The best sporting goods shops in Smithtown

2 places we’ve checked and would send a neighbor to. Open any one to read what we wrote about it.

2 places · newest first

Your business could be here.

Be at the top of Smithtown's page when you're in Smithtown's newsletter.

Put my business here

Local businesses pay to be shown here. A person checks every one.

Smithtown Running Company (opens in a new tab)

91 E Main St

Whether you're chasing PRs or just making dog walks feel less creaky, Smithtown Running Company pairs expert fitting with a deep lineup of…

Whether you're chasing PRs or just making dog walks feel less creaky, Smithtown Running Company pairs expert fitting with a deep lineup of running, walking, and training shoes. They back the local race scene and are often named among America’s best, so your feet are in good hands.

From the Suffolk County newsletter, October 30, 2026

New Balance SoHo (opens in a new tab)

542 Broadway · New York

Need new miles or just something clean for strolling Broadway back home? Make a quick hop to New Balance SoHo for the full collection of…

Need new miles or just something clean for strolling Broadway back home? Make a quick hop to New Balance SoHo for the full collection of running and lifestyle shoes, apparel and accessories. The in-store 3D foot scanner dials in your fit so your Bayonne steps feel better.

From the Manhattan newsletter, October 23, 2026

Arc'teryx Flatiron (opens in a new tab)

149 5th Ave · New York

Store carrying outdoor clothing and equipment for men and women such as weatherproof jackets, pants, and sweaters.

Store carrying outdoor clothing and equipment for men and women such as weatherproof jackets, pants, and sweaters.

Peak Design NYC Store (opens in a new tab)

241 Lafayette St · New York

Whether you’re hauling camera gear, commuting with a slick everyday sling, or hunting for a travel carry-on that doesn’t quit, Peak Design…

Whether you’re hauling camera gear, commuting with a slick everyday sling, or hunting for a travel carry-on that doesn’t quit, Peak Design NYC Store lets you test-drive the goods, pick brains for expert advice, and dial in a setup that actually fits your routine.

From the Manhattan newsletter, November 6, 2026

Amundsen New York (opens in a new tab)

262 Mott St · New York

Amundsen New York brings together outdoor clothing and equipment for men and women, with a focus on heritage-inspired design and natural…

Amundsen New York brings together outdoor clothing and equipment for men and women, with a focus on heritage-inspired design and natural materials. It’s a good spot to browse for pieces made for life outside, whether your idea of adventure involves a mountain trail or simply dressing like you might find one.

From the Manhattan newsletter, November 13, 2026

Orvis NY 5th Avenue (opens in a new tab)

489 5th Ave · New York

Fly-fishing and outdoor-sports gear, plus stylish clothing for men and women.

Fly-fishing and outdoor-sports gear, plus stylish clothing for men and women.

L.L.Bean (opens in a new tab)

220 Smith Haven Mall · Lake Grove

Retailer offering a variety of outdoor apparel & footwear, plus sporting & camping gear.

Retailer offering a variety of outdoor apparel & footwear, plus sporting & camping gear.

Fleet Feet Columbus Circle (opens in a new tab)

10 Columbus Cir · New York

Sleek sporting goods store specializing in running, including gait analysis, events & group runs.

Sleek sporting goods store specializing in running, including gait analysis, events & group runs.

Supreme (opens in a new tab)

190 Bowery · New York

Supreme brings together skateboards and related gear, sneakers, and its own streetwear in a shop rooted in New York skate culture. Whether…

Supreme brings together skateboards and related gear, sneakers, and its own streetwear in a shop rooted in New York skate culture. Whether you need a fresh setup or just want to browse the latest mix of skate and style, it’s a worthwhile SoHo stop.

From the Manhattan newsletter, October 30, 2026