The best sporting goods shops in Sheboygan

2 places we’ve checked and would send a neighbor to. Open any one to read what we wrote about it.

2 places · newest first

Your business could be here.

Be at the top of Sheboygan's page when you're in Sheboygan's newsletter.

Put my business here

Local businesses pay to be shown here. A person checks every one.

American Science & Surplus (opens in a new tab)

6901 W Oklahoma Ave · Milwaukee

Whether you need a last-minute beaker, oddball robot parts, quirky garden gear, or a craft project that spirals into a weekend, American…

Checked Sep 12

Whether you need a last-minute beaker, oddball robot parts, quirky garden gear, or a craft project that spirals into a weekend, American Science & Surplus delivers the good kind of chaos. The Milwaukee shop is employee-owned, and the stock changes constantly, so every visit feels like discovery.

From the Milwaukee newsletter, September 18, 2026

Clear Water Outdoor (opens in a new tab)

250 N Water St · Milwaukee

Clear Water Outdoor is your Milwaukee plug for trail to lake gear, with trusted brands like Patagonia, Fjallraven, Chaco, and Smartwool…

Clear Water Outdoor is your Milwaukee plug for trail to lake gear, with trusted brands like Patagonia, Fjallraven, Chaco, and Smartwool plus kayak and SUP rentals that actually get you outside. Shopping for sandals and a day pack, or itching to paddle this week, they’ve got you covered.

From the Watertown newsletter, October 3, 2026

EOS Surf (opens in a new tab)

510 N 8th St

Family-owned EOS Surf covers Sheboygan’s board-sport needs with surfboards, paddleboards, wetsuits, apparel and footwear, plus lessons and…

Family-owned EOS Surf covers Sheboygan’s board-sport needs with surfboards, paddleboards, wetsuits, apparel and footwear, plus lessons and rentals for getting out on the water. Whether you’re dialing in your first board or just need a solid pair of shoes, it’s a local shop with plenty to explore.

From the Sheboygan County newsletter, November 9, 2026

MKE Outdoor Indoor Exchange (opens in a new tab)

3044 S Delaware Ave · Milwaukee

Used and new outdoor gear, clothing and footwear, with a consignment program.

Used and new outdoor gear, clothing and footwear, with a consignment program.

Dunham's Sports (opens in a new tab)

3506 Kohler Memorial Dr

Retail chain stocking equipment, clothing & footwear for sports, fitness & outdoor recreation.

Retail chain stocking equipment, clothing & footwear for sports, fitness & outdoor recreation.