The best antique, thrift & vintage shops in Suffolk County

“St. Mary’s Thrift Shop is the parish-run spot where Babylon neighbors do the good kind of rummaging, with ever-changing secondhand finds and no-nonsense prices. It’s low-key, friendly, and close by, perfect for a quick weekend pop-in when you’re chasing that just-right something you didn’t know you needed.”

From the Babylon newsletter, September 25, 2026

“Chapterhouse Boutique mixes well‑chosen vintage, handmade pieces, and a bit of witchy stuff with legit tailoring and alterations, so your thrifted treasure actually fits. If you’re in Babylon, it’s a quick hop to Lindenhurst for unique finds you won’t see duplicated at the next backyard hang.”

From the Babylon newsletter, October 1, 2026

“St Peter's By the Sea Thrift Shop delivers the good stuff... vintage clothes and shoes, fine china, and gently used toys that make secondhand feel first-rate. It’s part of St.”

From the Babylon newsletter, October 9, 2026

“FourLeaf Thrift Store - Lindenhurst is a registered NY Benefit Corporation with a clear mission to create positive environmental impact through reuse. Donate your pre-loved items to keep good stuff in circulation, then hunt for wallet-friendly finds that cut waste...”

From the Lindenhurst newsletter, September 7, 2026

“FourLeaf Thrift Store is a NY Benefit Corporation that turns reuse into a mission, with racks of secondhand gems and a simple way to keep stuff out of the landfill. Babylon folks can drop donations, browse for surprises in Copiague or Lindenhurst, and you might even spot a few friendly in-store characters.”

From the Babylon newsletter, September 12, 2026

“Whether you need a quirky mug, a cozy sweater, or a stack of old-school DVDs, Mary Immaculate Thrift Shop is the church-run treasure hunt hiding in plain sight. Donate your usable goods, then swing back to discover something you didn’t know your home was missing.”

From the Brookhaven newsletter, September 29, 2026

“St. Paul’s Thrift Shop is a volunteer-run community hangout with a rotating “special table” of curiosities, from wedding gowns and fine china to granny’s attic finds and seasonal crafts. Pop in, flip through books and toys, refresh your home stash, then leave feeling smug about the perfect unexpected find.”

From the Brookhaven newsletter, September 26, 2026

“Angels of Long Island is a nonprofit resale spot for low-price clothing, housewares, and vintage finds, plus a food pantry that keeps neighbors fed. They team with 1-800-GOT-JUNK and Evtek Recycling to reroute usable goods and recycle cans, so your closet clean-out actually helps people.”

From the Brookhaven newsletter, August 31, 2026

“Set in Downtown Patchogue, Village Vintage Thrift & Curated Goods turns the usual thrift sift into a walk-through set, with tightly pulled vintage apparel, estate jewelry, designer denim, sequined showstoppers, and the kind of oddball jacket you didn't know you needed.”

From the Brookhaven newsletter, September 12, 2026

“Ketcham Inn Book Barn is a treasure trove with one of the South Shore’s largest used-book inventories, spanning Long Island history, fiction, YA, kids, art, nature, cooking and more, plus vintage records for good measure.”

From the Brookhaven newsletter, August 20, 2026

“This week, Remember Yesteryears Vintage Center is your wander-and-discover zone for antiques and real-deal vintage, the kind of place you pop in for a lamp and leave with a story. Refresh a room, gift with personality, or indulge your inner magpie for an hour.”

From the Brookhaven newsletter, August 6, 2026

“Housed in a historic greenhouse in Saint James, The Greenhouse Antiques And Collectibles brings together 50 North Shore dealers for a constantly shifting trove of mid-century pieces, quirky decor and true oddities. Perfect for a Babylon weekend browse when your place needs a little character upgrade.”

From the Smithtown newsletter, September 30, 2026

“Craving a treasure hunt that actually pays off? The Times Vintage is a Greenport go-to packed with one-of-a-kind, handpicked fashion, mid-century decor and hard-to-find vinyl, plus ever-changing displays by Ricky. They even offer prop and wardrobe rentals, clutch for shoots, parties or a last-minute vibe switch.”

From the North Fork newsletter, September 27, 2026

“From clean, well-organized racks of designer clothing and jewelry to housewares, vintage scores and furniture, East End Hospice Thrift Shop makes browsing dangerously fun. 100% of proceeds benefit local children's bereavement services, so your weekend haul quietly does something beautiful for our community.”

From the The Hamptons newsletter, September 30, 2026

“Southampton’s Grandma Did It Better curates fully restored vintage by era, from Mod and Boho to Grunge and Supermodel, so you can snag a power suit or that perfect 90s tee this week. Think YSL blouses, Givenchy jackets, and Chanel or Gucci bags that feel fresh, not costume.”

From the The Hamptons newsletter, September 19, 2026

“Thrift store chain offering secondhand clothing, footwear, furniture, books & household items.”

“If your closet could use a little history, PJ Vintage is stacked with curated vintage clothing, jewelry and quirky collectibles that make outfits feel personal. Pop in this week, dig around, and walk out with a one-of-a-kind piece your friends will swear you thrifted ages ago.”

From the Brookhaven newsletter, August 14, 2026

“Collette is the rare consignment find where Mies van der Rohe BRNO chairs, Milo Baughman chairs, chic lighting, rugs, and witty art share the floor with new arrivals to browse, plus interior design and estate sales.”

From the The Hamptons newsletter, September 22, 2026

“Chain retailer buying & selling trendy secondhand clothing for teens & young adults.”

“Thrift store chain offering secondhand clothing, footwear, furniture, books & household items.”

“Hidden Treasures Thrift Shop keeps the racks fresh with curated pre-loved clothing, accessories, and home goods, from everyday basics to surprise luxe finds. Pop in this week, we spotted a Tory Burch saddle bag, a Jacques Lemans watch, and a nostalgic 90s teapot... proof that sustainability can look seriously good.”

From the Babylon newsletter, August 25, 2026

“Starke Naked Vintage is a smart local go-to when your closet needs character, with Lydia Starke’s picks spanning Alaïa, Issey Miyake, Chanel, Dior and Versace, plus wearable staples for women and men, bags and jewels. There are even under-$50 and under-$100 sections for guilt-free treasure hunting.”

From the Brookhaven newsletter, October 7, 2026

“Boutique selling unique, vintage clothing and accessories for women, plus gifts.”

“Twin Hearts Vintage has a new Southampton location open, serving up 40s to 70s jewelry, chic handbags, MCM glass, and the occasional designer gem that makes you say I’ll plan an outfit around this. Your weekly reminder to choose character over cookie cutter.”

From the The Hamptons newsletter, September 26, 2026

“Islip UMC Thrift Shoppe is where locals score real finds without the rummage fatigue.”

From the Islip newsletter, September 23, 2026

“Huntington Thrift keeps good stuff in circulation with a mix of previously loved finds that feels more treasure hunt than chore. Sustainable shopping with local flavor, perfect when you want pieces with history and personality that make your place or closet a little more you.”

From the Huntington newsletter, August 28, 2026

“Part vintage treasure hunt, part curated design fix, The House of Timeless Treasures packs two floors with antiques, mid-mod glass, eclectic decor, and contemporary handcrafted pieces from 10 independent vendors, so you can actually score that conversation-starter you’ve been picturing for the living room.”

From the Huntington newsletter, October 7, 2026

“If your shelves crave character, swing by The Carriage House Shop this week for locally loved vintage in the restored Nugent Carriage House, from paintings and prints to jewelry, LPs, dishes, and postcards.”

From the The Hamptons newsletter, October 7, 2026

“Need a midweek serotonin boost, and a chair that isn’t from your cousin? ARF Thrift & Treasure Shop is packed with donated furniture, home decor, and clothing with real personality, and every purchase supports the cats and dogs at the Animal Rescue Fund of the Hamptons, so give it a look this week.”

From the The Hamptons newsletter, September 24, 2026

“Thrift store chain offering secondhand clothing, footwear, furniture, books & household items.”

“Stair's Incurable Collector curates English, American, Continental and Asian antiques, from mirrors and desks to clocks, scientific instruments and statement lighting. Over 100 years of know-how means real provenance, real patina. Browse for that one piece that makes the room...”

From the Huntington newsletter, September 23, 2026

“Thrift store selling clothing and other donated goods to benefit an adult drug and alcohol rehabilitation center.”

“Thic Chic Plus Size Boutique is the rare spot where every rack is actually for you, with current and vintage styles in sizes 0x-5x, extended-size shoes, accessories, and menswear too. If you love thrifting without the digging, their inclusive, body-positive curation makes shopping fun again.”

From the Smithtown newsletter, October 7, 2026

“Echoes Antiques & Auction Gallery, Inc. turns weeknight scrolling into treasure hunting, with estate-sale gems, fine art, vintage steins, and quirky collectibles in an easy online catalog. If you’ve been meaning to refresh a wall or flex your picker instincts, their auctions make it fun to bid and win.”

From the Islip newsletter, October 1, 2026

“Privet Estate Sales turns Hamptons move-outs and renos into a rotating online trove of modern and mid-century furniture, lighting, outdoor sets, and art pulled from real local homes. Sprucing the place up this week? Keep an eye on their latest auctions and pounce when that perfect piece pops up.”

From the The Hamptons newsletter, October 3, 2026

“St. Mark's Thrift Shop keeps closets fresh and budgets happier, with volunteer-run racks and a mission that gives away more than it sells. Score quality finds, and know your purchase helps neighbors through their voucher program...”

From the Islip newsletter, October 7, 2026

“Antique Attics is a multi-dealer trove where the mix changes weekly, so you can actually find the Pyrex, vintage decor, military memorabilia, jewelry and oddball collectibles you’ve been hunting for. They run live and online auctions and offer consignment, so the treasure keeps circulating locally.”

From the Islip newsletter, August 11, 2026

“Collette Home is where Hamptons locals score one-of-a-kind furniture, art, lighting, rugs, and all the little finishing touches, with fresh arrivals in Bridgehampton, Southampton Village, and Tanger Outlet. Want to lighten the load at home too? They make consignment easy so great pieces keep circulating locally.”

From the The Hamptons newsletter, September 14, 2026

“The Retreat Boutique serves up designer gems, everyday staples, and a legit Shoe Parlor worth a lap. You get great finds, and 100% of proceeds power The Retreat’s free services for survivors. Cleaning out your closet this week?”

From the The Hamptons newsletter, September 17, 2026

“Thrift store chain offering secondhand clothing, footwear, furniture, books & household items.”

“Small Holdings Farm is a country antique store where farmhouse, cottage, coastal, and elegant industrial all play nice, which means chic decor without the fuss. When your living room needs a little "I actually tried" energy, this modern country trove delivers character pieces you’ll keep bragging about.”

From the Riverhead newsletter, October 4, 2026

“Rosie's Vintage is a multi-dealer playground in a 300-year-old house, packed with rotating finds from 40+ vendors, from mid-century furniture and retro clothing to quirky collectibles.”

From the Huntington newsletter, September 30, 2026