The best restaurants in Erie

44 restaurants we’ve checked and stand behind — with the story on each one. Not a ranking; a record.

Browse another shelf: all of Erie’s best · Entertainment · Bakeries & Sweets · Nightlife · Arts & Culture · Beauty · Home & Garden · Hobbies, Books, & Crafts · Antiques, Thrift, & Vintage · Shopping

Pinned in Erie today

This spot is open today.

Two pinned places a day in Erie — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. List your business →

Paid placements are always marked.

Restaurants · 44 places · showing the latest additions first

Falcone’s Kitchen leans into history and tradition with a menu that puts quality and flavor first, served in a welcoming space built for…

2901 Copperleaf Dr · ✓ checked Jul 30

Falcone’s Kitchen leans into history and tradition with a menu that puts quality and flavor first, served in a welcoming space built for gathering. When you want an easy win this week, grab your crew for Italian comfort and keep an eye on their events.

From the Erie newsletter, August 7, 2026

Website ↗

When you need a legit quick bite that tastes like Chef Lisa actually cooked for you, Dinner is Served Cafe turns out Belgian waffles,…

334 W 8th St · ✓ checked Jul 30

When you need a legit quick bite that tastes like Chef Lisa actually cooked for you, Dinner is Served Cafe turns out Belgian waffles, breakfast bowls, scratch-made soups, and signature wraps, plus Big Bad Meals you can pre-order for the week... perfect for stocking the fridge this week.

From the Erie newsletter, August 4, 2026

Website ↗

Casual spot turning out Neapolitan pies with hand-stretched cheese, plus small plates and a bar.

Located inside the Flagship City Food Hall, 508 State St

Casual spot turning out Neapolitan pies with hand-stretched cheese, plus small plates and a bar.

Website ↗

Creative takes on Asian fare, Japanese classics & sushi in sleek digs with beer, sake & wine.

2767 W 12th St

Creative takes on Asian fare, Japanese classics & sushi in sleek digs with beer, sake & wine.

Website ↗
Run a Erie business? Two pinned spots a day — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. Advertise →

Casual yet sophisticated gathering place for globally inspired eats, wine, craft beer & cocktails.

25 E 10th St

Casual yet sophisticated gathering place for globally inspired eats, wine, craft beer & cocktails.

Website ↗

Underdog BBQ

Restaurants

Casual place offering BBQ classics, such as brisket, ribs, and baked beans, plus beer.

2714 W 8th St

Casual place offering BBQ classics, such as brisket, ribs, and baked beans, plus beer.

Website ↗

Alfee’s Pizza

Restaurants

A variety of chow including pizza & chicken wings rounds out the menu at this casual destination.

3001 Glenwood Park Ave #2711

A variety of chow including pizza & chicken wings rounds out the menu at this casual destination.

Website ↗

Laid-back alehouse hosts live bands & serves American fare such as jumbo sandwiches & steaks.

726 W Bayfront Pkwy

Laid-back alehouse hosts live bands & serves American fare such as jumbo sandwiches & steaks.

Website ↗

Colony Pizza

Restaurants

Casual pizzeria offering comfort food in a cozy atmosphere, plus hoagies and wings.

2666 W 8th St

Casual pizzeria offering comfort food in a cozy atmosphere, plus hoagies and wings.

Website ↗

Relaxed, counter-service pizzeria dishing up thin-crust pies, wings, and other comfort eats.

3651 W 12th St

Relaxed, counter-service pizzeria dishing up thin-crust pies, wings, and other comfort eats.

Website ↗

Japanese eatery that cooks hibachi steaks on grills at tables and serves a variety of sushi rolls and sake.

279 E Fairmount Ave (Lakewood)

Japanese eatery that cooks hibachi steaks on grills at tables and serves a variety of sushi rolls and sake.

Website ↗

Laid-back eatery serving burgers, pizzas and sandwiches, plus craft beer and cocktails in a casual setup with outdoor seating.

4575 W Ridge Rd

Laid-back eatery serving burgers, pizzas and sandwiches, plus craft beer and cocktails in a casual setup with outdoor seating.

Website ↗

Casual joint offering creative hot dogs & a vast selection of beers, including six-packs to go.

8238 Perry Hwy

Casual joint offering creative hot dogs & a vast selection of beers, including six-packs to go.

Website ↗

Family-friendly buffet chain featuring all-you-can-eat American fare, plus salad & dessert bars.

7500 Peach St

Family-friendly buffet chain featuring all-you-can-eat American fare, plus salad & dessert bars.

Website ↗

Restaurant offering lake views and live music with small plates, cocktails, and rooftop seating.

6 Sassafras Pier Third Floor

Restaurant offering lake views and live music with small plates, cocktails, and rooftop seating.

Website ↗

Food and drink court featuring a variety of casual eateries and local vendors as well as a bar.

22 N Park Row

Food and drink court featuring a variety of casual eateries and local vendors as well as a bar.

Website ↗

Lucero

Restaurants

Cozy spot serving tapas, pinxtos, and Spanish wines plus cocktails.

940 W Erie Plaza Dr

Cozy spot serving tapas, pinxtos, and Spanish wines plus cocktails.

Website ↗

Casual, locally-owned food truck specializing in wood-smoked meats for sandwiches and mac ‘n’ cheese.

274 E Fairmount Ave (Lakewood)

Casual, locally-owned food truck specializing in wood-smoked meats for sandwiches and mac ‘n’ cheese.

Website ↗

Pizza, calzones & other basic Italian fare served in a long-running joint with an old-school vibe.

1529 W 38th St

Pizza, calzones & other basic Italian fare served in a long-running joint with an old-school vibe.

Website ↗

Upscale restaurant with a black-and-white motif featuring a menu of steaks, scallops, and crab cakes, plus live music.

4353 W Ridge Rd

Upscale restaurant with a black-and-white motif featuring a menu of steaks, scallops, and crab cakes, plus live music.

Website ↗

Casual, family-friendly bar & grill serving American menu with on-site catering & takeout available.

1624 W 38th St

Casual, family-friendly bar & grill serving American menu with on-site catering & takeout available.

Website ↗

Family-owned fixture slinging pizza and other Italian eats such as stuffed rigatoni, meatballs and lasagna.

1604 W Grandview Blvd

Family-owned fixture slinging pizza and other Italian eats such as stuffed rigatoni, meatballs and lasagna.

Website ↗

Rum Runners

Restaurants

Relaxed spot dishing up burgers and seafood classics on an outdoor deck or inside, plus a waterfront bar.

133 E Dobbins Landing

Relaxed spot dishing up burgers and seafood classics on an outdoor deck or inside, plus a waterfront bar.

Website ↗

Casual restaurant serving made-to-order smash burgers, birria tacos, and cheesesteaks, plus breakfast.

2614 Glenwood Park Ave

Casual restaurant serving made-to-order smash burgers, birria tacos, and cheesesteaks, plus breakfast.

Website ↗

Open kitchen serving Neapolitan pizzas, burgers, and daily entrees in a relaxed atmosphere.

4823 Peach St

Open kitchen serving Neapolitan pizzas, burgers, and daily entrees in a relaxed atmosphere.

Website ↗

Long-running Pittsburgh-born chain known for its sandwiches piled high with coleslaw & french fries.

5800 Peach St

Long-running Pittsburgh-born chain known for its sandwiches piled high with coleslaw & french fries.

Website ↗

Italian eatery featuring steaks and pasta dishes, plus ample wine, beer and cocktails.

6590 W Lake Rd (Fairview)

Italian eatery featuring steaks and pasta dishes, plus ample wine, beer and cocktails.

Website ↗

Oliver's Rooftop

Restaurants

Relaxed venue for seafood, steaks and more, plus cocktails, beer and wine.

130 E Front St

Relaxed venue for seafood, steaks and more, plus cocktails, beer and wine.

Website ↗

Wingstop

Restaurants

Casual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.

5043 Peach St Unit A-12

Casual counter-serve chain serving a variety of chicken wings & sides.

Website ↗

Southern & Caribbean cuisine, plus wine & cocktails, served a relaxed, warm setting with a cozy bar.

1402 W 10th St

Southern & Caribbean cuisine, plus wine & cocktails, served a relaxed, warm setting with a cozy bar.

Website ↗

Pint-sized '50s-style diner with basic American fare & desserts plus a build-your-own sundae bar.

25 Peninsula Dr

Pint-sized '50s-style diner with basic American fare & desserts plus a build-your-own sundae bar.

Website ↗

Market showcasing local produce, baked goods, and handmade crafts, plus a restaurant.

910 Market St #3319 (Meadville)

Market showcasing local produce, baked goods, and handmade crafts, plus a restaurant.

Website ↗

Easygoing trattoria offering Italian favorites like pastas, sandwiches & classic entrees.

2112 E Lake Rd

Easygoing trattoria offering Italian favorites like pastas, sandwiches & classic entrees.

Website ↗

Snug, narrow outlet offering a compact menu of smoked BBQ plus sandwiches, sides & veggie wings.

2609 US-19

Snug, narrow outlet offering a compact menu of smoked BBQ plus sandwiches, sides & veggie wings.

Website ↗

Pint-sized pizza joint whipping up simple pies, subs & wings for late-night takeout or delivery.

302 W 8th St

Pint-sized pizza joint whipping up simple pies, subs & wings for late-night takeout or delivery.

Website ↗

Casual eatery featuring smoked brisket, ribs, chicken and turkey sandwiches and plates.

3431 Poplar St

Casual eatery featuring smoked brisket, ribs, chicken and turkey sandwiches and plates.

Website ↗

Simple spot for American home cooking, serving weekday mornings, plus Fridays & Saturdays overnight.

4108 Peach St

Simple spot for American home cooking, serving weekday mornings, plus Fridays & Saturdays overnight.

Website ↗

Eclectic eatery offering comfort food with vegetarian options, plus wine, cocktails, and beer.

60 Chautauqua Ave (Lakewood)

Eclectic eatery offering comfort food with vegetarian options, plus wine, cocktails, and beer.

Website ↗

Pine Junction

Restaurants

Homey, lodgelike bar with a seasonal patio, offering hearty American meals, draft brews & cocktails.

9757 Bailey Hill Rd (Sherman)

Homey, lodgelike bar with a seasonal patio, offering hearty American meals, draft brews & cocktails.

Website ↗

Cozy eatery for American dishes like pancakes, burgers and fries, plus desserts.

5455 W Ridge Rd

Cozy eatery for American dishes like pancakes, burgers and fries, plus desserts.

Website ↗

Set in a historic train car, this celebrated, daytime diner serves up traditional American plates.

4019 Main St

Set in a historic train car, this celebrated, daytime diner serves up traditional American plates.

Website ↗

Casual hotel eatery offering American eats in a light-filled room with bay views & patio seating.

2 Sassafras Pier

Casual hotel eatery offering American eats in a light-filled room with bay views & patio seating.

Website ↗

Homey, family-owned spot for traditional Italian cuisine, including pastas, seafood & steaks.

2826 Plum St

Homey, family-owned spot for traditional Italian cuisine, including pastas, seafood & steaks.

Website ↗

Stevo's Pizza

Restaurants

Casual pizzeria serving NYC-style & deep-dish pies plus other comfort food such as burgers & wings.

1019 State St

Casual pizzeria serving NYC-style & deep-dish pies plus other comfort food such as burgers & wings.

Website ↗

Listed here?

You’ve earned the mark — get the BaseLocal’s Best badge for your site →. Want in? List your business →