The best bakeries & sweet shops in Erie

“Stefanelli's Candies has been handcrafting Erie’s famous sponge candy since 1929, small-batch over copper kettles with that melt-away crunch locals swear by. When the sweet tooth hits this week, their boxed chocolates, bars, and chocolate-covered treats deliver Old World flavor that somehow tastes like hometown pride.”

From the Erie newsletter, August 4, 2026

“Majestic Baking Company keeps Erie in great bread with sourdough and artisan loaves baked in a timeworn brick oven that’s been warm for generations. Dating back to 1887, baking since 1915, and under new owners since 2019, it’s the place for a crust that snaps and a crumb that makes soup feel fancy.”

“Bustling French and Turkish bakery for pastries and coffee plus a cafe-style menu.”

“Long-standing family-owned bakery specializing in homemade pies, cookies and other sweet goods.”

“Bakery offering a selection of cookies, brownies and cupcakes, plus wedding cakes.”

“Teen-oriented retail chain for a large assortment of games, snacks, jewelry, room decor & more.”

“Local bakery and deli featuring fresh breads, pies, cookies and baklava, plus cannoli.”

“Long-running confectionery shop hand-crafting chocolates in small batches.”

“Retailer offering premium chocolate & other confections, plus cocoa & gift baskets.”

“Bakery specializing in pretzels and other baked goods made from local ingredients.”

“Down-to-earth establishment offering sweet & savory crepes made from locally sourced ingredients.”