The best restaurants in Martha's Vineyard

“Chef & Owner Christopher Stam fuses New England roots with international flair at Alchemy Bistro & Bar, turning land and sea bounty into a menu that beats pantry pasta. This week, pair it with cocktails voted Best on the Island 2014 to 2024 and a Wine Spectator Award of Excellence list led by Meaghan Robinson.”

“Midnight Taco & Tequila Bar dishes SoCal-style tacos built on fresh, local ingredients, from crispy, cheesy pork birria to tuna belly and lime-garlic shrimp, plus tequila to match. Hit it this week for garden-grown OB produce, house marinades, and scratch everything that keeps flavors bright...”

From the Martha's Vineyard newsletter, August 4, 2026

“Wicked Burger is Edgartown’s fast casual spot from Chef Chris Stam and the Alchemy team, turning out crispy, juicy smash patties with special sauces, proper sides, and shakes that hit the spot. Make dinner this week wicked easy, you’ve earned it.”

From the Martha's Vineyard newsletter, August 6, 2026

“Atria has been the Vineyard's go-to for relaxed-elegant nights since 2000, with Chef Christian Thornton turning local catch and farm goods into contemporary New England plates that actually taste like here. Treat yourself this week, whether you want a neighborhood hang or a celebration-worthy meal.”

From the Martha's Vineyard newsletter, August 7, 2026

“Casual take-out outfit serving familiar eats, plus breakfast sandwiches and desserts.”

“Al fresco coffee shop offering coffee drinks, breakfast eats & sandwiches, open May through fall.”

“Coastal-chic restaurant at the Harbor View Hotel offering refined American fare and a bar.”

“Fish-focused menu served in a casual dining room or on the expansive deck, plus DJs some nights.”

“Elegant bistro with patio seating dishing up farm-to-table American fare such as steak & seafood.”

“Family-friendly eatery features upscale New American cooking, plus an outdoor deck with ocean views.”

“Casual nook in a renovated house serving area-sourced comfort food, local beers & homemade desserts.”

“Casual option for pizza and subs like steak and cheese, plus vegetarian fare.”

“Seafood and pasta dishes are served at this airy restaurant featuring a patio for cocktails and wine.”

“Cozy hangout serves up local seafood & bar fare, plus sports TV, video games & live music.”

“Wood-fired flatbreads & other American bites in a bi-level space with exposed-brick walls.”

“Lively, brick-accented restaurant offering a seafood-focused menu & live music on a seasonal basis.”

“Rustic pub dishing up traditional fare such as burgers, lobster rolls and chowder, alongside fish-and-chips.”

“Italian-American dishes star at this upscale bistro serving pre-dinner drinks on its quaint porch.”

“A menu featuring seafood towers & contemporary bistro fare in a renovated home with patio seating.”

“A French-inspired, locally sourced menu served in a classy dining room & wine/cocktail bar.”

“Easygoing eatery serving pizza and Brazilian plates, including gluten-free and vegan options.”

“Veteran waterside go-to with patio offers, breakfast & comfort-food dinners, plus beer & wine.”

“Cozy, upscale restaurant showcasing locally sourced, ingredient-driven cuisine with cocktails and water views.”

“Old-school throwback with a retro motif & traditional American dishes for breakfast, lunch & dinner.”