The best restaurants in Sheboygan
109 restaurants we’ve checked and stand behind — with the story on each one. Not a ranking; a record.
Browse another shelf: all of Sheboygan’s best · Entertainment · Nightlife · Beauty · Arts & Culture · Antiques, Thrift, & Vintage · Bakeries & Sweets · Home & Garden · Hobbies, Books, & Crafts · Shopping · Sporting Goods · Pets · Cafes · Health & Wellness · Parks & Outdoors · Services
Pinned in Sheboygan today
This spot is open today.
Two pinned places a day in Sheboygan — $10 here, $25 adds the newsletter. List your business →Paid placements are always marked.
Filippo's Italian Restaurant
RestaurantsSizable, homestyle Italian plates & pizza are offered in a homey mainstay with quaint decor & a bar.
Filippo's Italian Restaurant
RestaurantsDaddy's Soul Food & Grille
RestaurantsMom-&-pop operation dishing up daily specials such as meatloaf & catfish in relaxed surrounds.
Daddy's Soul Food & Grille
RestaurantsSaz's State House
RestaurantsLaid-back BBQ restaurant & sports bar offering signature ribs & a shuttle to area sports games.
Saz's State House
Restaurantsdoh'p Wood-Fired Fare
RestaurantsBay View’s Doh'p Wood-Fired Fare turns out wood-fired pies from the crew behind the Doh'p Wood-Fired Food Truck, formerly Hot Box Pizza…
doh'p Wood-Fired Fare
RestaurantsSheboygan's Family Restaurant
RestaurantsSheboygan's Family Restaurant has been feeding Sheboyganites for over 20 years with an affordable, big-tent menu that nails the basics,…
Sheboygan's Family Restaurant
RestaurantsAwi Sushi
RestaurantsCraving a midweek upgrade? Awi Sushi is all about fresh, made-to-order bites from an owner who’s spent 15+ years perfecting the craft, with…
Awi Sushi
RestaurantsNadi Plates
RestaurantsNadi Plates is Milwaukee’s woman-owned Italian food truck and caterer serving scratch-made, original recipes from Owner and Executive Chef…
Nadi Plates
RestaurantsWings Over Milwaukee
RestaurantsPopular restaurant chain with a variety of chicken wings, chicken tenders, boneless wings & sides for dine-in, takeout & delivery.
Wings Over Milwaukee
RestaurantsGolden Corral Buffet & Grill
RestaurantsFamily-friendly buffet chain featuring all-you-can-eat American fare, plus salad & dessert bars.
Golden Corral Buffet & Grill
RestaurantsBacchus - A Bartolotta Restaurant
RestaurantsSleek, upscale New American spot with a huge wine list & a conservatory with Lake Michigan views.
Bacchus - A Bartolotta Restaurant
RestaurantsZarletti
RestaurantsSmall, minimalist restaurant serving up creative Italian fare & wine by the glass or bottle.
Zarletti
RestaurantsScreaming Tuna
RestaurantsCasual Asian-fusion bistro offering sushi, seafood & steak plus skyline views, wine & cocktails.
Screaming Tuna
RestaurantsQDOBA Mexican Eats
RestaurantsA menu of customizable Mexican food served in a modern restaurant, plus takeout & catering.
QDOBA Mexican Eats
RestaurantsLuigi's Italian Restaurant
RestaurantsCasual trattoria, part of a local chain, for familiar Italian classic dishes & Chicago-style pies.
Luigi's Italian Restaurant
RestaurantsSweet Diner
RestaurantsHip spot for breakfast & lunch classics plus coffee & cocktails in understated modern environs.
Sweet Diner
RestaurantsJJ fish & Chicken
RestaurantsLocal fast-food chain featuring fried chicken, fish & shrimp, plus wings, in a low-key setting.
JJ fish & Chicken
RestaurantsHeirloom MKE
RestaurantsCasual, modern restaurant and bar specializing in creative New American dishes, plus gluten-free options.
Heirloom MKE
RestaurantsSmokin’ Jack's BBQ (3rd St. Market Hall)
RestaurantsBarbecue restaurant and takeaway spot where platters, sandwiches and bowls are the norm.
Smokin’ Jack's BBQ (3rd St. Market Hall)
RestaurantsSanford
RestaurantsChef’s tasting menu of creative, upscale New American fare & wine served in an elegant venue.
Sanford
RestaurantsKame Ramen & Sushi Poke
RestaurantsRelaxed eatery featuring ramen and poke bowls, plus burgers, steaks and hibachi.
Kame Ramen & Sushi Poke
RestaurantsWard's House of Prime
RestaurantsUpscale chophouse serving steaks & seafood, plus a classic bar menu in dark-wood environs.
Ward's House of Prime
RestaurantsGreen Street Food & Spirits
RestaurantsWelcoming eatery serving broasted chicken and pork, prime rib and fish dishes in a cozy, family-operated setting.
Green Street Food & Spirits
RestaurantsCasual restaurant offering Laotian fare such as pho and sticky rice, plus vegetarian options.
Taco Bell
RestaurantsFast-food chain serving Mexican-inspired fare such as tacos, quesadillas & nachos.
Taco Bell
RestaurantsBUMP'S GRILL TAVERN, HOME OF THE LIARS CLUB
RestaurantsCorner pub serving up fish fries, old fashioneds, and other comfort food with happy hour specials.
BUMP'S GRILL TAVERN, HOME OF THE LIARS CLUB
RestaurantsTrattoria Stefano
RestaurantsUpscale Italian fare created from local ingredients & served in a casual, rustic space.
Trattoria Stefano
RestaurantsTexas Roadhouse
RestaurantsLively chain steakhouse serving American fare with a Southwestern spin amid Texas-themed decor.
Texas Roadhouse
RestaurantsPho Viet
RestaurantsStraightforward strip-mall restaurant serving noodle soups & other classic Vietnamese cooking.
Pho Viet
RestaurantsNoodles and Company
RestaurantsCounter-serve chain offering international noodle & pasta dishes from mac 'n' cheese to Pad Thai.
Noodles and Company
RestaurantsSushi&Grill
RestaurantsSushi, hibachi, teriyaki and tempura platters served in casual, takeout-friendly quarters.
Sushi&Grill
RestaurantsChiang Mai Garden
RestaurantsCozy restaurant offering a selection of Thai dishes such as pho and volcano chicken.
Chiang Mai Garden
RestaurantsUmi Sushi And Steak House
RestaurantsHibachi & kitchen fare along with sushi, rolls & bento boxes in a sleek, contemporary setting.
Umi Sushi And Steak House
RestaurantsCamino
RestaurantsUnfussy neighborhood eatery & bar serving American pub grub, burgers & craft beers.
Camino
RestaurantsBirch
RestaurantsContemporary bistro serving Midwestern cuisine prepared on an open-fire hearth.
Birch
RestaurantsFive O'Clock Steakhouse
RestaurantsOld-school supper club serving upscale steakhouse fare in a wood-accented venue since 1946.
Five O'Clock Steakhouse
RestaurantsKimpton Journeyman Hotel
RestaurantsHigh-end property with sophisticated quarters, a rooftop bar & Mediterranean dining, plus a gym.
Kimpton Journeyman Hotel
RestaurantsLegend Larry's
RestaurantsLocal chain of sports bars serving up chicken wings with a variety of housemade sauces & sides.
Legend Larry's
RestaurantsCafé At The Plaza
RestaurantsStylish 1920s-inspired cafe with a lush garden patio serving organic, locally sourced fare & brews.
Café At The Plaza
RestaurantsCalderone Club - Downtown Milwaukee
RestaurantsOld-world setting for thin-crust pies, made-from-scratch pasta, panini & an extensive wine list.
Calderone Club - Downtown Milwaukee
RestaurantsRodizio Grill Brazilian Steakhouse Milwaukee
RestaurantsOutpost of a Brazilian steakhouse chain offering skewered meats carved tableside, plus a salad bar.
Rodizio Grill Brazilian Steakhouse Milwaukee
RestaurantsUptown Slice
RestaurantsNew York-style pizzas are available by the pie or by the slice at this cozy joint with a bar.
Uptown Slice
RestaurantsDorsia
RestaurantsReimagined Italian pasta & pizza, plus wine & cocktails, in a contemporary, relaxed bistro setting.
Dorsia
RestaurantsFat Cow
RestaurantsLively eatery for comfort foods (including burgers and wings), cocktails and craft beer.
Fat Cow
RestaurantsLupi & Iris
RestaurantsWood-fired place offering pastas salads, steaks, swordfish and other meats.
Lupi & Iris
RestaurantsToppers Pizza
RestaurantsPizzeria chain making pies with unusual toppings (wings too), offered at counter or via delivery.
Toppers Pizza
RestaurantsField to Fork
RestaurantsCasual market for locally sourced products & a daytime cafe serving informal farm-to-table dishes.
Field to Fork
RestaurantsPizza Shuttle
RestaurantsBeer, pizza & other Italian eats in a casual eatery with late-night hours, a jukebox & photo booth.
Pizza Shuttle
RestaurantsMorel
RestaurantsRustic-chic spot offering a daily changing menu of New American plates plus cocktails & beer.
Morel
RestaurantsThe Milwaukee Steakhouse
RestaurantsAngus steaks, seafood & classic American fare are served in a traditional dining room with a bar.
The Milwaukee Steakhouse
RestaurantsLuigi's Italian Restaurant
RestaurantsUnpretentious Italian joint specializing in pasta meals, pizzas, sandwiches & party trays.
Luigi's Italian Restaurant
RestaurantsSobelmans on St. Paul
RestaurantsBar & grill, housed in an original Schlitz tavern, known for Bloody Marys, burgers & sandwiches.
Sobelmans on St. Paul
RestaurantsMad Chicken
RestaurantsFast-food joint dishing up hormone- and antibiotic-free chicken, wings, and other comfort bites.
Mad Chicken
RestaurantsA contemporary spot for creative sushi rolls & traditional Thai dishes served in a stylish space.
MKE Classic Pizza
RestaurantsHip counter-serve spot for creative pizzas, calzones & sandwiches plus gluten-free & vegan options.
MKE Classic Pizza
RestaurantsFixture Pizza Pub
RestaurantsCharming bistro with exposed brick & a bar area, featuring signature pizzas, Italian subs & pastas.
Fixture Pizza Pub
RestaurantsBourbon Street Pub and Grill
RestaurantsLaid-back joint for New Orleans-inspired fare, plus cocktails, beer, wine and live music.
Bourbon Street Pub and Grill
RestaurantsAmilinda
RestaurantsSpanish & Portuguese plates are paired with cocktails & wine in a cozy-chic setting.
Amilinda
RestaurantsBaoBao Cuisine
RestaurantsVibrant eatery featuring pho (including seafood varieties) and fried seafood rice, along with bubble teas.
BaoBao Cuisine
RestaurantsMason Street Grill
RestaurantsClassic restaurant/lounge in the historic Pfister Hotel offering steakhouse fare & live jazz.
Mason Street Grill
RestaurantsThe Immigrant Restaurant
RestaurantsElegant eatery at the American Club Resort Hotel serving New American fare in multiroom surrounds.
The Immigrant Restaurant
RestaurantsMovida at Hotel Madrid
RestaurantsA modern, rustic dining room in the Hotel Madrid serving upscale Spanish cuisine.
Movida at Hotel Madrid
RestaurantsSushi Yuki
RestaurantsTrendy spot for sushi and other Japanese dishes prepared with high-quality ingredients.
Sushi Yuki
RestaurantsLegend Larry's
RestaurantsLocal chain of sports bars serving up chicken wings with a variety of housemade sauces & sides.
Legend Larry's
RestaurantsSafina
RestaurantsItalian eatery for familiar classics like pasta and eggplant parm, plus cocktails and wine.
Safina
RestaurantsSafeHouse
RestaurantsBuzzy spy-themed hideaway features creative cocktails & casual fare in a quirky, dimly lit interior.
SafeHouse
RestaurantsIl Ritrovo
RestaurantsMultitasking venue featuring a wood-fired Neapolitan pizzeria, wine bar, deli & Italian grocery.
Il Ritrovo
RestaurantsSaffron - Modern Indian Dining
RestaurantsElevated take on Indian staples, including tandoori fare, served in a stylish space with outdoor seats.
Saffron - Modern Indian Dining
RestaurantsScenic Bar & Restaurant
RestaurantsCasual eatery (with full bar) serving draft beer and battered fish, plus steak, chicken and seafood picks, and dessert.
Scenic Bar & Restaurant
RestaurantsTochi Ramen
RestaurantsModern space with a punk-rock vibe offering Japanese ramen soups, plus noodle & rice dishes.
Tochi Ramen
RestaurantsDave's Hot Chicken
RestaurantsFast-casual destination serving fried chicken, mac 'n' cheese, milkshakes and beer, plus a gluten-free menu.
Dave's Hot Chicken
RestaurantsIl Cervo
RestaurantsUpscale eatery specializing in Italian fare and cocktails served in a serene dining room.
Il Cervo
RestaurantsMo’s...A Place for Steaks
RestaurantsUpscale restaurant serving premium steaks, seafood & wine in sophisticated surroundings.
Mo’s...A Place for Steaks
RestaurantsTransfer Pizzeria Café
RestaurantsRelaxed cafe featuring 40-plus types of creative pizzas, wine & beer plus local art & live music.
Transfer Pizzeria Café
RestaurantsHarry's Diner
RestaurantsCasual, '50s-style restaurant serving breakfast, lunch and dinner options.
Harry's Diner
RestaurantsMarco's Pizza
RestaurantsCounter-serve chain serving up a menu of specialty or custom pizzas for takeout or delivery.
Marco's Pizza
RestaurantsStory Hill BKC
RestaurantsCasual, urban nook with seasonal American fare & weekend brunch, plus retail wines, beers & spirits.
Story Hill BKC
RestaurantsPhở Cali
RestaurantsCasual Vietnamese eatery with a big menu featuring pho and other noodle soups, plus vermicelli.
Phở Cali
RestaurantsPho Spot MKE
RestaurantsCozy restaurant inside 3rd St. Market Hall serving Vietnamese staples including pho and banh mi.
Pho Spot MKE
RestaurantsLa Merenda
RestaurantsColorful spot with an outdoor bar & a menu of globally inspired small plates, local beers & wine.
La Merenda
RestaurantsSmoke Shack
RestaurantsCozy spot serving slow-smoked barbecue meats & Southern-style sides in rustic environs.
Smoke Shack
RestaurantsJJ Fish & Chicken
RestaurantsLocal fast-food chain featuring fried chicken, fish & shrimp, plus wings, in a low-key setting.
JJ Fish & Chicken
RestaurantsCafé Corazón
RestaurantsColorful eatery serving locally sourced Mexican fare with many vegan options, plus margaritas.
Café Corazón
RestaurantsBraise Restaurant & Culinary School
RestaurantsLocally sourced New American fare, regional beers & global wines served in wood-accented digs.
Braise Restaurant & Culinary School
RestaurantsCarnevor | Milwaukee’s Premier Steakhouse
RestaurantsUpscale steakhouse serving classic fare & an extensive wine list in a dark, contemporary setting.
Carnevor | Milwaukee’s Premier Steakhouse
RestaurantsBack Street BBQ & Hot Pot
RestaurantsAll-you-can-eat featuring hot pots cooked at your table and Korean barbecue.
Back Street BBQ & Hot Pot
RestaurantsSantino's Little Italy
RestaurantsTraditional Neapolitan pizzas, plus pasta & drinks in a rustic setting with an 1890s Brooklyn vibe.
Santino's Little Italy
RestaurantsMilwaukee ChopHouse
RestaurantsClassic chophouse with white tablecloths & warm woods offering steaks, seafood & a big wine list.
Milwaukee ChopHouse
RestaurantsLa Carreta Mexican Restaurant
RestaurantsBurritos, fajitas, and other Mexican eats served in a relaxed environment with margaritas.
La Carreta Mexican Restaurant
RestaurantsSwingin' Door Exchange
RestaurantsThis cozy haunt with old-school, saloon-like decor serves cocktails & American comfort food.
Swingin' Door Exchange
RestaurantsSan Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana
RestaurantsRustic-chic eatery with an open kitchen serving wood-fired Neapolitan pizza, antipasti & more.
San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana
RestaurantsWho's on Third
RestaurantsChill sports pub with wings, cheese curds & other American eats, plus craft beers & weekend brunch.
Who's on Third
RestaurantsStella Van Buren
RestaurantsPosh Westin Hotel restaurant serving upscale Italian dishes, steaks & seafood, plus craft cocktails.
Stella Van Buren
RestaurantsArrosto Delicatessen
RestaurantsFocaccia, panini and roast beef sandwiches join tiramisu, salads, soups, bowls, chips and desserts at this deli.
Arrosto Delicatessen
RestaurantsCavas
RestaurantsLatin American dishes served in a compact, laid-back tapas restaurant with a riverside terrace.
Cavas
RestaurantsGoodkind
RestaurantsInventive seasonal cuisine & house cocktails in an easygoing tavern setting with outdoor seats.
Goodkind
RestaurantsPapa Johns Pizza
RestaurantsPizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts.
Papa Johns Pizza
RestaurantsXankia
RestaurantsPho noodle soups, banh mi sandwiches & other Vietnamese classics served in basic digs.
Xankia
RestaurantsBartolotta's Lake Park Bistro
RestaurantsQuaint bistro featuring upscale French fare, an extensive wine list & Lake Michigan views.
Bartolotta's Lake Park Bistro
RestaurantsLino Ristorante Italiano
RestaurantsCasual eatery with a patio & Sheboygan River views serving Italian seafood, pasta & meat dishes.
Lino Ristorante Italiano
RestaurantsIan's Pizza Milwaukee | Downtown
RestaurantsWisconsin-born chain known for its creative pizzas including its signature mac 'n' cheese pie.
Ian's Pizza Milwaukee | Downtown
RestaurantsToast Milwaukee
RestaurantsHip spot for American daytime eats with coffee, beer & Bloody Marys, plus seasonal outdoor seating.
Toast Milwaukee
RestaurantsSaint Bibiana
RestaurantsBurger, chicken sandwich eatery offering beer cheese, biscuits and gravy and cocktails, plus fried pickles.
Saint Bibiana
RestaurantsTenuta's Italian Restaurant
RestaurantsHomey eatery serving traditional Italian staples & wines by the glass in an old-school space.
Tenuta's Italian Restaurant
RestaurantsThe Chef's Table
RestaurantsRestored venue hosting events with food and wine, plus tours and demonstrations.
The Chef's Table
RestaurantsPapa Johns Pizza
RestaurantsPizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts.
Papa Johns Pizza
RestaurantsLocal Press Eatery
RestaurantsCasual eatery featuring burgers, fries, beer and sandwiches.
Local Press Eatery
RestaurantsHungry Sumo
RestaurantsTraditional & creative sushi, Japanese & Thai small plates, rice bowls & ramen in a modern space.
Hungry Sumo
RestaurantsWonderland
RestaurantsDiner with an eclectic vibe serving vegan and vegetarian alternatives to American classics, as well as brunch fare.
Wonderland
RestaurantsUncle Wolfie's Breakfast Tavern
RestaurantsWarm, family-owned spot featuring breakfast, lunch, coffee & cocktails plus a curated retail space.
Uncle Wolfie's Breakfast Tavern
RestaurantsNothing matched that. Know a spot we’re missing? Tell us →
Listed here?
You’ve earned the mark — get the BaseLocal’s Best badge for your site →. Want in? List your business →
New spots land in the newsletter first
Free, every morning — this list is what we've already told Sheboygan about.
One email a day. Unsubscribe anytime.