgehampton Candy Kitchen pairs homemade ice cream with familiar breakfasts, sandwiches, and old-school soda fountain charm. Family-owned since 1925, it’s a Bridgehampton original where swivel stools and checkered floors are part of the appeal, and a scoop makes an excellent excuse to linger.

From the The Hamptons newsletter, November 6, 2026