The best restaurants in Smithtown

Chill choice for Mexican cuisine with a vibrantly decorated space & a petite patio.

949 Columbus Ave (New York)

Casual restaurant with a sizable tequila selection and Mexican fare such as tacos and birria.

313 10th Ave (New York)

Sophisticated, modern American eatery plating tasting menus and multi-course dishes for intimate gatherings.

2 Spring St (Oyster Bay)

Japanese mainstay turning out fresh sushi & other basic fare in a simple setting.

17 E 48th St (New York)

Bustling eatery serving large, shareable portions of Italian comfort food in a lively setting.

147 W 43rd St (New York)

Trendy Japanese eatery serving elevated omakase dinners in a speakeasy-style setting with cocktails.

232 7th Ave (New York)

Casual, cozy eatery offering sushi, bento boxes, udon and dumplings, plus cocktails and beer.

980 6th Ave (New York)

Stylish restaurant with an industrial vibe specializing in Japanese seafood rolls.

15 W 28th St (New York)

Deli offering sandwiches, bagels, and a hot bar, plus catering, and a juice bar.

270 Jerusalem Ave (Hempstead)

Casual restaurant offering Mexican fare, including pupusas, plus cocktails and beer.

400 Fulton Ave # C (Hempstead)

Mexican eatery preparing traditional dishes, plus fajitas and margaritas served by friendly staff.

2055 Middle Country Rd (Centereach)

Stylish, bright eatery featuring market-driven Italian cuisine, regional wines & apéritifs.

1133 Broadway (New York)

Stylish, bright eatery featuring market-driven Italian cuisine, regional wines & apéritifs.

359 Columbus Ave (New York)

Deli featuring a buffet and selling pizza, beer, sandwiches, and breakfast items.

115 Main St (Hempstead)

Established Madison Square Garden-area staple serving pizzas whole and by the slice.

413 8th Ave (New York)

Pizzeria serving slices and pies, plus a selection of pasta, salads, and other standards.

888 6th Ave (New York)

Tacos, pupusas, and other Mexican dishes share the menu at this casual place with live music and karaoke nights.

114 N Franklin St (Hempstead)

Informal spot offering a variety of sushi rolls (salmon, shrimp tempura, vegetable), as well as combos.

42 W 38th St Ste 6 (New York)

Small taco joint featuring LA-style tacos, quesadillas, burritos and agua fresca.

139 W 28th St (New York)

Mexican dishes, including tacos and burritos, served in a casual setting.

2212 Middle Country Rd (Centereach)

South-of-the-border spot with outside seats offering basic fare & a renowned margarita happy hour.

608 9th Ave (New York)

Casual eatery featuring Mexican dishes, cocktails, and live music, plus late-night hours.

46 Fulton Ave Ste 6 (Hempstead)

Buzzing eatery & lounge offering Japanese dishes with a French twist, plus cocktails & beer.

311 W 43rd St (New York)

Compact diner serving up basic Mexican dishes along with burgers & breakfast fare.

665 10th Ave (New York)

Lively restaurant with colorful decor, offering typical Mexican dishes, cocktails, and brunch.

134 W 46th St (New York)

Potent drinks & a crowded warm-weather patio are the main draws at this longtime Mexican eatery.

61 7th Ave S (New York)

Chill Mexican venue offering classic fare, craft cocktails & happy-hour specials in comfy digs.

741 9th Ave (New York)

Relaxed venue with seasonal cocktails, Italian craft beers & classic Neapolitan pizza.

309 W 50th St (New York)

Intimate eatery serving brick oven pizzas and homemade Italian pastas such as gnocchi and linguini.

132 W Houston St (New York)

Guatemala-born counter-serve chain specializing in fried & grilled chicken & sides.

1665 5th Ave (Bay Shore)

Weekend brunch hot spot serving homestyle American eats with many locally sourced ingredients.

120 Hudson St (New York)

Eatery slinging familiar Italian eats such as pasta dishes, pizza and lasagna in a casual setting.

876 Connetquot Ave (Islip Terrace)

Restored Central Park icon for American fare in an elegant setting with courtyard & garden seating.

Central Park, W 67th St (New York)

Skip the grill stress and call in the pros, because Better Burger rolls up with a food truck and chefs who crank out gourmet burgers, gooey…

1070 Middle Country Rd #13 (Selden)

When you need a proper carb hug this week, Pasta Eater Hell’s Kitchen is all about homemade pasta, from rich carbonara to truffle…

744 9th Ave (New York)

When you need a weeknight pick-me-up, Noodlelove brings delicious, healthy Asian flavors with quality ingredients and thoughtful prep, all…

192 Mott St (New York)

Panchita Grill is the move when you want legit Latin comfort without leaving Smithtown. Think Nachos Panchita stacked with beef or chicken…

67 W Main St

Save yourself the charcoal splinters and let The Pigs BBQ Hideout handle dinner. A delivery-first barbecue outfit that leans into saucy,…

174 Islip Ave (Islip)

Wings 'n Things has been frying it right since 1988, serving fresh, crispy chicken with homemade sides and fall-off-the-bone ribs that…

519 Fulton Ave (Hempstead)

Straightforward fast-food restaurant offering generous burgers with French fries.

91 E 7th St (New York)

Rustic Italian fare with a seasonal twist headlines at this cash-only, simple BYOB.

532 N Country Rd (St James)

Easygoing eatery offering a mix of pizza styles & traditional Italian mains, plus a bar & take-out.

40 E Main St

A full menu of American eats & plenty of beer is on tap at this Irish-style tavern.

28 Cliff St (New York)

Energetic, greenmarket-driven hot spot by the High Line serving American fare plus a popular brunch.

156 10th Ave (New York)

Chill counter-serve place dishing up traditional Thai delicacies in snug surrounds.

331 Lexington Ave (New York)

Creative Barcelona-style tapas made with market-fresh ingredients in a warm, modern space.

1460 2nd Ave (New York)

Late-keeping restaurant offering traditional Korean specialties & booze in smart surroundings.

lower level, 11 E 32nd St (New York)

Caterer offering healthy food made with local ingredients, plus a cafe and private dining.

127 Smithtown Blvd #11 (Nesconset)

Retailer offering chocolate & related novelties, including seasonal & special-occasion gifts.

841 Broadway (New York)

Select meats, seafood, salads & a deep wine list offered in a clubby atmosphere, open since 1966.

210 E 46th St (New York)

Strip-mall hub with modern digs serving an Asian mix including sushi, chef's specials & bento boxes.

182 Terry Rd

Italian dishes such as pasta and fish served in a cozy, romantic atmosphere.

615 Hudson St (New York)

Cafe with wood & brick interior where locals gather for hearty American fare, coffee, beer & wine.

600 W 218th St (New York)

Sweet two-floor spot for sweets, coffee and brunch classics, cocktails and sandwiches.

694 8th Ave (New York)

Chinese restaurant offering noodles, dumplings & meal kits in unpretentious surroundings.

96 8th Ave (New York)

Casual pizzeria with a kids' menu serving specialty pies and other comfort food.

192 Islip Ave (Islip)

Cafe known for its creative sweet & savory crêpes also serving wraps, waffles, smoothies & espresso.

71 E Main St

Spacious, casually chic brasserie with hearty dishes featuring Californian & Italian influences.

345 Park Ave S (New York)

Ramen dishes & pork buns are the lures at this popular East Village Japanese eatery.

65 4th Ave (New York)

No-frills, cash-only burger counter hidden inside an upscale hotel.

119 W 56th St (New York)

Chain dishing up wings, tenders & burgers, plus sauces ranging from sweet to very spicy.

455 Park Ave S (New York)

This casual haunt offers bar snacks, steak dinners & plenty in between, plus varied wines & spirits.

31 8th Ave (New York)

Simple counter-serve outpost serving paella, empanadas & quesadillas, plus classic Spanish desserts.

744 9th Ave (New York)

Swanky steakhouse with a raw bar boasting walls covered with photos of old-Hollywood stars.

11 E 12th St (New York)

High-end Italian seafood & housemade pastas in a chic Central Park South setting.

240 Central Park S (New York)

Family-owned, casual joint serving BBQ dishes such as brisket/ ribs and pulled pork, along with sides like cornbread.

401 Hawkins Ave A (Lake Ronkonkoma)

Counter-serve burger joint offering quick bites in an informal setup with gas pumps.

51-63 8th Ave (New York)

Michelin-starred Flatiron District tavern featuring a menu of modern, seasonal American dishes.

42 E 20th St (New York)

Charming, seasonally inspired eatery known for cocktails and wines alongside creative dishes.

99 Bank St (New York)

Neighborhood fixture since 1969 serving huge menu of American faves in simple, comfy surrounds.

92 E Main St

Ramen, Korean fried chicken & other Asian offerings in a down-to-earth establishment.

618 Amsterdam Ave (New York)

Bustling New American eatery with huge windows & an emphasis on farm-fresh fare.

54 Carmine St (New York)

Modern Latin fare served with signature cocktails in funky quarters.

216 7th Ave (New York)

Rustic sports bar with an enormous selection of beer, plus bar eats like ribs & wings.

126 Chambers St (New York)

Cozy venue providing Italian plates paired with wine, beer, and cocktails, plus vegetarian and vegan options.

260 Islip Ave (Islip)

Traditional Italian dishes, pizzas, and cocktails served in a relaxed, industrial-chic restaurant.

474 9th Ave (New York)

Sophisticated chophouse chain serving steak, seafood, sandwiches & cocktails in a lively setting.

250 Vesey St (New York)

Chicken joint known for its spicy, Nashville-style tenders, sliders, and kale slaw.

944 8th Ave (New York)

Italian cuisine, including seafood, served in an intimate space with a full bar & wine list.

1870 E Jericho Tpke (Huntington)

Casual fixture featuring rice bowls containing a variety of fish and fresh ingredients, plus an array of toppings and sauces.

80 Broad St (New York)

Barcelona-style tapas & a deep menu of Spanish wines can be shared in this compact, busy spot.

53 W 19th St (New York)

Laid-back restaurant showcasing Italian fare such as pizza and homemade pasta and featuring a wine bar and outdoor seating.

637 Hudson St (New York)

Mediterranean-inspired small plates, beer, and wine served in a casual setting that has a bar.

487 Main St (Northport)

Unfussy Italian eatery offering pasta, pizza & meat dishes, plus weekend brunch, wine & cocktails.

2791 Broadway (New York)

Breakfast basics, diner favorites and burgers are served at this casual eatery with a cozy vibe.

156 E Main St

Informal Spanish storefront restaurant & tapas bar featuring Galician fare with wines & cocktails.

192 Grand St (New York)

Restaurant featuring leather booths and a zinc bar, serving creative American fare.

33 Cortlandt Alley (New York)

Upscale restaurant with a fireplace and live music serving a Spanish menu including seafood and tapas.

1095 Jericho Tpke (Commack)

Several varieties of ramen plus soup dumplings, pork buns & more offered in a busy, no-frills space.

811 8th Ave (New York)

Upscale chain for aged prime beef, seafood & other traditional steakhouse fare in a clubby space.

136 Washington St (New York)

Casual restaurant for Italian cuisine plus steaks and other Mediterranean eats, along with wines.

404 N Country Rd

Outpost of a chain specializing in traditional New York-style sandwiches, plus build-your-own options.

16 W 23rd St (New York)

Burgers and other American comfort food served in a sports bar setting with happy hour specials.

250 W 54th St (New York)

Busy, bustling restaurant offering Korean barbecue, fried rice & other classic fare.

312 5th Ave 2nd floor (New York)

Breezy eatery for handmade pasta dishes and sauces, plus a range of toppings.

165 1st Ave (New York)

Modern bistro chain serving gourmet meat & veggie burgers.

630 9th Ave (New York)

Casual, contemporary Japanese restaurant serving sushi, hibachi, tempura, noodles & more.

9 E Main St

Vibrant American bistro with a convivial bar offering happy hours, brunch, and an outdoor patio.

501 E Main St (Islip)

Classic red-sauce specialties and vegan versions are available at this vintage-1908 Italian eatery.

302 E 12th St (New York)

Narrow Italian eatery with counter-service offering organic pasta, housemade sauces & classic sides.

102 MacDougal St (New York)

Pub serving classic Irish-American fare as well as beer and cocktails in a family-friendly setting.

528 E Main St (Islip)

Naples meets NYC at this trattoria with thin-crust pizza, Italian wines & ample sidewalk seating.

3 Greenwich Ave (New York)

Casual, contemporary spot offering a wide-ranging menu and full bar. Pizza and wine are a specialty, as well as other Italian dishes.

517 E Main St (Islip)

Warm, casual spot dishing up all-organic burgers (lamb, turkey and bison too) plus fries and milkshakes.

120 Church St (New York)

Stylish, lively spot dishing out upscale burgers, hot dogs and salads alongside cocktails, beers and wine.

45 E 33rd St (New York)

Locally sourced, upscale American cuisine served in a barn-inspired setting with a chef’s table.

19 E 26th St (New York)

Sleek destination turning out Asian fusion BBQ & small plates with creative cocktails.

647 9th Ave (New York)

Upscale restaurant for Greek staples (with a twist), plus DJ music and hookah.

123 Washington St (New York)

Upscale Tuscan-American restaurant in a warm setting with an open kitchen & a large wine list.

403 E 12th St (New York)

Sprawling entertainment venue with a high-tech driving range & swanky lounge with drinks & games.

5231 Express Dr N (Holtsville)

Flavorsome Greek specialties served in an elegant eatery with both indoor and outdoor settings.

226 3rd Ave (New York)

Cocktail spot known for its signature Clementine Cocktail, plus food such as steak frites and escargot.

553 E Main St (Islip)

Greek restaurant from Long Island with traditional cuisine and prix fixe lunch menu in a contemporary setting.

15 W 18th St (New York)

Serves Korean BBQ and other traditional dishes in a casual, open-timbered space with in-table grills.

22 W 32nd St 2nd floor (New York)

Easygoing restaurant specializing in feijoada & other Brazilian dishes, plus cachaça cocktails.

43 Carmine St (New York)

A lantern-lit indoor garden & live jazz in the adjoining bar complement light Italian fare.

129 MacDougal St (New York)

Snug, contemporary cafe specializing in Korean fried chicken, plus modern Asian bites & beer.

248 W 106th St (New York)

American restaurant by Tom Colicchio in the landmark Beekman Hotel with a sumptuous design.

5 Beekman St (New York)

Chef Thomas Keller's New American restaurant offers luxe fixed-price menus, with Central Park views.

10 Columbus Cir (New York)

Cozy eatery offering breakfast, lunch, and mimosas, including vegan options.

204 Smithtown Blvd Unit 8 (Nesconset)