The best antique, thrift & vintage shops in Smithtown
10 places we’ve checked and would send a neighbor to. Open any one to read what we wrote about it.
Your business could be here.
Be at the top of Smithtown's page when you're in Smithtown's newsletter.
Local businesses pay to be shown here. A person checks every one.
Tamino Autographs, LLC (opens in a new tab)
120 Bennett Ave Apt 1 H · New York
Tamino Autographs, LLC is a New York based dealer for when your walls demand culture, specializing since 2006 in authentic autographs…
GEM Pawnbrokers (opens in a new tab)
4229A Broadway · New York
Family-owned since 1947, GEM Pawnbrokers offers loans and purchases for jewelry, diamonds, gold, watches, and electronics, with free,…
Thrift NYC (opens in a new tab)
30 W 14th St · New York
Vintage clothing store offering a wide variety of items, including leather jackets and cowboy boots.
Housing Works Thrift Shops - West Village (opens in a new tab)
245 W 10th St · New York
Secondhand outpost stocked with clothing, home items, books and furniture, plus vases.
Housing Works Thrift Shops - Columbus & 74th St (opens in a new tab)
306 Columbus Ave · New York
Dig for closet upgrades and apartment glow-ups at Housing Works Thrift Shops - Columbus & 74th St, a lively spot where clothing, shoes,…
Housing Works Thrift Shop - Yorkville (opens in a new tab)
1730 2nd Ave · New York
Thrift shop carrying furniture and clothing for men and women, plus antiques, collectibles, and vintage items.
Housing Works Thrift Shops - Broadway & 96th St (opens in a new tab)
2569 Broadway · New York
Whether you need a closet refresh, a quirky lamp, or that just-right coffee table, Housing Works Thrift Shops - Broadway & 96th St keeps…
The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center (opens in a new tab)
194 Front St · Hempstead
Thrift store chain selling donated items such as furniture, clothing, and other goods.
Encore Une Fois (opens in a new tab)
103 South St · Oyster Bay
Craving a little low-rise nostalgia and sparkly chaos? Encore Une Fois is a Y2K-focused thrift store with throwback finds and Instagram…
The Greenhouse Antiques And Collectibles (opens in a new tab)
425 N Country Rd · St James
Housed in a historic greenhouse in Saint James, The Greenhouse Antiques And Collectibles brings together 50 North Shore dealers for a…
The Niche Shop (opens in a new tab)
311 E 81st St · New York
The Niche Shop blends a build-your-own Niche Charms bracelet bar with curated vintage clothing and designer bags, letting you craft your…
BK Antiques & Home (opens in a new tab)
306 E 61st St 2nd floor · New York
BK Antiques & Home hunts down European antiques and contemporary finds, then mixes them with their BK LIMITED line of made-to-order…
Explosive Bargains & Thrift (opens in a new tab)
127 Smithtown Blvd · Nesconset
Store in Nesconset Plaza offering a variety of items from antiques to DVDs at discount prices.
Procell (opens in a new tab)
5 Delancey St · New York
Vintage store spotlighting 80s & 90s apparel & accessories for men & women, including concert tees.
Furnish Green (opens in a new tab)
132 1/2 W 24th St · New York
If your apartment’s begging for personality, Furnish Green is the curated vintage spot dropping 25 new finds every weekday, from legit…
Mantiques Modern (opens in a new tab)
146 W 22nd St #1 · New York
Mantiques Modern curates 20th-century furniture, art, and objets from names like Hermes, Cartier, Dior, and Gucci, plus quirky grails like…
Plato's Closet Commack NY (opens in a new tab)
6153 Jericho Tpke · Commack
Chain retailer buying & selling trendy secondhand clothing for teens & young adults.
Pilgrim New York (opens in a new tab)
70 Orchard St · New York
Pilgrim New York mixes NYC-made womenswear with vintage gold from labels like Ann Demeulemeester, Prada, and Yohji Yamamoto, all backed by…
ZeroKid NJ (opens in a new tab)
381 Monmouth St · Jersey City
ZeroKid NJ keeps the hunt easy with character-packed vintage that makes everyday fits less boring. Watch for fresh drops and one-off finds,…
Options for Community Living Thrift Shop (opens in a new tab)
392 Hawkins Ave · Lake Ronkonkoma
Options for Community Living Thrift Shop delivers the true treasure-hunt experience, from clothing and housewares to small electronics and…
PaganBabyDolls Vintage Boutique (opens in a new tab)
162 Allen St · New York
PaganBabyDolls Vintage Boutique leans whimsical, romantic, and boho-chic, with clothes, shoes, and accessories spanning the ’70s through…
Savers (opens in a new tab)
755 Larkfield Rd · Commack
Thrift store chain offering secondhand clothing, footwear, furniture, books & household items.
Another Man's Treasure (opens in a new tab)
195 Montgomery St · Jersey City
Another Man's Treasure is a vintage shop with well-curated racks of statement pieces, everyday staples, and the kind of accessories that…
Hamlet's Vintage (opens in a new tab)
161 W 4th St · New York
Vintage shop for clothes & accessories from the 1940s to the 1980s for men & women, plus home decor.
Nelson & Nelson Antiques (opens in a new tab)
1050 2nd Ave Gallery 57 · New York
Nelson & Nelson Antiques has been NYC’s go-to for one-of-a-kind sterling, with 19th to mid-20th century hollowware, Tiffany sterling, and…
Spark Pretty (opens in a new tab)
333 E 9th St · New York
Spark Pretty is the NYC-based vintage wonderland for unapologetically bright '80s and '90s pieces, plus the playful accessories that tie it…
Islip UMC Thrift Shoppe (opens in a new tab)
350 E Main St · Islip
Islip UMC Thrift Shoppe is where locals score real finds without the rummage fatigue. Racks of clothing for men, women, infants, and kids,…
Spellman Gallery (opens in a new tab)
1672 1st Ave · New York
Whether you’re window-shopping or hunting for a piece with real provenance, Spellman Gallery punches above its weight with works by names…
Heirlooms Antiques (opens in a new tab)
177 E 87th St · New York
If you’ve got a soft spot for pieces with history, Heirlooms Antiques on the Upper East Side curates 19th and 20th century art, jewelry,…
The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center (opens in a new tab)
74 Pennington St · Newark
Used goods, including furniture, clothing, toys and books, at a discount.
Now and Forever Jewelry (opens in a new tab)
32 W 47th St Unit 41 · New York
If you love pieces with history, Now and Forever Jewelry curates vintage and antique gems from Victorian through Art Deco, with rings,…
East Village Vintage Collective (opens in a new tab)
545 E 12th St · New York
Eclectic vintage outfitter (1960s-90s) featuring art, accessories, gifts and knickknacks.
2nd STREET (opens in a new tab)
142 W 26th St · New York
2nd STREET nails that sweet spot where Gucci and Reebok mingle with vintage and current Japanese drops, all secondhand and in premium…
Checked Sep 17
The End of History (opens in a new tab)
548 Hudson St · New York
The End of History is packed with vintage mid-century Italian and Scandinavian glass and ceramics, from sculptural vases to bright, curious…
Shop Heirlooms (opens in a new tab)
145 N 11th St · Newark
Shop Heirlooms brings together vintage clothing, jerseys, sneakers, and memorabilia, with finds ranging from classic team tees to music and…
Aberizk (opens in a new tab)
9 Spring St · New York
Aberizk hits that Brooklyn sweet spot between hard-to-find vintage and modern styling, with a sharp edit of tops, dresses, outerwear, bags,…
L Train Vintage (opens in a new tab)
204 1st Ave · New York
If you like scoring vintage without scary price tags, L Train Vintage keeps the good stuff coming, family owned and restocked at least…
Ticker History (opens in a new tab)
12-16 Vestry St 6th Floor · New York
Ticker History sells vintage and specimen stock and bond certificates across banks, railroads, airlines, tech and Disney, with very New…
Grand Bazaar NYC (opens in a new tab)
100 W 77th St · New York
Grand Bazaar NYC is the city’s biggest curated weekly market where 100+ local vintage dealers, artists, designers and craft-makers bring…
Upper East Vintage (opens in a new tab)
675 Madison Ave #3F · New York
Upper East Vintage curates expertly picked pieces from the 1930s through the 1990s, shoppable by appointment for that private,…
Thic Chic Plus Size Boutique (opens in a new tab)
367 Lake Ave · St James
Thic Chic Plus Size Boutique is the rare spot where every rack is actually for you, with current and vintage styles in sizes 0x-5x,…
Swann Auction Galleries (opens in a new tab)
104 E 25th St Fl 6 · New York
Swann Auction Galleries lines up smartly curated sales across books, maps, vintage posters, photographs, and fine art, including their 20th…
Crossroads Trading (opens in a new tab)
122 2nd Ave · New York
Crossroads Trading is where your once-loved pieces become someone else’s go-to and your next favorite fit comes home with you. Swing by…
9th St. Vintage (opens in a new tab)
346 E 9th St · New York
From 1920s silk slips and Edwardian skirts to 1940s trousers, Big E denim, and perfectly thrashed band tees, 9th St. Vintage lives its…
Crossroads Trading (opens in a new tab)
24 W 26th St · New York
Crossroads Trading is the rare spot where clearing out your closet actually pays. Bring in current, on-trend pieces for cash or trade…
Olde Good Things (opens in a new tab)
333 W 52nd St · New York
Architectural artifact dealer offering reclaimed building materials & antiques.
Into The Void (opens in a new tab)
117 Brunswick St · Jersey City
Into The Void is the spot when your Jackson place needs real-deal antique furniture with patina, personality, and stories baked in.…
White Trash (opens in a new tab)
304 E 5th St · New York
When your place needs character beyond big-box bland, White Trash keeps a rotating trove of midcentury modern seating, storage, tables,…
Housing Works Thrift Shops - Chelsea (opens in a new tab)
143 W 17th St · New York
Whether you’re refreshing the apartment or chasing that perfect vintage piece, Housing Works Thrift Shops - Chelsea turns over designer…
Antique Attics (opens in a new tab)
2789 Middle Country Rd · Lake Grove
Antique Attics is a multi-dealer trove where the mix changes weekly, so you can actually find the Pyrex, vintage decor, military…
New York Vintage Inc (opens in a new tab)
117 W 25th St · New York
New York Vintage Inc is a membership-based digital showroom for fashion, style, and design professionals, with a collection spanning…
Metropolis Vintage (opens in a new tab)
803 Broadway · New York
If your tees are looking tired this week, go treasure-hunting at Metropolis Vintage, where classic Ralph Lauren Polo everything meets a…
SYL-LEE ANTIQUES (opens in a new tab)
1133 Broadway Ste 606 · New York
Family-run Syl-Lee Antiques buys and sells antiques, fine art, jewelry, and designer furniture, and they’ll come to you for straightforward…
conSHINEment (opens in a new tab)
910 Bergen Ave · Jersey City
conSHINEment is a sustainable consignment spot with premium secondhand finds for men and women, from designer labels and vintage gems to…
Church Street Surplus (opens in a new tab)
327 Church St · New York
Vintage shop packed with men's & women's vintage threads as well as Army-Navy clothes.
Island Thrift (opens in a new tab)
1770 Middle Country Rd · Centereach
Retailer of used clothing, furniture and jewelry as well as other housewares.
Ritual Vintage Clothing (opens in a new tab)
377 Broome St · New York
Ritual Vintage Clothing is that cozy, well-edited spot locals hit when they want pieces with stories, from Victorian and 1920s gems to 70s…
Crossroads Trading (opens in a new tab)
47 W 13th St · New York
Crossroads Trading is the buy-sell-trade spot for on-trend, gently used clothing, shoes, and accessories, where you can turn last season…
D&J Antique Buyers (opens in a new tab)
579 5th Ave · New York
When the attic starts looking like a mini museum, D&J Antique Buyers makes estate selling simple with respectful home visits, competitive…
Alpha & Omega Jewelry (opens in a new tab)
32 W 47th St Unit 41 · New York
Sweet jewelry store featuring antique and vintage pieces and contemporary styles.
Nothing here matches that.
Try a shorter word, or look through every kind of place in Smithtown.
Know a great place we’re missing? Email hello@baselocal.com
The best of Smithtown, every morning
New places show up in the Smithtown newsletter first. It's free.
One email a day. Unsubscribe anytime.