The best bakeries & sweet shops in Martha's Vineyard

“Whether you crave a scoop or a seriously good sugar fix, Ben and Bill's of Edgartown churns classic ice cream and turns out homemade chocolates like peanut butter cups, turtles, clusters, bark and truffles. Keep them in your freezer, bribe your friends, or order an ice cream cake for birthdays.”

From the Martha's Vineyard newsletter, September 17, 2026

“Retailer selling casualwear, accessories & gifts with its signature dog logo for men, women & kids.”

“For a dependable island grab-and-go that actually knows your order by week two, Blackbird Cafe keeps the ovens humming with baked goods, easy online ordering, and legit catering for your next backyard thing. Regulars will appreciate the rewards, and gift cards make excellent neighbor bribes.”

From the Martha's Vineyard newsletter, September 8, 2026

“Espresso Love is that steady local standby for proper espresso, homemade pastries, and the simple joys of sandwiches, salads and bagels. Keep it in your weekly rotation when you need a quick, tasty reset that doesn’t overcomplicate things, just fuels you back to life.”

From the Martha's Vineyard newsletter, September 6, 2026

“Back Door Donuts in Oak Bluffs is the move when you want a truly massive fritter or a custom cake that steals the whole party. Swing by for fun, creative bakes that taste as good as they look, then act surprised when the box disappears fast.”

From the Martha's Vineyard newsletter, August 13, 2026

“Whether you’re sprinting to the boat or easing into island errands, Delicious MV brings a little Paris to your morning with artisan breads, golden pastries, savory bites, and crafted coffee. Cap it off with rich handmade ice cream, because yes, you’ve earned dessert before noon.”

From the Martha's Vineyard newsletter, August 22, 2026

“The Good Shoppe is your go-to when a sugar craving hits, with candy, refreshing Italian ice, solid coffee, and their signature Good Cookie, an oversized chocolate chip baked in a pizza oven and served hot in a pizza box. Perfect little pick-me-up between errands.”

From the Martha's Vineyard newsletter, August 31, 2026

“Sweet Bites is a family owned, small batch bakery and espresso bar bringing Brazilian flair to Vineyard Haven, turning weekday cravings into legit occasions with flaky pastries, breakfast bites, hearty sandwiches, and custom cakes for your next celebration...”

From the Martha's Vineyard newsletter, August 20, 2026

“Craving a real deal morning? Delicious MV Bakery is serving French style artisan breads, golden pastries, rich handmade ice cream, and crafted coffee that actually tastes like a pause. Quick grab and go or linger for brunch, it’s the cozy, delicious reset your week could use.”

From the Martha's Vineyard newsletter, August 17, 2026

“Iggy's Bread keeps Island carb cravings happy with its Martha’s Vineyard Café outposts in Edgartown and Menemsha, turning out fresh, no-nonsense bread that’s perfect for weeknight dinners, beach sandwiches, or that last-minute “we need something good with dinner” run.”

From the Martha's Vineyard newsletter, September 1, 2026