The best book, hobby & craft shops in Smithtown

11 places we’ve checked and would send a neighbor to. Open any one to read what we wrote about it.

11 places · newest first

Your business could be here.

Be at the top of Smithtown's page when you're in Smithtown's newsletter.

Put my business here

Local businesses pay to be shown here. A person checks every one.

Kyle's Comics (opens in a new tab)

1029 W Jericho Turnpike

Kyle's Comics buys, sells, and trades comics and collectibles, from Golden Age finds to modern issues, plus CGC- and CBCS-graded books.…

Kyle's Comics buys, sells, and trades comics and collectibles, from Golden Age finds to modern issues, plus CGC- and CBCS-graded books. Whether you’re tracking down a hard-to-find title or ready to part with a collection, Kyle’s experience and deep inventory make this Smithtown shop worth a look.

From the Smithtown newsletter, November 11, 2026

Recirculation, a project of Word Up (opens in a new tab)

876 Riverside Dr · New York

Recirculation, a project of Word Up keeps books and records moving through the neighborhood with pay-what-you-can finds, a kids’ corner…

Recirculation, a project of Word Up keeps books and records moving through the neighborhood with pay-what-you-can finds, a kids’ corner mural by MC Maniphes, and a steady stream of community events like collage nights, clothing repair circles, readings, and jams, ideal for Mount Vernon folks craving low-key browsing.

From the The Bronx newsletter, November 12, 2026

The Fountain Bookshop (opens in a new tab)

803 W 187th St · New York

The Fountain Bookshop makes browsing easy with staff picks, bestsellers, audiobooks, local-author titles, and book clubs for readers who…

The Fountain Bookshop makes browsing easy with staff picks, bestsellers, audiobooks, local-author titles, and book clubs for readers who enjoy a little company with their next read. There’s even an ice cream shop in the mix, because a good book and a sweet treat are a pretty solid pairing.

From the The Bronx newsletter, November 18, 2026

Newbury Comics (opens in a new tab)

313 Smith Haven Mall · Lake Grove

Source for music, movies, comics & other pop culture goods, with an emphasis on independent artists.

Source for music, movies, comics & other pop culture goods, with an emphasis on independent artists.

The Corner Bookstore (opens in a new tab)

1313 Madison Ave · New York

Since 1978, The Corner Bookstore has been handpicking the best of the best across fiction, nonfiction, history, biography, travel,…

Since 1978, The Corner Bookstore has been handpicking the best of the best across fiction, nonfiction, history, biography, travel, cookbooks, poetry, mysteries, and art, and they host frequent author events. It’s the kind of Carnegie Hill staple where staff recommendations actually hit.

From the The Bronx newsletter, September 16, 2026

Revolution Books (opens in a new tab)

437 Malcolm X Blvd · New York

Revolution Books is a radical indie bookstore where global books and DVDs share shelf space with ideas that actually make you think. Swing…

Revolution Books is a radical indie bookstore where global books and DVDs share shelf space with ideas that actually make you think. Swing by for thought-provoking events and film discussions, then leave with something that sparks debate at dinner instead of another half-read bestseller.

From the The Bronx newsletter, October 8, 2026

Sister's Uptown Bookstore (opens in a new tab)

1942 Amsterdam Ave · New York

Need a little inspiration between subway stops this week? Sister's Uptown Bookstore is Harlem’s longest continually operating Black-owned…

Need a little inspiration between subway stops this week? Sister's Uptown Bookstore is Harlem’s longest continually operating Black-owned bookstore, with a curated selection, local author love, and community vibes from open mics to workshops... the kind of spot where your TBR grows and your spirit does too.

From the The Bronx newsletter, October 22, 2026

Crosswords & Gifts (opens in a new tab)

307 Hawkins Ave · Ronkonkoma

Crosswords & Gifts is a local Christian bookstore and gift shop with faith-centered reads and thoughtful keepsakes that make last-minute…

Crosswords & Gifts is a local Christian bookstore and gift shop with faith-centered reads and thoughtful keepsakes that make last-minute gifting feel intentional. They post new merchandise on Facebook, so you can snag something uplifting for a friend, your small group, or your own coffee table.

From the Suffolk County newsletter, October 19, 2026

Word Up Community Bookshop/Librería Comunitaria (opens in a new tab)

2113 Amsterdam Ave · New York

Volunteer-run and wonderfully bilingual, Word Up Community Bookshop/Librería Comunitaria stocks general-interest reads in many languages,…

Volunteer-run and wonderfully bilingual, Word Up Community Bookshop/Librería Comunitaria stocks general-interest reads in many languages, then turns around and throws community events that actually feel like community, from Uptown Kid Lit to neighborhood programs like Recirculation and The People’s Fridge.

From the Poughkeepsie newsletter, September 9, 2026

Rizzoli Bookstore (opens in a new tab)

1133 Broadway · New York

Rizzoli Bookstore is the rare spot where you can lose an hour in lush illustrated tomes, serious literature, and European magazines, then…

Rizzoli Bookstore is the rare spot where you can lose an hour in lush illustrated tomes, serious literature, and European magazines, then stick around for an author talk or their Rizzoli Music Aperitivo.

From the Manhattan newsletter, October 1, 2026

Book Culture (opens in a new tab)

536 W 112th St · New York

Skip the algorithm this week and let Book Culture do the curating. Between staff picks that actually hit, new academic titles, best…

Skip the algorithm this week and let Book Culture do the curating. Between staff picks that actually hit, new academic titles, best sellers, and those dangerous window displays, you’ll find something to sink into... maybe even a book club pick that becomes your next personality.

From the New Rochelle newsletter, October 20, 2026

Barnes & Noble (opens in a new tab)

600 Smith Haven Mall · Lake Grove

Bookseller chain stocking housebrand eReader, plus a broad selection of titles for adults & kids.

Bookseller chain stocking housebrand eReader, plus a broad selection of titles for adults & kids.

McNally Jackson Books Rockefeller Center (opens in a new tab)

1 Rockefeller Plaza · New York

Need a smart reset between emails, swing by McNally Jackson Books Rockefeller Center for staff picks that actually hit, new and noteworthy…

Need a smart reset between emails, swing by McNally Jackson Books Rockefeller Center for staff picks that actually hit, new and noteworthy shelves, signed copies if you’re quick, and a lively slate of events and book clubs that keep your TBR deliciously unruly.

From the The Bronx newsletter, November 5, 2026

The Book Cellar (opens in a new tab)

1465 York Ave · New York

The Book Cellar is a volunteer-run used bookstore where donated finds range from fantasy and romance to New York-themed titles, with plenty…

The Book Cellar is a volunteer-run used bookstore where donated finds range from fantasy and romance to New York-themed titles, with plenty of chances to stumble on a new favorite or an excellent gift. Its ever-changing shelves make browsing feel like a treasure hunt, minus the map and pirate hat.

From the Manhattan newsletter, November 18, 2026

Books of Wonder (opens in a new tab)

42 W 17th St · New York

Books of Wonder is the kind of children's bookstore that makes you accidentally leave with three extra picture books. Semiweekly storytime,…

Books of Wonder is the kind of children's bookstore that makes you accidentally leave with three extra picture books. Semiweekly storytime, signed editions, a stash of old and rare titles, and a whole Oz universe make it a dependable go-to for Staten Island parents hunting gifts and rainy-day inspiration.

From the Freeport newsletter, September 10, 2026

Book Culture (opens in a new tab)

2915 Broadway · New York

Book Culture mixes new and gently used gems with a deep bench of arts and humanities titles, plus in-store events and readings that…

Checked Sep 3

Book Culture mixes new and gently used gems with a deep bench of arts and humanities titles, plus in-store events and readings that actually feel like conversations, making it a smart nearby stop for Mount Vernon readers who pop in for one book and somehow leave with three.

From the Manhattan newsletter, October 28, 2026

Three Lives & Company (opens in a new tab)

154 W 10th St · New York

Three Lives & Company is that snug, meticulously curated bookshop you wish every corner had, quietly matching Manhattan moods since 1968.…

Three Lives & Company is that snug, meticulously curated bookshop you wish every corner had, quietly matching Manhattan moods since 1968. Preorder signed and inscribed copies of Hernan Diaz’s Ply and Susan Kaufman’s Walk With Me New York: Holiday, then linger for staff picks that actually surprise.

From the The Bronx newsletter, September 24, 2026

Àbákẹ́ Books & Cafe (opens in a new tab)

2 Webster Ave · Jersey City

Àbákẹ́ Books & Cafe brings together thoughtfully sourced coffee, books spotlighting authors across the diaspora, and a community-minded…

Àbákẹ́ Books & Cafe brings together thoughtfully sourced coffee, books spotlighting authors across the diaspora, and a community-minded approach to connection. It’s a lovely spot to browse a curated collection and find something more meaningful than another scroll through your phone.

From the North Jersey newsletter, November 4, 2026

Gittler Instruments, LLC (opens in a new tab)

150 Remington Blvd · Ronkonkoma

Gittler Instruments, LLC makes minimalist titanium guitars with six individual string pickups, LED fret markers and MIDI tracking that is…

Gittler Instruments, LLC makes minimalist titanium guitars with six individual string pickups, LED fret markers and MIDI tracking that is 100% Roland compatible. Worth a test drive this week if your setup needs a shake up because the Gittler T2 turns precision and sustain into an everyday habit.

From the Huntington newsletter, August 6, 2026

4th World Comics (opens in a new tab)

33 NY-111

For weekly readers and back-issue diggers, 4th World Comics has been the local go-to since 1982, stocking new issues, variants, manga, toys…

For weekly readers and back-issue diggers, 4th World Comics has been the local go-to since 1982, stocking new issues, variants, manga, toys and collectibles plus the largest selection of independent comics on Long Island. Family-run and staffed by fellow fans, they can set up a pull list so you never miss a favorite.

From the Smithtown newsletter, November 19, 2026

Music & Arts (opens in a new tab)

116 Jericho Tpke · Commack

Retail chain offering musical instruments, audio gear & accessories, plus rental & repair services.

Retail chain offering musical instruments, audio gear & accessories, plus rental & repair services.

The Compleat Sculptor (opens in a new tab)

110 W 19th St · New York

Whether you're carving stone, pouring molds, dabbling in special effects, or fixing a statue your cat decapitated, The Compleat Sculptor…

Whether you're carving stone, pouring molds, dabbling in special effects, or fixing a statue your cat decapitated, The Compleat Sculptor has materials from around the world, from Italian agate alabaster and Smooth-On silicones to patinas, tools, and body casting gear.

From the The Bronx newsletter, October 15, 2026

Guitar Center (opens in a new tab)

8 Garet Pl · Commack

Large guitar shop stocking acoustic and electric guitars, as well as amps, drums and keyboards.

Large guitar shop stocking acoustic and electric guitars, as well as amps, drums and keyboards.

B & B Rare Books, Ltd (opens in a new tab)

165 Madison Ave #500 · New York

B & B Rare Books, Ltd. specializes in modern first editions, signed and inscribed books, children’s literature, poetry, and other…

B & B Rare Books, Ltd. specializes in modern first editions, signed and inscribed books, children’s literature, poetry, and other collectible works. Browse for a literary gem, or ask about their book buying, appraisals, binding, and repair services.

From the Manhattan newsletter, November 14, 2026

Barnes & Noble (opens in a new tab)

33 E 17th St · New York

Bookseller chain stocking housebrand eReader, plus a broad selection of titles for adults & kids.

Bookseller chain stocking housebrand eReader, plus a broad selection of titles for adults & kids.

Brothers Guitar & Record Shop - Buy, Sell, Repair & Maintenance (opens in a new tab)

316 E 84th St · New York

Whether your Strat needs a proper setup or you just want to audition some tasty pedals, Brothers Guitar Shop brings a curated mix of new…

Whether your Strat needs a proper setup or you just want to audition some tasty pedals, Brothers Guitar Shop brings a curated mix of new and used gear plus pro repairs and lessons. From Fender and Martin to PRS, they’ll get your tone sorted this week, no drama.

From the Manhattan newsletter, October 29, 2026

Guitar Center (opens in a new tab)

25 W 14th St · New York

Retail outlet selling a huge array of electric, acoustic and bass guitars, keyboards and drums.

Retail outlet selling a huge array of electric, acoustic and bass guitars, keyboards and drums.

Michaels (opens in a new tab)

675 Avenue of the Americas NYC-Manhattan-Chelsea · New York

Chain retailer carrying art & hobby supplies plus home decor (most offer classes & custom framing).

Chain retailer carrying art & hobby supplies plus home decor (most offer classes & custom framing).

EconoCrafts (opens in a new tab)

29 Riverside Ave Bldg 2 suite 400 · Newark

EconoCrafts makes it easy to find supplies for all kinds of creative plans, from beading and painting to sewing, seasonal projects, and…

EconoCrafts makes it easy to find supplies for all kinds of creative plans, from beading and painting to sewing, seasonal projects, and STEAM activities.

From the Newark newsletter, November 19, 2026

Calico Guitarworks (opens in a new tab)

201 Smithtown Blvd · Nesconset

Guitar and bass care shop offering repairs, maintenance and pickups and tuners upgraded by appointment.

Guitar and bass care shop offering repairs, maintenance and pickups and tuners upgraded by appointment.

Sew What's New and Yarn Too! (opens in a new tab)

400 E Main St · Islip

Sew What's New and Yarn Too! is a friendly Islip shop for quilting and sewing enthusiasts, with rows of fabric, notions, and thread, plus…

Sew What's New and Yarn Too! is a friendly Islip shop for quilting and sewing enthusiasts, with rows of fabric, notions, and thread, plus helpful staff and project classes. Whether you have a project in mind or just want to browse and talk shop, it’s an easy place to feel at home.

From the Islip newsletter, November 9, 2026

Barnes & Noble (opens in a new tab)

2289 Broadway · New York

Bookseller chain stocking housebrand eReader, plus a broad selection of titles for adults & kids.

Bookseller chain stocking housebrand eReader, plus a broad selection of titles for adults & kids.

ReWax and UnWine Candle Making Bar (opens in a new tab)

2 Division St · Jersey City

ReWax and UnWine Candle Making Bar mixes candle crafting with karaoke and BYOB, so you can pour a signature scent, then grab the mic. Their…

ReWax and UnWine Candle Making Bar mixes candle crafting with karaoke and BYOB, so you can pour a signature scent, then grab the mic.

From the Hudson County newsletter, October 29, 2026

Best Buy (opens in a new tab)

531 5th Ave · New York

Chain retailer with a large array of brand-name electronics, computers, appliances & more.

Chain retailer with a large array of brand-name electronics, computers, appliances & more.

Advantage Music (opens in a new tab)

435 Hawkins Ave · Lake Ronkonkoma

Whether your kid’s starting school band or you’re gearing up for a gig, Advantage Music has you covered with rentals coordinated with local…

Whether your kid’s starting school band or you’re gearing up for a gig, Advantage Music has you covered with rentals coordinated with local schools, expert repairs, and legit one-on-one lessons. Stocked with trusted brands like Fender, Yamaha, and D’Addario, it’s a solid local go-to.

From the Brookhaven newsletter, November 6, 2026

Best Buy (opens in a new tab)

60 W 23rd St · New York

Chain retailer with a large array of brand-name electronics, computers, appliances & more.

Chain retailer with a large array of brand-name electronics, computers, appliances & more.

Best Buy (opens in a new tab)

1280 Lexington Ave · New York

Chain retailer with a large array of brand-name electronics, computers, appliances & more.

Chain retailer with a large array of brand-name electronics, computers, appliances & more.