The best restaurants in Smithtown
36 places we’ve checked and would send a neighbor to. Open any one to read what we wrote about it.
Your business could be here.
Be at the top of Smithtown's page when you're in Smithtown's newsletter.
Local businesses pay to be shown here. A person checks every one.
Azulejos Fine Mexican Cuisine (opens in a new tab)
368 E Main St
Azulejos Fine Mexican Cuisine pairs traditional preparation and natural ingredients with standouts like fresh grouper, sea scallops, and…
Sun Island Plate (opens in a new tab)
820 S Orange Ave · Newark
Craving smoky jerk chicken, rich oxtail, or curry goat? Sun Island Plate serves Jamaican favorites in Newark, with Rasta pasta for when…
Islip Country Deli (opens in a new tab)
240 E Main St · Islip
From breakfast sandwiches and griddle favorites to heroes, salads, and catering platters, Islip Country Deli has the familiar deli lineup…
Insignia Prime Steak & Sushi (opens in a new tab)
610 Smithtown Bypass
Insignia Prime Steak & Sushi pairs prime dry-aged steaks and exotic beef cuts with fresh seafood and creative sushi, all in a chic,…
Takki Ramen (opens in a new tab)
97 E Main St
For Japanese comfort food that blends traditional flavors with a modern, fusion-inspired menu, Takki Ramen is a Smithtown spot worth…
Nino's Delicatessen (opens in a new tab)
75 W Main St
Nino's Delicatessen aims to make fresh food with a good attitude, with a wide-ranging menu for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. It’s also a…
Salsa Salsa of Smithtown (opens in a new tab)
320 Maple Ave
Salsa Salsa Smithtown serves Mexican standards with plenty of taco choices, from a la carte tacos and trios to flights and street tacos.…
Sunshine Halal Restaurant (opens in a new tab)
5 S Munn Ave · Newark
From beef sausage and egg sandwiches to waffles, omelets, and breakfast wraps, Sunshine Halal Restaurant brings plenty of halal choices to…
Subway (opens in a new tab)
660 Islip Ave · Brentwood
Casual counter-serve chain for build-your-own sandwiches & salads, with health-conscious options.
Wendy's (opens in a new tab)
168 E Main St · Islip
Fast-food burger chain serving sides such as chili & baked potatoes.
Burger King (opens in a new tab)
942 W Jericho Turnpike
Well-known fast-food chain serving grilled burgers, fries & shakes.
Del Fuego (opens in a new tab)
430 N Country Rd · St James
Easy eatery offering Tex-Mex dishes & a long list of tequilas in festive cantina-roadhouse digs.
Branchinelli's Pizza & Restaurant (opens in a new tab)
555 NY-111 · Hauppauge
Casual strip-mall restaurant & pizza parlor attracts crowds with hearty helpings of Italian staples.
Nrgize (opens in a new tab)
122 E Main St
Counter-serve chain known for its low-sugar smoothies, custom protein shakes & other drinks.
Chick-fil-A (opens in a new tab)
530 Smithtown Bypass
Fast-food chain serving chicken sandwiches & nuggets along with salads & sides.
Subway (opens in a new tab)
1217 NY-25A
Casual counter-serve chain for build-your-own sandwiches & salads, with health-conscious options.
Pace's Steak House (opens in a new tab)
325 Smithtown Bypass · Hauppauge
High-end chophouse serving signature dry-aged beef & seafood with a deep wine list & bustling bar.
Chipotle Mexican Grill (opens in a new tab)
387 Smithtown Bypass · Hauppauge
Casual restaurant offering Mexican fare, including design-your-own burritos, tacos & bowls.
Subway (opens in a new tab)
173 B Smithtown Blvd · Nesconset
Casual counter-serve chain for build-your-own sandwiches & salads, with health-conscious options.
Hauppauge Palace Diner (opens in a new tab)
525 Smithtown Bypass · Hauppauge
From breakfast to late-night snacks, this basic diner delivers comfort-food faves at all hours.
Taco Bell (opens in a new tab)
773 Smithtown Bypass
Fast-food chain serving Mexican-inspired fare such as tacos, quesadillas & nachos.
Tropical Smoothie Cafe (opens in a new tab)
32 E Main St
Health-conscious cafe chain featuring a menu of custom smoothies, sandwiches & wraps.
Panera Bread (opens in a new tab)
399 Nesconset Hwy · Hauppauge
Counter-serve bakery/cafe chain serving sandwiches, salads & more, known for its bread & free WiFi.
Tim Hortons (opens in a new tab)
819 W Jericho Turnpike
Canadian chain for signature premium-blend coffee, plus light fare, pastries & breakfast sandwiches.
Vintage Steak House (opens in a new tab)
433 N Country Rd · St James
Lodgelike chophouse with steer-themed decor pairs high-end steaks & fish with an ample wine list.
Kotobuki (opens in a new tab)
377 Nesconset Hwy · Hauppauge
Straightforward sashimi shares a menu with unusual rolls & other Japanese fare in a modern space.
McDonald's (opens in a new tab)
107 E Main St · Islip
Classic, long-running fast-food chain known for its burgers & fries.
El Toro Restaurant and Deli (opens in a new tab)
255 Fulton Ave #B · Hempstead
Relaxed family-owned cantina serving tacos, burritos & other Mexican standards, plus margaritas.
Pollos Mario Steak House & Seafood (opens in a new tab)
75 N Franklin St · Hempstead
Laid-back and family friendly, Pollos Mario Steak House & Seafood delivers the kind of Colombian comfort that fixes weeknights fast, from…
La Hacienda (opens in a new tab)
392 Clinton St · Hempstead
Compact outfit serving a range of Central American specialties & enduring favorites like burritos.
Layered Delights LLC (opens in a new tab)
899 18th Ave · Newark
Layered Delights LLC keeps it Jersey with brioche bacon egg and cheese in the morning, crisp-crust arugula pizza and garlic or spicy wings…
Tango Argentinian Steakhouse (opens in a new tab)
99 W Suffolk Ave · Central Islip
Relaxed Argentinian steakhouse serving up a menu of meat, seafood & pasta, plus wines.
J&R's Islip Steak House (opens in a new tab)
116 E Main St · Islip
J&R's Islip Steak House serves marinated steaks, premium burgers, combos, and seafood in a laid-back, family-friendly setting. It’s a…
George's Pizzaria Inc (opens in a new tab)
726 W 181st St · New York
No-frills counter-service shop offering pizza by the slice or pie, plus gyros, wings & pastas.
Justin’s BBQ & Cafe (opens in a new tab)
798 Mt Prospect Ave · Newark
Justin’s BBQ & Cafe is that casual, local go-to for strong espresso, real deal breakfast, and stacked sandwiches, plus the smoky barbecue…
The Uptown Garrison (opens in a new tab)
821 W 181st St · New York
Cocktails & upscale comfort fare, including breakfast, served in a cozy, rustic-chic tiled setting.
Wimpy's (opens in a new tab)
1232 St Nicholas Ave · New York
Snug counter serve offering pizza, burritos & casual grub such as sandwiches & hamburgers.
Tropical Juice Bar (opens in a new tab)
879 Franklin Ave · Newark
When East Orange mornings need a boost, Tropical Juice Bar mixes fresh smoothies and juices with made-to-order Caribbean-style meals and…
Guac & chips Mexican grill (opens in a new tab)
3853 Broadway · New York
Guac & Chips Mexican Grill nails the post-commute craving with crunchy chips, fresh guac, and no-nonsense tacos and burritos that actually…
iPizzaNY (opens in a new tab)
3801 Broadway · New York
New York-style pizzeria offering pies and slices in a casual setting.
Taco Bell (opens in a new tab)
1351 St Nicholas Ave · New York
Fast-food chain serving Mexican-inspired fare such as tacos, quesadillas & nachos.
Mambi (opens in a new tab)
4181 Broadway · New York
When you need a plate of straight-up Dominican comfort, Mambi in Washington Heights comes through with crisp empanadas, garlicky mofongo,…
Geisha Asian Fusion (opens in a new tab)
4186 Broadway · New York
Asian restaurant popular for sushi and bento boxes, plus dumplings and tempura.
Fresco's Pizzeria (opens in a new tab)
804 W 187th St · New York
Low-key, contemporary counter serve also serving pasta dishes, gourmet salads & panini.
Exclusive Pizza (opens in a new tab)
810 W 181st St · New York
Exclusive Pizza slings jumbo slices and Indian-inspired pies that actually slap, from Palak Paneer to Chicken Masala, plus the usual NYC…
Jersey Mike's Subs (opens in a new tab)
4055 Broadway · New York
New Jersey–based counter-serve sandwich chain serving jumbo subs filled with cold cuts & toppings.
Bono Trattoria (opens in a new tab)
3658 Broadway · New York
Italian dishes & pizza served in cool industrial digs with a tin ceiling, brick oven & rustic bar.
Tampopo Kitchen (opens in a new tab)
805 W 187th St · New York
Snug, counter-service eatery dishing up Japanese favorites such as udon and sushi, along with ramen and tempura.
Cabrini Juicery (opens in a new tab)
817 W 187th St · New York
Casual juice shop offering a variety of drinks plus sandwiches, and acai bowls.
Sofrito (opens in a new tab)
679 Riverside Dr · New York
Sofrito brings authentic Puerto Rican cuisine, vibrant music, and that breezy Caribbean vibe to a polished room where brunch turns into a…
Floridita (opens in a new tab)
4162 Broadway · New York
Since 1995, Floridita has been the neighborhood go-to for Cuban-Dominican plates that actually taste like somebody’s abuela cooked, plus…
Famous Famiglia Pizzeria (opens in a new tab)
4020 Broadway · New York
Pizza chain offering NYC-style pies & other familiar Italian fare in a counter-serve setting.
Tacosmoy Food Truck (opens in a new tab)
1221 St Nicholas Ave · New York
Tacosmoy Food Truck keeps it simple and satisfying with quick, legit tacos and burritos that actually taste like someone cared. Perfect for…
Lobster Steakhouse (opens in a new tab)
4227 Broadway · New York
Steakhouse serving seafood and small plates in addition to beer, wine, and cocktails.
Omar's Cafe PR (opens in a new tab)
646 Mt Prospect Ave · Newark
When you need a real deal pick me up, Omar's Cafe PR hits with crispy empanadas, chicharron de pollo, pernil with arroz con gandules, and…
Fort Washington Public House (opens in a new tab)
3938 Broadway · New York
Relaxed hangout for American fare plus cocktails featuring house-infused liquors, beer & wine.
Saggio (opens in a new tab)
827 W 181st St · New York
Little hideaway for Southern Italian specialties & diverse wines served amid a warm, intimate vibe.
El Conde Bar & Grill (opens in a new tab)
1263 St Nicholas Ave · New York
El Conde Bar & Grill in Washington Heights turns out juicy skirt steak, mofongo with shrimp, and other Caribbean-Latin comforts, plus fresh…
Pizzeria L'Antica (opens in a new tab)
3789 Broadway · New York
Casual eatery dishing up New York-style pies and slices along with chicken tenders and pasta.
Koronet Pizza (opens in a new tab)
4087 Broadway · New York
Known for crispy-crust pies and jumbo slices big enough to be a two-hander, Koronet Pizza keeps it simple and satisfying with classic…
Wahi Diner (opens in a new tab)
3915 Broadway · New York
Unfussy, always-open establishment serving traditional American favorites like pancakes & burgers.
Terravita Uptown (opens in a new tab)
4193 Broadway · New York
Relaxed option furnishing a diverse selection of international plates & snacks, plus weekend brunch.
Caribbean Station Dominican Cuisine (opens in a new tab)
879 Franklin Ave Unit 3 · Newark
Caribbean Station Dominican Cuisine keeps it easygoing with roast chicken, hearty stews, and pernil that tastes like a Sunday at abuela’s.…
Dallas BBQ Washington Heights (opens in a new tab)
3956 Broadway · New York
Bustling local chain serving big plates of saucy meats & other classic fare plus jumbo margaritas.
Mexican Rooster newark nj (opens in a new tab)
736 Mt Prospect Ave · Newark
Mexican Rooster Newark is that reliable move when you want legit tacos al pastor, big parrilladas de mariscos, and comforty plates like…
The Calaveras NYC (opens in a new tab)
949 Columbus Ave · New York
Chill choice for Mexican cuisine with a vibrantly decorated space & a petite patio.
Taqueria On Tenth (opens in a new tab)
313 10th Ave · New York
Casual restaurant with a sizable tequila selection and Mexican fare such as tacos and birria.
2 Spring (opens in a new tab)
2 Spring St · Oyster Bay
Sophisticated, modern American eatery plating tasting menus and multi-course dishes for intimate gatherings.
Hatsuhana (opens in a new tab)
17 E 48th St · New York
Hatsuhana salutes centuries-old techniques and keeps the focus on sushi fundamentals, precision, and balance. When you just want the…
Tony's Di Napoli (opens in a new tab)
147 W 43rd St · New York
Bustling eatery serving large, shareable portions of Italian comfort food in a lively setting.
Madison Pizza NYC (opens in a new tab)
14 E 37th St · New York
Madison Pizza NYC keeps your slice rotation interesting, with a tri color slice striping vodka, margherita, and pesto, plus a Buffalo…
Sushi by Bou- Chelsea NYC @ Bosque Flowers & Coffee (opens in a new tab)
232 7th Ave · New York
Hidden inside a flower-and-coffee shop, Sushi by Bou- Chelsea NYC @ Bosque Flowers & Coffee serves speakeasy-style, chef-led omakase that…
Sushi & Co-Midtown (opens in a new tab)
980 6th Ave · New York
Sushi & Co-Midtown nails the quick-but-good thing, with black rice sushi, the signature Sushi Taco, and make-your-own sushi boxes that hit…
Coney Island Diner and Bazaar (opens in a new tab)
495 Orange St · Newark
When you want a cozy, halal breakfast that actually satisfies, Coney Island Diner and Bazaar brings classic American plates, Mexican…
KazuNori: The Original Hand Roll Bar (opens in a new tab)
15 W 28th St · New York
Stylish restaurant with an industrial vibe specializing in Japanese seafood rolls.
270 Deli NY Inc. (opens in a new tab)
270 Jerusalem Ave · Hempstead
270 Deli NY Inc. is a nearby go-to keeping locals fueled with hefty sandwiches, fresh bagels, a legit hot bar, and a juice bar when you…
Camelitas (opens in a new tab)
400 Fulton Ave # C · Hempstead
Camelitas is serving the kind of Mexican you brag about to your group chat, with traditional recipes dialed up using quality ingredients…
Plaza Margarita Restaurant (opens in a new tab)
2055 Middle Country Rd · Centereach
Mexican eatery preparing traditional dishes, plus fajitas and margaritas served by friendly staff.
La Pecora Bianca NoMad (opens in a new tab)
1133 Broadway · New York
Stylish, bright eatery featuring market-driven Italian cuisine, regional wines & apéritifs.
Starbucks Coffee Company (opens in a new tab)
455 E Main St · Islip
Welcoming coffeehouse with handcrafted coffee, espresso & tea, plus breakfast, lunch & pastries.
Sushi Tokoro Madison Ave (opens in a new tab)
285 Madison Ave #106 · New York
Next time you trek west, Sushi Tokoro Madison Ave nails the hand-roll bar vibe with clean cuts, fresh ingredients, and simple, balanced…
La Pecora Bianca UWS (opens in a new tab)
359 Columbus Ave · New York
La Pecora Bianca UWS nails the market-driven Italian thing with a bright, stylish room, seasonal plates, and a lineup of regional wines and…
Eternal Deli (opens in a new tab)
115 Main St · Hempstead
When you need a quick win, Eternal Deli comes through with egg sandwiches, omelettes, lox bagels, cheesy pizzas, and stacked subs and wraps…
NY Pizza Suprema (opens in a new tab)
413 8th Ave · New York
Established Madison Square Garden-area staple serving pizzas whole and by the slice.
La Bella Pizzeria (opens in a new tab)
342 Lexington Ave · Oyster Bay
La Bella Pizzeria in Oyster Bay turns cravings into rituals with authentic Italian recipes and a specialty pie lineup that goes beyond…
Quality Pizza Co. Midtown (opens in a new tab)
888 6th Ave · New York
Quality Pizza Co. Midtown covers the classics, but the menu gets more adventurous with Grandma and Sicilian squares, spicy pepperoni, and…
Jalapeño (opens in a new tab)
114 N Franklin St · Hempstead
Tacos, pupusas, and other Mexican dishes share the menu at this casual place with live music and karaoke nights.
Katsu Sushi (opens in a new tab)
42 W 38th St Ste 6 · New York
Informal spot offering a variety of sushi rolls (salmon, shrimp tempura, vegetable), as well as combos.
Taqueria by El Prieto NYC (opens in a new tab)
139 W 28th St · New York
Small taco joint featuring LA-style tacos, quesadillas, burritos and agua fresca.
El Rodeo Taco. Bar & Grill (opens in a new tab)
2212 Middle Country Rd · Centereach
El Rodeo Taco. Bar & Grill keeps it casual and genuine with a family-owned vibe, fresh ingredients, and plates that taste like someone…
Patron Mexican Grill (opens in a new tab)
608 9th Ave · New York
South-of-the-border spot with outside seats offering basic fare & a renowned margarita happy hour.
El Guadalajara Bar & Grill (opens in a new tab)
46 Fulton Ave Ste 6 · Hempstead
El Guadalajara Bar & Grill nails the fun side of Mexican dining with flavorful plates, cocktails that know how to mingle, and a steady…
Fushimi Times Square (opens in a new tab)
311 W 43rd St · New York
Buzzing eatery & lounge offering Japanese dishes with a French twist, plus cocktails & beer.
Tulcingo Del Valle (opens in a new tab)
665 10th Ave · New York
Neighborhood tip: Tulcingo Del Valle turns out legit Mexican classics like mole poblano, cochinita pibil, and sopa de mariscos, plus hand…
Amor Loco (opens in a new tab)
134 W 46th St · New York
Amor Loco brings Mexican-inspired dishes, cocktails, and brunch to the table in a lively, colorful setting. Come for the tacos, stay for…
Caliente Cab Co. (opens in a new tab)
61 7th Ave S · New York
Potent drinks & a crowded warm-weather patio are the main draws at this longtime Mexican eatery.
Rancho Tequileria (opens in a new tab)
741 9th Ave · New York
Chill Mexican venue offering classic fare, craft cocktails & happy-hour specials in comfy digs.
Don Antonio (opens in a new tab)
309 W 50th St · New York
Relaxed venue with seasonal cocktails, Italian craft beers & classic Neapolitan pizza.
Song' E Napule (opens in a new tab)
132 W Houston St · New York
Song' E Napule turns out blistered brick-oven pies with that soft-chewy Neapolitan center, plus homemade pastas like gnocchi and linguini…
Piscitelli Pizza & Pasta (opens in a new tab)
3668 John F. Kennedy Blvd · Jersey City
Piscitelli Pizza & Pasta nails the old-school Italian comfort thing with a few fun twists. Think star-shaped pies stuffed with ricotta,…
Mike's Restaurant (opens in a new tab)
602 Palisade Ave · Jersey City
Craving easy, satisfying Mexican comfort without overthinking dinner? Mike's Restaurant has you covered with straightforward flavors and…
Sabor A Veracruz (opens in a new tab)
992 Summit Ave · Jersey City
Sabor A Veracruz is a straightforward Mexican restaurant in Jersey City that keeps things simple and convenient with online ordering and…
PizzaStudio (opens in a new tab)
Food court in Newport Center Mall, 30 Mall Dr W · Jersey City
Modern chain serving pizzas made with flavored crusts & a range of sauces & creative toppings.
Renato's Pizza Masters (opens in a new tab)
278 Central Ave · Jersey City
Longtime eatery for classic Italian fare in an unassuming storefront with tucked-away dining space.
Corto (opens in a new tab)
507 Palisade Ave · Jersey City
Casual neighborhood option crafting seasonal Italian cuisine in an airy venue with a vintage vibe.
Hibachi Grill & Supreme Buffet (opens in a new tab)
701 NJ-440 · Jersey City
Roomy all-you-can-eat mall restaurant offering sushi & various hot or cold Asian & American dishes.
Bubby's (opens in a new tab)
120 Hudson St · New York
Weekend brunch hot spot serving homestyle American eats with many locally sourced ingredients.
Mary's Pizza and Pasta (opens in a new tab)
876 Connetquot Ave · Islip Terrace
Eatery slinging familiar Italian eats such as pasta dishes, pizza and lasagna in a casual setting.
Felina Steak Jersey City (opens in a new tab)
2 Chapel Ave Unit 2 · Jersey City
Felina Steak Jersey City is a sleek, modern Italian steakhouse with sweeping city views, where a dry-aging room and a live lobster tank set…
Tavern On the Green (opens in a new tab)
Central Park, W 67th St · New York
Tavern On the Green is that rare Manhattan classic that still feels fresh, with courtyard and garden seating, deviled eggs three ways,…
Pasta Eater Hell’s Kitchen (opens in a new tab)
744 9th Ave · New York
When you need a proper carb hug this week, Pasta Eater Hell’s Kitchen is all about homemade pasta, from rich carbonara to truffle…
noodlelove (opens in a new tab)
192 Mott St · New York
When you need a weeknight pick-me-up, Noodlelove brings delicious, healthy Asian flavors with quality ingredients and thoughtful prep, all…
La Panchita Mexican, Spanish, & Latin Cuisine (opens in a new tab)
67 W Main St
La Panchita Mexican, Spanish, & Latin Cuisine brings together Mexican, Spanish, and Latin cooking with margaritas, sangria, and weekend…
The Pigs BBQ Hideout (opens in a new tab)
174 Islip Ave · Islip
Save yourself the charcoal splinters and let The Pigs BBQ Hideout handle dinner. A delivery-first barbecue outfit that leans into saucy,…
Seabra's Marisqueira (opens in a new tab)
87 Madison St · Newark
Craving legit Portuguese flavors that taste like a seaside vacation without the TSA? Seabra's Marisqueira has been serving Newark since…
Wilson Ave BBQ (opens in a new tab)
195-197 Wilson Ave · Newark
Wilson Ave BBQ in Newark is all about juicy, tender ribs and perfectly seasoned chicken, with generous portions and bold,…
Wings 'n Things (opens in a new tab)
519 Fulton Ave · Hempstead
Wings 'n Things has been frying it right since 1988, serving fresh, crispy chicken with homemade sides and fall-off-the-bone ribs that…
Tellers: An American Chophouse (opens in a new tab)
605 E Main St · Islip
Tellers: An American Chophouse is the kind of local institution you save for when you're feeling fancy, then remember why you should go…
Uncle Willie's Wings (opens in a new tab)
One Gateway Ctr · Newark
Uncle Willie's Wings delivers crisp, juicy wings coated in real-deal specialty sauces, from friendly heat to you-might-need-a-milkshake,…
7th Street Burger East Village (opens in a new tab)
91 E 7th St · New York
When you just want a no-nonsense burger that hits every time, 7th Street Burger East Village keeps it tight with made-to-order…
Nothing here matches that.
Try a shorter word, or look through every kind of place in Smithtown.
Know a great place we’re missing? Email hello@baselocal.com
Showing the 120 most recent of 433. See what changed this month
The best of Smithtown, every morning
New places show up in the Smithtown newsletter first. It's free.
One email a day. Unsubscribe anytime.